Moderators: Varanus, FM Game Moderators
RockFire wrote:Arc, I am convinced because of my night results and what everyone's said. I kind of can't think of it any other way unless I decide I want to gamethrow.
And I can go back and check considering I guess this game is just us now and it's not like anyone else is going to
Arcthurus wrote:Oh fuck. Rock.
Jerme wrote:First of all: I slept peacefully.
@Arc, I did say earlier that I am away till Sunday, so I apologize my absense till then.
Regarding me being scum: Firstly, I suspected Lex d2, voted him pretty early after the wagon started and then went afk. I don't think scum!Jerme (or rather Maf!Jerme) would have done this, as the vote was one of the deciding ones to kill Lexiam, without being removeable. Secondly, I did softclaim something when I wanted alol Rb'ers on me d2. Thirdly, my vote on Poison was explained in previous posts: Lack fo activity (bad reason I know) and not starting with lynching Lex in the desire of gettign rid of the inactives. Since there were two targets, I wanted to receive an opinion of a confirmed townie as an option if the given lynchcandidates are correct and who they'd think is more scum. Since nobody counter claimed Escort, I suspect I could trust PoisonMaids claim of being the role.
I think I have to retract my townread on both Rick and Rock for a while...
If both Rick and Rock speak the truth, Poison is put on the Witch/NE spot, but judging by the not combated Escort spot, I am not sure if this is believeable.
The not killing action of the Mafia migth be done, as we townies are already at each others throats, which they don't desire to clear by killing. Thus they wait until they can easily gain majority. Or its the stored kill technique.
I do not know what the sinister presence does, but instead of a redirection, it could be a duplicator instead. Means that everything that happened to Met would also happen to someone else... But I don't think that Met would not claim having slept peacefully when he actually were roleblocked. Does a resultforwarded exist, which coudl causes the roleblocked notification of Met to be applied to Naru)?
Just to say: I am not a 4d-Chessmaster, Rock, to pick up something you've stated before. I appreciate the thought, but you are wrong on me being scum.
TurdPile wrote:In my opinion, the sinister presence is akin to "You have been transported". And I'd think this is a perfect optional ability for the Witch... I'm not sure why Rock is outright dismissing this. This type of ability would give Mafia too much power if they could transport AND kill (ie transport someone out of protection, and kill them). I just can't see that happening. I'm honestly surprised no one has said it is a transport yet, because it seems obvious to me that is precisely what happened (Poison RBs met, but Naru got transported with Met, hence Naru got the RB instead). It's either this, or it forces someone to take on the actions that occur to another player (see Tornado).
Arc, I'm just going to chalk up your thought on Rock being Witch as you being tired. As stated before, if Rick flips Town - Rock is next on the block, which really doesn't serve him any purpose to hardclaim JOAT at this point, especially if it proves false. The only scenario I can see Rock being witch is if he is playing us all hardcore, is actually a mad genius, and is bussing Mafia as Witch to secure himself a town role to be able to help mafia the rest of the game. Which, without communication, is extremely risky. If this is how it actually turns out, Rock deserves to win this game TBH. I'm willing to back Rock here though.
enderitem wrote:I will be holding my vote until Rick makes his appearance again and tells the truth. If he does not, I will be joining his lynch wagon. I have already lost enough whim for this game.TurdPile wrote:In my opinion, the sinister presence is akin to "You have been transported". And I'd think this is a perfect optional ability for the Witch... I'm not sure why Rock is outright dismissing this. This type of ability would give Mafia too much power if they could transport AND kill (ie transport someone out of protection, and kill them). I just can't see that happening. I'm honestly surprised no one has said it is a transport yet, because it seems obvious to me that is precisely what happened (Poison RBs met, but Naru got transported with Met, hence Naru got the RB instead). It's either this, or it forces someone to take on the actions that occur to another player (see Tornado).
Arc, I'm just going to chalk up your thought on Rock being Witch as you being tired. As stated before, if Rick flips Town - Rock is next on the block, which really doesn't serve him any purpose to hardclaim JOAT at this point, especially if it proves false. The only scenario I can see Rock being witch is if he is playing us all hardcore, is actually a mad genius, and is bussing Mafia as Witch to secure himself a town role to be able to help mafia the rest of the game. Which, without communication, is extremely risky. If this is how it actually turns out, Rock deserves to win this game TBH. I'm willing to back Rock here though.
Power discussions aren't going to get us anywhere, it IS the reason why we are so confused in the first place.
Rick is impossible as Mafia, bussing his own Mafia member while he already lost one makes no sense and nevermind the counterclaim for that. It is way too riskier than what you are congratulating Rock for and it doesn't make any sense. This situation is far more complicated at this point and only Rick can clear it up. He can only be the Witch either way and at this point, I am starting to not care about what he has to say. If we lose this game, I blame him and only him.
Arcthurus wrote:
Didn't you also say he couldn't be witch.
Arcthurus wrote:Is the lie his *check*? Or is the lie that he thinks the scum is Rock out of the pair (instead of Poison)?
Also to be fair this day has been mostly through the weekend and he did say several times he wouldnt be around during those.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 69 guests