Share your game stories! [Post Game Stories Here]

[doyouknowanah]

I haven't been playing this game for too long, but the other night this happened:

It was almost the end of the game; there were few people left standing. Someone started saying I was the sk, so I had to reveal myself as the mayor so I didn't get lynched. Someone else was lynched instead, and so three people were still alive: the sk, a townie and me. Much to my surprise, sk must have forgotten I had revealed because at night he killed the other townie instead. So during daytime, sk had three votes against him (all mine) and I had only one. That was enough to send him to trial and then to be voted guilty by me. So I won as mayor ... although I ended up being the mayor of an empty town

The worst (although quite funny) game happened just a few minutes ago. It was a custom game, and there were 15 "Any" roles (I was mayor once again)
During Night 1, one of the players leaves the game, so the next morning we see that he is the only one dead, and that he had committed suicide.
He was mafia. Immediatly, a different music starts playing and a sign shows up saying "Town wins"...
14 of us were Townies

[Angrel]

just finished a game.
in the beginning the first guy to choose a name chose Jesus.
a bunch of people after that chose similarly biblical names, including me.(The Devil, God, and my name, Lucifer)
the game starts and I get my job and just start laughing.
after the first night, enough people decide they don't like playing with the prince of lies and lynch me.
they lynched their only doctor.
after the second night, it turned out that God was sick of playing and Killed himself, committing one of the worst sins out there.
later in the game, I'm contacted by the medium.
I decide to try and bye his soul.
he then informs me that he is the devil, and the only townie left.
the next night, he is killed by the mafia, and his identity is stolen.
Jesus was the one to steal the Devil's name.

[LordofFail]

Best game:
This is my first day of playing, ive been playing nonstop for about 6 hours now, and its 2 in the morning.
I am a Veteran, I killed Sheriff and Framer on same night with an alert, wasted a second alert, and had nerves of steel not to use any more alerts.
Day 12: 3 people left, me, Godfather and a Random Town.
Another user says that he is quiet because it is 6AM for him and he is really tired.
So we lynch the the other person, and he was a Medium.
Night 13: I got on alert and kill GF
For 2AM and first day of playing, it was ridiculous.


Another good game: Filled with anys i think.
4 people left, I am Arso, 3 days go by without anyone dying and I have 2 of the other 3 people doused.
I am debating whether or not to douse the final person, but I instead decide to kill my doused targets
Morning comes, and I see I got an achievement
"There can be only one"
-Burn GF and SK in same night.
Turns out the other 3 people were all night immune; one was the GF the other two were both SKs.
I won because Arso beats SK in a tie.

Another really good game:
-I was Transporter
From the third of fourth night onward, I was attacked almost every night, but survived by transporting myself with other people.
Town won by measure of me transporting myself with all the mafia and lynching the GF.


Worst game(s): Whenever I get a good role and die first night.

[SailorNeptune]

Best Game EVER! And I mean EVER!

I got SK (Serial Killer) for the second time in Classic Version.
Almost for the Entire Time, I was trying to figure out what to put in my Death Note.
While communicating with the other players. And my name was (Ohmwrecker) and there was another person there named (Minxling)
So one by one the Townie drops by the Mafia's hands. There is seven of us left. 5 townies and Gf and SK.
I finally figure out a Death Note "You've Been GODSMACKED!"
Sheriff who finally spoke told them to kill me cause he said I was Maf. (He got Lynched)
I killed Minxling, who healed me from the GF attack.
And I won. From almost absolutely doing nothing. They were so sure that Minx was bad, even the GF was convinced. That they absolutely forgot about the Serial Killer cause they thought I was AFK. Best Game Ever.
Spoiler:
(The Maf killed three people. I killed DetectiveL and Minx and won.) xD

[Deawyn]

Ragequits + Smart people + DC = fast win
Spoiler:

[SailorNeptune]

Sorry I'm up here again. It's just that. I get into so many games I just think this one deserves to be in the Worst of the Worst of Games.
-
I was SK again and the Jailor jailed me because my name is Minxiemoo. I ended up killing him and I wasn't even planning on it. So the town ends up Lynching almost everyone that's Immune while in their notes say who the GF is. So during the entire game. The mafia was still there and everybody else was just killing off the townies. The GF even said throughout the entire game that he was the GF and they still didn't kill him. And that's how the Mafia won the game over the Arsonist, The SK and The Witch. Baka Townies. We may have been bad, but at least we told you who the GF was.

