Arcanist(Neutral Killing)

[Ozyrox]

lol why me xD

well in my opinion, making the Arcanist immune to the bg would be abit too OP. Like the WW, you should just have it that the doc can't protect them but the bg can. Or maybe you should do it reverse, because the doctor can't heal someone attacked by a ww, vampire (i think) or revealed mayor. Seems abit unfair to the doc.

You can change the lore by saying that the boy asked the transporter before asking the doctor and that the doctor agreed to heal the town member but was jailed, so he couldn't do that. He explains this to the arcanist that the jailor interogated him on his way to his moms house and he was the only one who comforted him in the morning and everyone ignored him. Then when he ran in the woods to practice the arts he practiced attacks to counter the bodyguard and/or transporter for ignoring him but not the doctor.

Thats just a suggestion if you wanna flip it around to bg doesn't kill him but he can't kill healed target. It also makes the doctor more important in the game because the bg just straight up kills the killer while the doc only heals the person

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

lol why me xD

well in my opinion, making the Arcanist immune to the bg would be abit too OP. Like the WW, you should just have it that the doc can't protect them but the bg can. Or maybe you should do it reverse, because the doctor can't heal someone attacked by a ww, vampire (i think) or revealed mayor. Seems abit unfair to the doc.

You can change the lore by saying that the boy asked the transporter before asking the doctor and that the doctor agreed to heal the town member but was jailed, so he couldn't do that. He explains this to the arcanist that the jailor interogated him on his way to his moms house and he was the only one who comforted him in the morning and everyone ignored him. Then when he ran in the woods to practice the arts he practiced attacks to counter the bodyguard and/or transporter for ignoring him but not the doctor.

Thats just a suggestion if you wanna flip it around to bg doesn't kill him but he can't kill healed target. It also makes the doctor more important in the game because the bg just straight up kills the killer while the doc only heals the person

So BG imoonity and doc immoonity? I lyk dat.

[tdh99]

My last post up above, I don't remember posting that, I might have been really sleeping, either way, I think it should be able to be protected from both Doctor and Bodyguard, but the Bodyguard can't kill it, can only protect, I apologize if I am repeating an already stated idea, I just wanted to share my thoughts on the subject.

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

My last post up above, I don't remember posting that, I might have been really sleeping, either way, I think it should be able to be protected from both Doctor and Bodyguard, but the Bodyguard can't kill it, can only protect, I apologize if I am repeating an already stated idea, I just wanted to share my thoughts on the subject.

I was thinking Partial Doctor Immunity and Partial BG immunity. The mass trauma is unblockable, but the basic attack is stopped both ways.

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

Nobody else wants to contribute? *sigh*

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

New Poll and Changed Attributes! Check it out!

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

Nobody likes this anymore.....*sniff*

[mrbones45]

It is a very interesting role
But i am confused?
So does he kill the killers of the victim or just the visitors?
Well any way if it killed the killers then all killing roles would not kill as often giving town a boost
But if it only kills visitors that gives mafia a HUGE BUFF

[murat1996]

Wait, isn't this somewhat similar to my SW? And I said somewhat, so I need an answer Chubby!

If it isn't, just take me the similarities xD

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

It is a very interesting role
But i am confused?
So does he kill the killers of the victim or just the visitors?
Well any way if it killed the killers then all killing roles would not kill as often giving town a boost
But if it only kills visitors that gives mafia a HUGE BUFF

Both, since killers had to have visited the house.

Killers don't die, otherwise RIP mafia Night 6. But then how does it fight off mafia? Easy, it has a basic attack(next to living players) that will kill that player. I know I probably just lost your support, but just as clarification.

Wait, isn't this somewhat similar to my SW? And I said somewhat, so I need an answer Chubby!

If it isn't, just take me the similarities xD

I don't know what to answer to that, but it kills all visitors(Player 1 , Player 2 visit Player 5, Player 3 kills) to a dead person, thus killing 1 & 2 but not 3(cuz killer). It also has a standard attack to take out mafia. So I don't know how this is similar but you are the Role Idea God so I'll take your word for it.

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

I don't know what to answer to that, but it kills all visitors(Player 1 , Player 2 visit Player 5, Player 3 kills) to a dead person, thus killing 1 & 2 but not 3(cuz killer). It also has a standard attack to take out mafia. So I don't know how this is similar but you are the Role Idea God so I'll take your word for it.
That would be me. :p

I never knew about the forums when you made Electrician, so I only knew about Shadowalker. But here is the crown, Neco(cat in Japanese).

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

I don't know what to answer to that, but it kills all visitors(Player 1 , Player 2 visit Player 5, Player 3 kills) to a dead person, thus killing 1 & 2 but not 3(cuz killer). It also has a standard attack to take out mafia. So I don't know how this is similar but you are the Role Idea God so I'll take your word for it.
That would be me. :p

I never knew about the forums when you made Electrician, so I only knew about Shadowalker. But here is the crown, Neco(cat in Japanese).

Well Electrician died for a while, so there's that.
Also it's spelled Neko, with a K.

Thank you!


EDIT: If you are voting no, please EXPLAIN WHY(WTF!?!?!?!? HE IS ASKING FOR US TO GIVE FEEDBACK!? HE IS A JERK) I NEED TO FANBOY OVER JUSTIN BEIBER! is what everyone who voted No and didn't explain is thinking now.

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

Suggestion: On regular nights, allow them to attack like an SK. On full moon nights, allow them to target a dead person and force everyone who once visited to commit suicide (can be healed by Doctor and Jailor, but cuts through immunity and BG's). If you killed 2-3 people or more, you can't use a regular attack the next night.

That seems like a good idea. I'll put it in the OP tomorrow cuz right now I'm really tired. I wanna see if people like this idea, but I'll probably add it in anyways.

[K1llthestory]

Suggestion: On regular nights, allow them to attack like an SK. On full moon nights, allow them to target themselves and force anyone and everyone who visited a dead person to commit suicide (can be healed by Doctor and Jailor, but cuts through immunity and BG's). If you killed 3 people or more, you can't use a regular attack the next night.

The new edition. Use this one, not the other, lame, shitty one.

Why are you so mean and toxic

[kookeekwisp]

This role has 4 pages of comments, yet you feel the need to make people read your idea. Lots of people already saw it, and frankly, it's a really bad concept.

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

This role has 4 pages of comments, yet you feel the need to make people read your idea. Lots of people already saw it, and frankly, it's a really bad concept.

And a lot of other people like the concept. Your point?

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

If any who likes this(only me) wants to submit this to the Testing Grounds can, I give my permission(though I know it will be denied 100%)

[Ozyrox]

No I said they should either be bg immune or doc immune, not both lol

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

No I said they should either be bg immune or doc immune, not both lol

So just full immunity to one and not partial for both?

[Ozyrox]

No I said they should either be bg immune or doc immune, not both lol

So just full immunity to one and not partial for both?

Yeah and u should add a reason for this in your lore. Look at my previous post

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

No I said they should either be bg immune or doc immune, not both lol

So just full immunity to one and not partial for both?

Yeah and u should add a reason for this in your lore. Look at my previous post

Got it. I can do it tomorrow. . I got stupid Odyssey Project Research Flower Hunting stuff.

[Ozyrox]

Lol I'm not gonna ask. Also u don't have to listen to me exactly, it's ur role, and I'm just giving u suggestions u can choose whether he/she is immune to bg or doc

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

Lol I'm not gonna ask. Also u don't have to listen to me exactly, it's ur role, and I'm just giving u suggestions u can choose whether he/she is immune to bg or doc

Nothing is immune to BG(shadowwalker is but is partial) and it would be a cool-ish concept-ish that I like.

[Ozyrox]

Suggestion: On regular nights, allow them to attack like an SK. On full moon nights, allow them to target themselves and force anyone and everyone who visited a dead person to commit suicide (can be healed by Doctor and Jailor, but cuts through immunity and BG's). If you killed 3 people or more, you can't use a regular attack the next night.

You could have edited this in ur other post but nah lol. I don't think we should do that because the Arcanist would basically make the serial killer pointless. I mean this role is already similar to the WW and adding this extra feature would make it more OP

[ChubbyMooshroom9]

Suggestion: On regular nights, allow them to attack like an SK. On full moon nights, allow them to target themselves and force anyone and everyone who visited a dead person to commit suicide (can be healed by Doctor and Jailor, but cuts through immunity and BG's). If you killed 3 people or more, you can't use a regular attack the next night.

You could have edited this in ur other post but nah lol. I don't think we should do that because the Arcanist would basically make the serial killer pointless. I mean this role is already similar to the WW and adding this extra feature would make it more OP

Yeah. Pretty much this.