Fenraiser wrote:TheParanoidAndroid wrote:Fenraiser wrote:My reads list for this current D1:
Have fun. Also, don't take my reads personally.
Spoiler: Living Player List:
1) Stri: Seems level-headed. Asks questions, tries to push discussion forward. Noted that the someone sheep votes were weird. Does not involve himself emotionally in his posts. Calls people out for stuff boldly. Not as much posts as some others, but they are usually with much content. Passes eazy townread on murat for meta.
TOWNLEAN
[town: Mystic, murat, TPA]
[scum: James, awesome, TTR]
2) S0me0ne23: Strange initial vote on Elb. Notes of an Elb pocket attempt on under. Reads explanation is brief. Asks for player input often, and seems to try to advance the game or get more info from other players. Voted TPA after under.
TOWNLEAN
3) awesome5000: "Fuck you" reaction from Gent's post. Draws a non-heated exchange with teammystic? Says he does that a lot to his voters. Votes someone. Strangely noted that mdb was acting differently, saying mdb is more active and implying with his phrasing that mdb might be PR because of this. Other than that, his other posts were memes or minor things.
Reactions seem sort of, sort of genuine. I think someone seems more Town though.
NULL to TOWNLEAN
[TownTPA, Mystic, Elb]
[Scum:ames, xUltiix, someone else idk]
4) xUltiix: Annoyed at understood, but I do not sense much emotional distress like with Mystic or TPA but Xulti did not participate much in the argument. Claims that he will vig under. When under scumread him, xulti asked for possible scumbuddies that under suspects, an odd question in itself, although he explained that it will help the town more...somewhat ldd
NULL to SCUMLEAN
[town: GENT (feels town + contribution)/FENRAISER (gut town)/MYSTIC]
[scum: JAMES/AWESOME (has done pretty much nothing except talk about previous games and make jokes)/+1]
5) JamesD28: Eager to meme during meme phase. Initially voted (maybe sheeped) someone out of the blue with no explamation. Says he wanted vote in before EOD just in case he did not come back in time. Gives IRL reasons for this. Suspects Elb more than someone from his gut. Hardclaims Cit. Seem somewhat genuine. It could be a good excuse for scum, but it could be a good excuse for town as well. He clearly seems frustrated when mystic misinterprets/oversimplifies his intentions/motivations. A hint of desperation and exasperation I smell.
NULL
[Understood, TPA] (adapted)
[Someone, Elb] (adapted)
6) ChikolyOffensive: Questions Gent's reads. Meme phase claims wanted rand scum to make up for past scum games. A lot of the few posts seem partly mememy, but most of those were from the beginning.
NULL
7) CatgirlMaple
Prodded for inactivity. Others say cat canratscumhunt,need more info cuz most posts are nya enough to get a solid read.
NULL.
8) TheParanoidAndroid
Deliberately baited Understood for a reaction very hard for a reaction test. Although, he did not specify it until much later. After things spiraled out of control, salt was developed between him and under. Seemed genuinely frustrated and tired at under, and both risked getting smited by Santa for being naughty. Emotions seem genuine.
TOWNLEAN
[Elbmuh, Gent, TM]
[[James, Someone, TTR] is how im feeling rn]
9) TrueGent: Implies chikoly's post was scummy. Believes James explanation is shit. Thinks someonewagon is shit. Usually posts are short and memes, but some are very sharp. Do not know if I'm being buddied or the observation is legitimate. IDK. Also passes townread on murat cuz meta. But, True says his apathy varies between different games regardless of faction.
NULL.
[murat fenraiser stri]
[james elbmuh +1]
10) TeamMystic:
Seems town-motivated. Calls out people and what they say, namely awesome's reaction to Truegent's vote and james' sheep vote. Sometimes seems to slightly oversimplify and misconstrue the words of others though, although her thought process is clear. Very active. Seemed genuinely frustrated with understood. Uses votes for pressure. Puts a lot of pressure on people she suspects.
STRONG TOWNLEAN (I had my doubts but I skimmed over her ISO and changed my mind).
(Gent)
(TPA, Schultz) +Stri (adapted)
(murat, Fenraiser, Time, mdb, understood, S0me, Chikoly)
(Ulti, awesome, Elbmuh)
(James)
11) murat19967: Lots of memes in the beginning in his ISO. He strays away from memes as time goes on. A good number of his posts seems like he's either agreeing with what someone has said or just giving a minor response, although he does give out posts that stand alone. He has been given a townread for now, but something seems off, not from him but gent and stri who townread him. Is it such a big part of his meta? I'm wondering.
NULL to SCUMLEAN
12) UNDERSTOOD12345
Tunneling hard on TPA it seems. Seems town-motivated but idk. He is genuinely frustrated as well with the results of the Lie Incident. Did not know it was a reaction test until much later, and his interactions with mystic weren't so sweet either. His focus of voting changes, and he is not afraid to put his vote out and is very persistent. Voted Truegent.....Elb did so as well. There was also the scumteam claims that were never followed up. Also, he refers to hjs meta often, especially in the case where he scumread very successfully.
NULL (Maybe scum but idk)
13) Fenraiser: Townlock Like My Limerick
14) Schultz128: Seemed to get irritated with under's questioning as he started spamming "are you scum" 3 times, and asking this imo would not advance the game at all (salt so prob NAI). His reads seem good though, and he does have his analytical posts.
NULL.
[Someone, awesome, Chikoky: 50/50.] Please tell if I did not label right.
[Mdb, reap, murat: Shitters.]
15) Elbmuh: Teacher-Pupil interaction with understood, although he voted understood after getying irritated/pissed with him. Votes someone with TPA. In his interaction with understood, Elb had made it clear that he is town, and that under is also town, and he usually references past games and experiences to back up his credibility (although he does admit this), although it does seem like he is trying to get understood under his wing to teach, but I am doubtful. His tone seemed to be happy at teaching understood, but at it also seemed like he was almost gloating, or at least showing off (he states that he used self-meta for towncred) Was teaching or towncred the reason he was reaching out to understood? Thinks murat wagon is bad. Also votes Truegent.
GUT SCUMLEAN, NULL OTHERWISE
16) mdb1023: Reaction voted early on from Elb vote. A "fuck you" reaction vote towards Understood. Wants to PL TPA or Understood, although he prefers to PL Understood as TPA is more experienced. But flips when other game ends and he finds out under scumread the whole mafia. Very busy irl.
NULL.
17) TimeToReap: Voted TPA after lie incident. Probably meming as he reaction voted me in a non-hostile way soon afterwards. Votes elb for sheep behavior. After, he votes someone. Not enough posts.
NULL.
I like this post, effort is A+
These are rough reads, so they are probably not very good, but I'm getting somewhere and it is a good summary.
/vote murat
question? Why did u choose to vote me over ur other reads?
Cuz I need good understanding as to why u think this.