Share your game stories! [Post Game Stories Here]

[takenname21]

This happened a few days ago (or yesterday) in a Ranked (not Coven) game,

I got bodyguard, I vested N2 as I thought mafias will try to kill me and they did. The day after, people tried to vote me but failed (during that I kept silent because I don't want mafia to know that I was Bodyguard vested N2 and the Neutral Killing role already died). I got jailed right after and told Jailor everything (He didn't trust me that much but he's good enough not to click the execute button). The day after (or 2 days after), a Doctor was killed by the Mafia with a death note "The witch won't stop controlling me" (or something like that). Then, I immediately got a whisper "Screw You". It immediately go to my mind that the whisperer is Godfather and I said to everyone that he is GF and thought I was witch (Since there's a witch and witch has night immunity on the first attack). That day (if I'm correct), we lynched the third mafia (not the GF though because no one trusted me at that point and I didn't claim my role publicly yet because there was a doc). That night, I got jailed to check if mafia kills that night. And guess what, mafia didn't attack and the witch made jailor execute me. The next day, they got the GF lynched and Town won.

This may not be 100% correct but this is all that I remembered.

[dyaomaster]

Game 1: I'm Godfather. N1, SK and BG kill each other, and transporter swaps Mafioso into our kill target. Sheriff finds Framer. D2: We're fucked.
Game 2: I'm Vigilante. N1: Mafia clean and kill, SK kills. D2: Doctor decides to play Jester and acts as scummy as possible and is of course lynched. N2: Mafia kill, clean, SK kills Townie. D3: Another townie decides to suicide on the stand, and Escort decides to play super scummy and fluff talk all day N3: We lose majority
Game 3: I'm Forger. N1: I'm jailed, claim Lookout D2: Mafia attacked SK. SK kills LO. Sheriff, 2 spies, invest reveal and confirm themselves by getting SK lynched. Consort suicides. N2: We kill another TI who didn't claim on accident D3: Town lynches the unconfirmed Spy who went second N3: I'm executed by Jailor

Yay so fair

[deathofrats0808]

Ouch. That sucks.

[Villagerlover]

All Any
I am a veteran and I don't go on alert night 1.



"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You have died!"

*End of game*



*Serial Killer wins*



*Looks at end lobby.
1 Veteran.
14 Serial Killers.





Never playin' there again.

[qwertyuiopl]

All Any
I am a veteran and I don't go on alert night 1.



"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You have died!"

*End of game*



*Serial Killer wins*



*Looks at end lobby.
1 Veteran.
14 Serial Killers.





Never playin' there again.

Please tell me this isn't an actual thing that actually happened.

[polypies73]

All Any
I am a veteran and I don't go on alert night 1.



"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You have died!"

*End of game



*Serial Killer wins*




*Looks at end lobby.
1 Veteran.
14 Serial Killers.





Never playin' there again.

Please tell me this isn't an actual thing that actually happened.

Well you can;t have more than six of a role...
So i would say no.
Unless it changes in all any for some reason.

[Shilster]

All Any
I am a veteran and I don't go on alert night 1.



"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You have died!"

*End of game*



*Serial Killer wins*



*Looks at end lobby.
1 Veteran.
14 Serial Killers.





Never playin' there again.

You smell that?

Smells like bullshit

[Shilster]

If only we had a thread just for posting game stories

Lol, it's totally not alt accounts. nope.

[alex1234321]

I agree that leavers really annoying. They could drastically change a team's likelihood of winning. Fortunately, the Trial System tries to weed them out along with other unpleasant players.

[alex1234321]

I have had this happen to me many times. Generally if someone keeps doing this, especially if it is over multiple days, the best thing you could do is ignore them. By reacting you are only fueling the fire. And if you feel like a person is harassing you, then feel free to report them. If they did not leave, then you should just hope that a second person would see this and report them too. Usually, there will be someone like Townie 3 who would defend you.

[Leharn]

How Much Salt was the Sherrif eating?

[Leharn]

So I was mayor and I was like on day one. "I'm Mayor TP on Whisper me roles I'm not vet baiting"

D2 I was like " Whisper me roles" Some guy is like, "Then reveal your very sus." I revealed and he was sus. We got him hung and he was consig. On Voting there was someone like "Guilty?" In My mind, he was evil for that. The person we hung was consig :O.

Day 3: I asked a person's role who said "guilty?" And he said doctor, which I found BS. SO we hung him and the person was SO salty, he was "the mayor is metagaming report him now, he was SK.