[Veeena]

worst game ever?

it was an all any-s game. i'm thinking oh goody this'll be chaotic and fun.
i roll a mafioso. i'm thinking alright good good good. i can do this.
we come up to shake hands-
and i'm the ONLY MAFIA.
in the end, it turned out everyone was a townie except for two amnesiacs {turned townie} and a witch. possibly some survivors.
i killed about 7 people before they figured out it was me.
i think that qualifies under 'worst game ever'.

In an all 'any' game, I was a sheriff versus 9 mafia members, 2 jesters, an sk, escort, and amnesiac.
Needless to say I was lynched as i found one of them out the next day.

[SailorNeptune]

O.o ohkay that's even worse, considering that the mafia can speak to each other and know who the other is. there's no decieving the mafia.
that's still my worst game ever as a mafia, from a purely game standpoint.

The Mafia can still rat out the other Mafia's in their will. So I guess that's deceiving and rude.

[Rickdaily12]

NEW WORST GAME EVER.

I was Jester. I'm in classic, and I think, "well, time to falsely accuse someone!"

So the second day, I openly declare Sheriff, and shout down a random townie as a Discovered Mafia. Town threatens to lynch Me if I'm wrong. We lynch the townie. But in his will, he quickly jots "X is GF, Y is Framer." Meanwhile, I think "holy shit, I'm actually right!" He was the disguiser!

So in Night 2, I sign a true last will about what just happened. I get attacked by the SK. I LIVE. Doctor healed me.

Day 3, X openly claims to be the GF, but I don't buy it. (What mafia claims to be the real GF?) So I remind the town of the existence of a Framer, and the possibility of two Jesters. Then, I accuse a different person of being Mafia AGAIN ON the basis of Sheriff. The real Sheriff demands to know of how I could be a Sheriff, and I shrug him off by reminding him about the Random Town spot. SK rage leaves, and we lynch the random townie whose name ISN'T Y. And, Lo and Behold, the totally baseless accusation against all presented evidence led me to lynch the FRAMER. The town enters an uproar. Everyone thinks I'm the best sheriff in the world.

The third night, I openly cry into my last will. GF has had enough of me and finally kills me.

Day 4, everyone alive AND dead sees I'm a Jester. Everyone is stunned. And I'm still crying.


IT WAS TERRIBLE LUCK I SWEAR xD xD xD

[AidanUK]

I have just come out of a very interesting game where the game ended with a "Jester Wins" message!!! Never seen that one before. He was killed in the penultimate round. In the last round, he killed 1 player and the other player killed the other player, so nobody was left alive.

[Makrell]

I played a game that ended in draw.
was an al any game, started good and slow, havn gsome mislynches and stuff. I was arson, but saw i was doused in gas, realised we were two arsons, were 8 players left and i lit myself on fire.

NOONE WON

Spoiler:

[Sligneris]

[LordofFail]

Had an epic game yesterday

I was vet, and I hate dying first night, so I went on alert.
Lo an behold, it was a waste, and I was thinking, 'great start, only 2 left'

An night 3, I get blackmailed, and someone says that i am being very quiet. I put in my will that he is probably mafia.

Day goes by, I dont get lynched, and I figure that knowing good mafia strategies, either I am going to get blackmailed again or someone will attack me (there were 3 Mafia, A SK and An Arso, but the Arso got lynched on the 4th day).

Turns out that everything went better than expected, Mafia attacked me and I killed the GF.

I reveal that I am vet and was blackmailed on the third day.

No lynches on day 5

On the 6th day, we lynch the Mafioso, and there are only 3 people left, SK, me and Investigator.

At this points we all knew who was what, it was just a question of who the SK would attack.
I had 1 alert left, although I was claiming to have used it 2 nights prior.

I decided not to go on alert, and it paid off, the SK killed the Investigator.

I told him GG, and went on alert that night.

I killed the SK - one of the most tense games I have ever played.

I killed GF and SK as vet.

