I just got out of a game where I was Godfather and we happened to hit anno the arsonist. He got up on the stand and guiltied off because there were spies that caught him. Then, because mafioso hit the arso, arsonist knows who mafioso is because they doused them. So when up on the stand, arsonist said "X is mafioso. They hit me and I doused them". Next night, mafioso got executed by Jailor.
The dilemma in banning/not allowing it, is that you remove strategy. You can pretend to be salty on the stand and get a LO hung that "report 8. He's framer and outted me for no reason". Whether or not that works is in question. Another example is last mafia outting the Arso when last maf gets hung. Mafia has no way of winning but arso does, but arso gets outted by maf anyways because either arso voted mafia up or got them killed.
I'm not really looking for a definitive answer to this. Just everyone's opinion on this matter. Should it be allowed? Should it be banned? Is it harmful or toxic to the game's community (since people reghunt for this stuff). Share!