[Kimedis]

https://prnt.sc/heegck

All any game. So far most riddiculous game for me. Was there even chance for town to win this?

[Villagerlover]

All Any
I am a veteran and I don't go on alert night 1.



"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You were stabbed by a Serial Killer!"
"You have died!"

*End of game



*Serial Killer wins*




*Looks at end lobby.
1 Veteran.
14 Serial Killers.





Never playin' there again.

Please tell me this isn't an actual thing that actually happened.

Well you can;t have more than six of a role...
So i would say no.
Unless it changes in all any for some reason.

This was a long while ago. But it's stuck with me as the biggest reason to not play all any.
(This is back in the day when the Mafia could have 6 Mafia members....)

[Villagerlover]

Look, the fact that the sheriff expected to have any form of hope in All Any was enough for me to agree with whatever you had to say.

[MafiaMenace]

Not the place to put it, but nice scum-reading.

[mydownfall]

The worst game I have played, was in all any and I was mafioso... No other mafia and there was no NK and there ended up being 14 town... That was a terrable game
The best game I have played, I was vet and alerted N1 killed sheriff and announced D2 I was vet and was allerting tonight I alerted and killed the doc. D3 I said I alerted but really I didn't and made a huge vet bait ( I said something like I got over my parranoyer or Sommer) and N4... I alerted and killed 6 people the sherrif GF consort SK another doc and a arson

Game instantly ended with town win...

[qwertyuiopl]

Just now in all any
I named myself mitochondria
I got jailor.
At first I didn't realize it, but when I did it was one of the happiest moments of my life.

[UzayAltay]

Ranked role list

Final : Jailor ( with executions ) , Invest , Vet , SK , GF ( me ) , Mafioso .

Vet was confirmed at this point . We votes up Invest , because of there is 3 Investigator At Graveyard , and nobody thinks there is 4 Invest possible ( There was no disguiser , really 4 Invest cames ) . When we votes up Invest , A person asked me role at whisper . I guess he is Jailor ( because why a SK ask me role ? ) , I need some time , If jailor Jails me , we can't win this ( unless town Lynch SK in a 1v1v1 . So I took the risk , and claimed Mayor in whisper . He ask me to Reveal in whisper , and I answer with "Now ? " He answer yes , at last second , and day Ends ( Invest lynched 4-1 )
Jailor Jails SK and executed Hım , when we kill Hım .
Than We Lynch Veteran and win this .
#AlwaysFakeClaimMayor

Sad thing is I hope to Climb Gold ELO with this win , but I stay on Silver Elo , 1399

[Shilster]

2 Sheriff games where I lost and 1 Spy game + 1 Sheriff game I won in a row

[Gregreat]

Coven mode, Ranked rolelist, rolled Potion Master. So...name your poison! Hah! That never gets old...

Spoiler: D1, RC are myself and Hex Master. Beautiful.
N1, CL selects to control Malygos into gazing Medusa. Heart the HM is jailed and I investigate Lady, who comes up as Vig. Beautiful.

D2, no deaths. Malygos must not visit... Buddy the Elf claims Psychic and lists myself, Malygos, and PunnyBunny as possible evils. I whisper a Doc claim to Buddy, saying that I don't want to publicly claim it but that I can heal him, and Malygos says nothing. NE? PunnyBunny, on the other hand, starts reminding everyone that there can be MULTIPLE evils in Psychic's visions...but never claims a role, so he goes up on the stand. He indignantly claims Escort, and says that he didn't block N1. Town is very suspicious of this, but some are saying to inno so that he can confirm. He ends up getting guiltied 2-1, and flips...Arsonist. Damn, that's surprising. Town congratulates Psychic as the day ends.
N2, I kind of promised that I would stay on Buddy, since he was confirmed Psychic, so I use my heal on him while CL takes my advice and controls Vig into James Russel, one of the guilty votes on Arso. CL also takes the opportunity to notify us that Malygos was Jester. I get transported to another location.

D3, James Russel the Transporter is dead to Vigilante. Lady promptly claims controlled as Town begins to criticize Vig. Pirate whispers me to ask my role, and I say that I won't share because he's not confirmed Town (still playing the angle of wanting to stay unknown as TP). Someone asks who was controlled N1, and of course Jester isn't going to claim it, so Town now becomes suspicious of Heart, who was jailed N1. Heart claims Sheriff, and the claim buys enough time to escape the lynch.
N3, CL can kill now, so they select to control Psychic to kill him. I tell them not to, since I've claimed to be healing Buddy. They end up controlling Sexy Girl into Medusa, since Sexy Girl was the first to accuse Heart of being CL (and may very well be Jailor). I'm so focused on keeping Psychic alive that I forget to kill.

