1. Jailor is too powerful.
It's supposed to be. I actually enjoy having an all-powerful town member which can easily confirm and the role fits well into the game.
I propose the Jailor not being able to jail N1. In classic role lists, people will be less worried about jailing SK n1 (and SK will be less triggered if jailor calls tplo and is jailed N1) while it could allow for interesting fakeclaim jailor potential for evils if they really wish to take a high risk high reward gamble. Then it increases evil's KPN on the first night which is especially important in ranked, even though it will be a small amount, it often feels doomed if you hit the jailed target.
The above change will cause the "dont jail consecutive nights same person" nerf to be no longer needed.
Criticism to this change: Not enough.
My response: Again, jailor meant to be powerful. Just a very simple minor nerf.
2. Boring roles such as...
a. Mafioso and Godfather
I proposed TMK but I don't think it's a good idea after some thought.
I propose buffing both roles.
First, make Mafioso much more exciting. Allow Mafioso to choose an Astral Visit up to two nights, at the least.
Make Godfather slightly more exciting too. Possibly add roleblock immunity.
b. Medium
This role is really situational and can be extremely boring when town is ahead. There's already so many proposed changes to Medium so I'm not going to propose anything here besides looking at the Medium thread.
Town Support is supposed to be the more powerful roles, Medium is one of the weakest. There's clear need for a change.
c. Retributionist
Really boring when town is ahead, situational, and OP when town is behind.
I like the mechanic mentioned here for the most part and I propose we leave it the way it is.
d. Framer, Disguiser
Framer:
Make frames permanent. Just increases the chaos a tad bit more.
Disguiser:
Sorry I don't understand this role. Simplify it -- target maf, they will no longer appear sus and their visits will not be seen by spy.
Yes I actually do understand it fine but it's just so complicated that newbies will not understand it. I'll be referencing the above simplification --
So now combine the two roles and call it Framer.
e. Sheriff
Next to Medium on the most useless roles.
Just underpowered at this point but can be impactful. I suggest allowing Sheriff to check two targets a night.
They will either find both innocent or at least one suspicious. Those are the only two results this theoretical Sheriff would yield.
3. Unnecessary roles are overpowered.
a. Transporter
I'm fine with this role since it's supposed to be a powerful role. However I would suggest limited transports.