This was in a game of 7 town (no randoms), 3 mafia (GF and 2 randoms), Witch, Survivor, Amnesiac, SK and Arso.
Witch died on the first night, Amnesiac was killed by SK on night 3, Arso was lynched on day 4, Survivor was killed on night 2.

(Once I did the same as Jailor, winning the game for townies)

[LordofFail]

Just had a really interesting game.

Bunch of people left, 8 deaths on first night, I was SK.

Only 4 people left now, Jester is killing one of them from the grave.

Witch controls me and makes me attack myself. I live because im night immune.

Witch rats me out and I get lynched.

Ugh. I hate it when people dont read the rolecards, or play with the sole intent of going against when their role would normally do.
(which in this case would be to defend me and win the game, as witch only wins if town loses.)

[Veeena]

holy hell that is funny. That's happened to me too in the early versions of the game.

[Sligneris]

It was just an user who named themselves "you", but I like how well it fit with the situation. xD

[SailorNeptune]

I can't use Lilac anymore. Doesn't matter if I'm good or bad. I always get killed ;c in Customs first. Because someone's assumption just HAD to be right. /Cry.

[testaccount1234]

There were four of us left (doctor, jailer, some mafia role, godfather). I was doctor and the jailer & I knew who the remaining mafia are. The only problem was that half of the remaining town were mafia so we couldn't get a vote majority. So, at the next night, the jailer jailed the godfather while i wastefully used my self-heal. Skip to the next day and no-one got killed (Jailer jailed the Godfather). Jailer asks me during the day on whenever I still have my self-heal and I said I still had mine (even though I didn't). The jailer told me to use my self-heal while he executed the other mafia member. Well, I ended up healing the Jailer and the Godfather ended up quitting.

[AidanUK]

I just had my 1st experience of being Disguiser, and was all excited about it...then got lynched on the 1st round!

[SailorNeptune]

Strangest Game EVER
There was a disguiser and towards the end the disguiser ended up being dead. But let's role back a bit. So Faerie ends up dying, then I die. And my name is Xena. And then my (Anime Character) dies and we're in purgatory talking with our names mixed around. It's so weird. But yeah.
--------
Best Game as Witch.
I found the Vig and made her kill two Maf and a Townie. Found Maf and made him kill the last remaining people except there was a transporter and yer. I died :/

[Deawyn]

i can't believe this just happened.

I just finished a game, I was sk. Someone called my role on day 3 (yeah his pseudo was someone) and I don't know if it was either my answer "yup i'm sk" nor the massive random accusation in the chat that led to my victory in the end.
Town was petty much screwed from the beginning anyway (all the invest roles were gone by day 2).
In the end we're down to 4 people (medium, vet, gf and me); luckily for me i knew who the gf was (tried to kill him last night) and for once (yup we triple killed somone with the jester) we coordinated the murders

[Indigo1]

This happened yesterday. At the start of the round, I got the role of the serial killer (first time being one), and I bet that I was going to die in three days.
I actually managed to survive for quite a long time, when there were only 5 of us left: me, a retributionist, an executioner, a godfather and somebody else (can't remember). That day, the people decided to hang me, so I panicked (I'm not great on lying on the spot xD), and I said "I'm retributionist, not that it matters anymore". I said that, because the retri already resurrected somebody. For some reason there was a tie in the votes, and I lived, they couldn't accuse me anymore that day.
Next day, two people died: the retri, and the "somebody", so now it was down to me, a gf and an exe. The exe didn't want to lynch anybody, and left us to kill each other, she/he'd win with everybody anyway. Of course, we couldn't kill the other, because both roles are immune at night, so next day, we were still stuck.
Then the exe suddenly suggested that we hang the godfather. And we did.
I seriously didn't expect to win there, I've never been sk before xD

[AidanUK]

Just come out of a game where the mafia left death notes warning they would kill the first person who spoke or whispered. They succeeded in keeping everyone quiet for a while, though the effect didn't last permanently. A clever trick, though...

[Drake]

Have you ever played with 6 Mafia, an Arson, a SK, and the rest be town, and WIN as town?

I did yesterday

[Mrwarp22]

best game ever 1 mafia (me) 14 town mafia won !