D4, Sexy Girl is dead to Medusa and CL, and Lady is dead of guilt. Sexy Man says Sexy Girl was Sheriff, and was checking Buddy when they died. Buddy reclaims Psychic who found Arso, and claims to have been in jail N3, which would mean he literally can't be Medusa, but also means he got no N3 vision. Town complains that Jailor blocked Psychic, and no trial.
N4, CL confirms that Sexy Girl was Sheriff, which is very helpful for HM (since they claimed it). They witch Viridian and I kill Pirate.

D5, Pirate the Tracker is dead to Potion Master, and Viridian the Jailor is dead to CL. Jailor's will says that Bust a Stinky was jailed N4, and also claimed Psychic. I accuse him of being Medusa since Medusa didn't stone N4 (even though Jailor can't be controlled into stoning, Town somewhat buys this) and CL claims Invest, outing Malygos as Jest/HM. I add on that he is most likely HM, and we push Jester up. He claims BG and offers no will, and I CC TP, claiming Doc on Buddy (Tracker's will has me visiting Buddy N2, which is why he asked me my role). Jester gets guiltied 5-0, with CL and Medusa guiltying for some reason (did they forget that we all knew he was Jester?). As the day ends, I tell Jester to haunt Bust a Stinky, claiming that he is likely Medusa.
N5, CL selects to kill Buddy, as HM informs us that they have all but him hexed. I investigate Sexy Man, since he abstained on Jester, and he comes up Spy.

D6, Coven are the only ones standing. Horn Solo the BG and Sexy Man the Spy are dead to Final Hex, Bust a Stinky the Psychic is dead to Jester and Final Hex, and Buddy the Elf the Psychic is dead to CL. Coven wins in a clean sweep.

Tl;dr Coven performs their duties to the letter.

[Joacgroso]

So I just wasted an executioner scroll in classic because my target left in day 2... along with 4 other players. There was also a spammer who left later.
I was attacked in night 1 and by day 3 it was down to 7 players left: 3 maf, 3 townies and me. I claimed that town had already lost so we should lynch a random guy to end the game faster. I voted a random player (who ended up being mafia), and I was put on trial with 3 votes against the other guy. I said "GG. Report the leavers" and the random guy said "INNO THIS HE IS A JESTER!!", so they innoed me 0-2. Ugh. Then the fcking maf killed me at night! Also the jailor executed the veteran, who was really salty in the dead chat. Then mafia lynched the jailor and won in day 4.
Winning as jester in classic is really hard, since evils always kill you at night and town is too passive to vote anyone. Also, no matter what you do, there will always be someone saying "he is jester!". What should I have done in order to win that? I was pretty much screwed since maf already knew I was jester (they had attacked me in night 1 and sk was dead).

Screenshot here:
Spoiler:

PS: Genocider Syo was the serial killer, lmao

[Joacgroso]

So I decided to play a ranked practice game and rolled godfather despite my scrolls. The most boring mafia role since I already played a lot as gf in classic. This game was awful because of the cheaters.
There was a medium who acted like a jester in order to get lynched. At first town ignored him, but he was lynched later. But the worst part was that the vigi and the mafioso were either cheating or were the same person. The vigi shot the consig in night 2, the framer in night 3, and me in night 4 (of course I didn't die). And don't say that he scumread us, because everyone but the jester was quiet in the town. Then a lookout saw the mafioso killing our target and the vigi accused me of being immune. The mafioso didn't even claim, while I claimed lookout. They voted me up anyway, which lead me to believe that the vigi and the mafioso weren't the only multiaccounts. I admit I didn't defend myself too hard because I knew I was going to be lynched anyway. And they lynched me.
During the next night the mafioso killed another guy, so it was down to the ww, the mafioso, a medium and the vigi without bullets. They inmediately lynched the ww, who didn't even defend himself. We knew who the medium was because of the consig, so the mafioso only had to kill him in order to win. He selected him... but changed his mind during the last seconds. By this point, everyone knew he was maf because of the lookout, but they couldn't lynch him because the vigi wasn't voting. The mafioso didn't kill the next night either, but said that since his dead mafia partner was being racist, he would let himself be lynched (I was the only mafia who talked, and I only said that they were obviously cheating. The gamethrowing medium replied "who tf cares?". Then the vigi and the med lynched the mafioso despite we had a secured win.
I reported both of them and the gamethrowing medium, but I'm pretty sure no one else did it. Ugh. Maybe I should play ranked games to be safer from toxic players.

