Moderators: Varanus, FM Game Moderators
alouvre wrote:i disagree with 90% of your list it seems and found it hard to take seriously after you said persian was easily townread, samuel's posts were logical, and ryan was ignoring mel's points. i'll go read nfm 24 but lol. for what it's worth i remember ladd acting like this in dfm. but idt you were there. idk. cant be assed to check the others, i want to see what ladd has on kirize first.
SamuelJackson1972 wrote:Sheriff: James2 is NS
Investigator: Yauaustin202 is Cit/Godfather
Lookout: Harkonnen97 was visited by no one.
PersianRugs wrote:Not-SK list(includes dead ppl)
1.PersianRugs
2.ChamAlien
3.PurpleSidewalk1
4.Melanora
5.James2
6.JammySplodge's slot
7.Kirize12
8.Zero
9.SamuelJackson1972
10.ryanyb
As you can see, half of the game is already eliminated from being SK. There are 16 alive. 10 suspects of sk left.
OK, it looks like the GF probably did the killing. James2 was mafioso doing roleblocks with the consort and hitting the SK is likely.
How many ppl are left to check in?
@Truegent Also, can u please update the graveyard and add the ISOs for the replacements. That would be great
PersianRugs wrote:Slept peacefully.
When I saw "baby go boom" I thought we lynched the bomber -_-
alouvre wrote:what was that directed towards?
Because I could see myself having the same reaction in a parallel world.
alouvre wrote:you can still behave naturally and be scummy. look at the exchange samuel and i had about omgus and you explain to me how that's logical or even townie. and that doesn't breach the other problems I have with him concerning pushing his reads and actually taking a stance on them.
i still disagree with your view of persian's meta, but k. from your quotes it sounds like you want to townread him against anything else. weird.
alouvre wrote:i know it was supposed to be a follow up, but what made you feel like you needed to say it?
alouvre wrote:i don't think you're reading my posts lof. as i said, class soon, but meta is legit and i already said like two times i didnt like N only giving elaborations when he's prompted. i had to check if he was someone who did that naturally or someone who doesnt usually do that. and from what i can tell he doesnt.
npromin1 wrote:alouvre wrote:i don't think you're reading my posts lof. as i said, class soon, but meta is legit and i already said like two times i didnt like N only giving elaborations when he's prompted. i had to check if he was someone who did that naturally or someone who doesnt usually do that. and from what i can tell he doesnt.
K, I'll elaborate. Read NFM 20 Mafia Chat. Though I lost, I'm quite proud of this chat.
ladd wrote:There is no point looking for scum in the lynch wagon, when there was really no other option besides nolynch and everyone town player with a brain would have voted Mel, unless they had a really strong town read on them especially since they claimed Citizen. Seeing why there were no other options would be a much better work but the answer is pretty easy and I don't really think it helps that much, everyone was inactive the two most vocal people were strongly scumreading Mel so the lynch went that way.
ladd wrote:Yeah, whatever, this game is slow anyway so we may as well get this out of the way.
I want Kirize to claim.
Possibly Milte slot as well, but that has nothing to do with my role.
alouvre wrote:Kirize and Thukk0 were roleblocked N1.
was responding to your line in your forgoten read LoF. you haven't had a real presence in the thread until now and never followed through with your read on mel until it was too late. don't really feel like arguing whether drunkposting excuses it but it's funny how you're only presenting one side of situation when the two or so people that were against the lynch were just saying "i have a bad feeling, i think this is a bad idea" without ever actually defending her or explaining why.
ladd i'm waiting.
alouvre wrote:Q: are you omgusing!!!
A: yes.
I meant that your post seems to imply that you think they're [melanora is] omgusing.
alouvre wrote:nullscum might as well be a scumread dude. if you're gonna give an alignment stick to it, you can't say he's nullSCUM and expect others to treat it like a regular ol' nullread. and no, i'm going to continue making "insanely low effort posts" because this is how i want to play, sorry if it bothers you.
LordofFail wrote:forgot3n1, i would like to see a full reads list from you with town, null or scum next to each name. None of this nullscum or nulltown wishy washy nonsense. Either you have a townread or a scumread on a player (or a nullread, but there really shouldn't be too many of those by D3)
LordofFail wrote:forgot3n1, im not saying that you abandon the differences, im saying that by D3 you should not have so many people in the null category. Yes some people are going to be null, but there should not be as many nullreads as you have. I'm not saying you have to commit to a townread or a scumread but I would like more definitive opinions on who you think is town and scum.
TheForgot3n1 wrote:Why are you voting ladd over alouvre or Persian?
alouvre wrote:i don't know what you're saying in your first post. he said "that omgus though" right before he voted mel. never answered what the hell he was referring to, my post he mentioned isn't an acceptable answer. it was not in any way phrased to look like he wanted me to see it. put it right under some stuff he said directly to mel then moved on to james.
viewtopic.php?f=17&t=52772&p=1749113#p1749113
and may i point out he made this post later.
viewtopic.php?f=17&t=52772&p=1749984#p1749984
first post phrased like he was actually scumreading mel. second post lifted that off of her for no reason. never specified which scummier people he meant despite me asking. and if you read the other posts in the omgus exchange it's obvious he's evading giving a clear answer.
there is no fucking way his reaction was townie. my initial question ("how was it omgus if she (mel) scumread hark before he or I did?") both implied i thought he was accusing mel of omgusing and presented a very clear question. his answer? quoting a post of mel's that directly supported that mel wasn't omgusing and asked me if i was drunk. and the conversation only gets more confusing from there. he knew exactly wha he was doing. there's no other explanation dude. i'm pretty sure my questions were clear. and then he ends the argument by claiming he was doing a reaction test lol. yeah fucking right.
nullscum might as well be a scumread dude. if you're gonna give an alignment stick to it, you can't say he's nullSCUM and expect others to treat it like a regular ol' nullread. and no, i'm going to continue making "insanely low effort posts" because this is how i want to play, sorry if it bothers you.
you didn't want to be townread and now you seem concerned about. nobody wants to lynch you. seems like you were just getting uncomfortable with the amount of suspicion on you.
what things should we be questioning? be more specific.
pedit ok N, I'll do that.
alouvre wrote:you didn't want to be townread and now you seem concerned about. nobody wants to lynch you. seems like you were just getting uncomfortable with the amount of suspicion on you.
TheForgot3n1 wrote:A nullscum is someone you would prefer to lynch over a null. Use common sense, it's someone I think is more scummy, than a nullread, such as Lexiam.LordofFail wrote:forgot3n1, im not saying that you abandon the differences, im saying that by D3 you should not have so many people in the null category. Yes some people are going to be null, but there should not be as many nullreads as you have. I'm not saying you have to commit to a townread or a scumread but I would like more definitive opinions on who you think is town and scum.
Okay. You can consider every nullscum to be a weaker form of scumlean. Let's say, slight scumlean. I am not sure enough to say scumlean, since that implies personally believing in like a 30-40% chance-ish ofbeing scum, which I don't for Persian to be honest. Maybe for alouvre that chance is actually quite accurate.
Now, LoF, I find your stance on nolynching quite interesting, I haven't seriously considered nolynching when you truly don't believe in your vote. Anyway,
Why are you voting ladd over alouvre or Persian?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest