Moderators: Varanus, FM Game Moderators
melanora wrote:Thoughts on which alignment would RB who?
Jerme wrote:I somehow suspect Metrion...
TrueGent wrote:I am done without a lynch
I also expect to live to tomorrow or something has gone seriously wrong
Schultz128 wrote:not only was gent n1'd
not only was gent the cop
gent the cop got fucking n1'd in a mod game
nerds
Guzame wrote:That's... An interesting choice for a night 1 kill. I assume they picked Gent because they were one of the least likely players to be protected tonight?
I'm looking at the death note, trying to think of who'd leave a message like that. It's got a surprising amount of personality to it, especially with a Lenny face of all things. It's not something I'd expect a lot of players to use. But then again, it could be done on purpose to make the more "memey" players look suspicious?
It's probably not worth it to pursue that line of thinking for now.
RockFire wrote:Welp, time to actually start and not be labeled crazy.
I slept peacefully and I find TrueGent to be an interesting person to pick as a N1 target. I assume the kill is by the mafia and the neutral is likely some sort of support for the mafia unless anyone says something pointing to the contrary. I guess if the Mafia had a 13 - 1 odds of him being an ally and took the risk? He was one of the more active players too which shows some gusto in the killing considering there were way more quiet players to pick.
On another note, the music is too happy about finding a corpse in a camp.
melanora wrote:Jerme wrote:yay I am able to wake up from my peaceful to see d2.
@Naru: I am sleepy too.
I do not see a sense in the DN...
I somehow suspect Metrion...
Do you suspect him because of the Gent kill?
I would suspect Met to kill Gent, but then we get into WIFOM, and until there's a pattern of actions, I can't say one way or the other how I feel.
enderitem wrote:I strongly disagree. What Swords said was that they were modifications of the standard roles so I don't think it is that off the rails if we look at Gent's role and I also believe Gent probably was right on track when it came to his D1 reads hence my advice to check D1. However, that is my gut talking here. It is also a matter of scarecrowing to make sure the possible Medium does not reveal. Nevertheless, you asking for evidence here isn't something I am really fond of to be perfectly honest.
Metrion wrote:Firstly there aren't going to be two escorts. There could also be a neutral that roleblocks theoretically or a prankster or something stupid. I'd say that Arckas is a scummier target to pick but he only posted like 6 times yesterday and the other target is TP so trying to determine alignments from a D1 that had next to no content is a waste of time. Just assume scum have a roleblocker for sure. I agree with Rock's wanting to avoid trying to meta-Swords, the man is clearly insane from playing instruments for too long.
He is definitely an oddball when you look at D1 conversation he had with Gent and just him overall but in my eyes there is someone looking as bad as him, maybe even worse. I think Gent's reads will be probably our lynch targets for today if they do not fix their appearance. I kinda want to watch these two dome as well so there is also that.Metrion wrote:enderitem wrote:I strongly disagree. What Swords said was that they were modifications of the standard roles so I don't think it is that off the rails if we look at Gent's role and I also believe Gent probably was right on track when it came to his D1 reads hence my advice to check D1. However, that is my gut talking here. It is also a matter of scarecrowing to make sure the possible Medium does not reveal. Nevertheless, you asking for evidence here isn't something I am really fond of to be perfectly honest.
So you think Lexiam is scum then.
RockFire wrote:Ender, saying things you think without any logical basis is like chucking a hail mary and hoping for the best. Nothing points to or against your theory really besides gut which is why I was asking what basis you had for that since nothing supports that. Evidence can be quotes you believe point to things but I've seen nothing that supported your ideas and you already said they're just feelings which really don't do much in Mafia ever in my experience.
And Met, I assume the Neutral is a mafia ally in an 18 player game unless proven otherwise because I doubt we have another killing role around if only one person died considering the odds are usually against protectives N1 and 18 players with two killing factions means we can only make two mistakes lynch wise if all kills go off before we losing which is pretty harsh to Town.
enderitem wrote:Metrion wrote:Firstly there aren't going to be two escorts. There could also be a neutral that roleblocks theoretically or a prankster or something stupid. I'd say that Arckas is a scummier target to pick but he only posted like 6 times yesterday and the other target is TP so trying to determine alignments from a D1 that had next to no content is a waste of time. Just assume scum have a roleblocker for sure. I agree with Rock's wanting to avoid trying to meta-Swords, the man is clearly insane from playing instruments for too long.
I actually never thought of the Prankster possibility. Both Mafia & Town did gain new roles while I was gone after all. I need to check this out.He is definitely an oddball when you look at D1 conversation he had with Gent and just him overall but in my eyes there is someone looking as bad as him, maybe even worse. I think Gent's reads will be probably our lynch targets for today if they do not fix their appearance. I kinda want to watch these two dome as well so there is also that.Metrion wrote:enderitem wrote:I strongly disagree. What Swords said was that they were modifications of the standard roles so I don't think it is that off the rails if we look at Gent's role and I also believe Gent probably was right on track when it came to his D1 reads hence my advice to check D1. However, that is my gut talking here. It is also a matter of scarecrowing to make sure the possible Medium does not reveal. Nevertheless, you asking for evidence here isn't something I am really fond of to be perfectly honest.
So you think Lexiam is scum then.
RockFire wrote:Also, Ender I'm curious about why you find the Lexiam - Gent interaction odd since all I see is Lexiam asking why Gent thinks he's scum. That seems like a very small interaction to have some basis on it and that's not even considering the possible kill motivation of framing him. As for everything else, looking at Gent's ISO he only scum read Lexiam which means either scenario is plausible really unless you get something out of it that I don't see.
Met, fair enough really. I'm also curious as to what Ender is on about too really since the whole point of having scum reads is to state your opinions to the rest of the game for possible lynches.
Metrion wrote:Stop the pronoun game, thx.
Why aren't you voting Lex or the mystery person?
Arcthurus wrote:Without beating around the bush, he seems to be talking about either guzame/m4x (cant see anyone else gent mentioned)
I cant see anything of note on their d1 tbh, the former had an intro and the latter had memes
Alzar wrote:there is no such thing as a meta, forum mafia is a lie, we are products of a confused society
Alzar wrote:there is no such thing as a meta, forum mafia is a lie, we are products of a confused society
enderitem wrote: It is made obvious from the start that Gent's posts aren't just memes so he should be able to tell that Gent really didn't like his entrance at all from the way he said he would lynch him if he could. In my eyes, a noob Townie would definitely be more curious about the reason why such a harsh judgment was made because, you know, they wouldn't to get mislynched in the future. Learning why would definitely help them in the future.
melanora wrote:Thoughts on which alignment would RB who?
Naru2008 wrote:Could also be two Consorts, if we are going to give possible outcomes.
There's also the possibility someone is lying about being roleblocked.
Veeena wrote:How are we so sure that there is a rhyme or reason towards the attack of Gent other than the basic reason that he is not indeed mafia? His posts seem to be on par with how he would usually play and even with the one major post of him about death, the rest seems just run of the mill enough.
Lexiam I have no opinion on until he speaks more. The first day doesn't portray anyone well enough when the majority seems to be of memes and reminiscing times.
ObiWan wrote:Mela seems iffy to me too.
As a note: I’m trying not to hold back what I initially feel this game because I did in Enders game when I should’ve pushed more people and it was bad. I felt Mela was a bit scummy in Enders game from the start and didn’t push it and that was a mistake. (Mela don’t be triggered)
I will dive into more of the Mela train tomorrow, too lazy right now
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 200 guests