[polypies73]

So I decided to play a ranked practice game and rolled godfather despite my scrolls. The most boring mafia role since I already played a lot as gf in classic. This game was awful because of the cheaters.
There was a medium who acted like a jester in order to get lynched. At first town ignored him, but he was lynched later. But the worst part was that the vigi and the mafioso were either cheating or were the same person. The vigi shot the consig in night 2, the framer in night 3, and me in night 4 (of course I didn't die). And don't say that he scumread us, because everyone but the jester was quiet in the town. Then a lookout saw the mafioso killing our target and the vigi accused me of being immune. The mafioso didn't even claim, while I claimed lookout. They voted me up anyway, which lead me to believe that the vigi and the mafioso weren't the only multiaccounts. I admit I didn't defend myself too hard because I knew I was going to be lynched anyway. And they lynched me.
During the next night the mafioso killed another guy, so it was down to the ww, the mafioso, a medium and the vigi without bullets. They inmediately lynched the ww, who didn't even defend himself. We knew who the medium was because of the consig, so the mafioso only had to kill him in order to win. He selected him... but changed his mind during the last seconds. By this point, everyone knew he was maf because of the lookout, but they couldn't lynch him because the vigi wasn't voting. The mafioso didn't kill the next night either, but said that since his dead mafia partner was being racist, he would let himself be lynched (I was the only mafia who talked, and I only said that they were obviously cheating. The gamethrowing medium replied "who tf cares?". Then the vigi and the med lynched the mafioso despite we had a secured win.
I reported both of them and the gamethrowing medium, but I'm pretty sure no one else did it. Ugh. Maybe I should play ranked games to be safer from toxic players.

Ranked is slightly better.
But...
Not taht much better

[Gregreat]

VIP mode, rolled Mayor. Already doing better than Trump...

Spoiler: D1, VIP is Ikaros. He promptly says "crus on vip", which I think means that he's claiming Crusader.
N1, Mayor doesn't do anything at night, silly.

D2, Teo the Trapper has left the game, as has Misy the Psychic. Some people ask if Psychic leaving is reportable. Ikaros claims second Trapper and asks who the Crusader is, saying that he'll trap them. Light claims Crusader, so that's three TPs accounted for. Thanatos asks slash summon his role, and slash summon seems reluctant to claim, so I start a vote on him (I'm fully expecting CL to try and kill me, which will waste a night). Moshi Moshi questions the vote as the day ends before slash can be put up.
N2, What a surprise, I get witched.

Moshi Moshi the Potion Master is dead to Vigilante, and Communist Cat the Pirate is dead to Crusader. His will says he plundered Ikaros, so now Coven knows who VIP is. The GA has protected Chara, and God claims GA as I reveal. I press slash summon for a claim, and he claims Doc, the last TP slot. He says he healed Thanatos, and Thanatos confirms, claiming Sheriff in the process. No lynch.
N3, Going back over the claims, I realize that all Town roles have been claimed with the exception of Vig and Tracker. Time to start forcing claims tomorrow.

D4, Elsa the Necromancer is dead to Vig, Jason Finch has been stoned by Medusa, and Thanatos has been drained by CL and stoned by Medusa. If only TS were Medium... Oh well, I reason that Jason is Tracker, since he can only be Vig or Tracker and Vig shot Necromancer instead of Medusa. Reminding everyone that Thanatos was Sheriff, there are only three people who have yet to claim; Anna, Aaron, and Chara. I ask Aaron his role, and he promptly claims Vig, which means that Chara and Anna are the confirmed Coven. Chara wasn't protected by GA today, so I push the vote on them to keep GA from protecting them tomorrow and wasting a day. Chara claims Medusa on the stand, and says that since Vig has been outed, CL will control them tonight. Light starts yelling to inno and hang Anna, but I advocate the guilty vote on the grounds that GA will protect Chara if we don't hang them today. Chara is guiltied, and flips CL (She tried to buy a night by screwing over Medusa. Savage...). God is upset that he is now Survivor, as Anna says she will stone God for failing to protect Chara.
N4, I calmly wait for the end of the night, knowing that victory is assured.

D5, Anna the Medusa is dead to Vig and Crusader. Town wins. ...She did actually try to stone the confirmed Survivor, and Crus went off the VIP to get her.

Tl;dr Claiming is never a bad thing.