TG Role/Concept Poll | Voting

[superdog551]

/Vote Blacksmith
/Vote Neutral Subalignment Rearrangement

[Benn3]

/vote Historian

[sunbird1002]

/vote Historian + Neutral Realignment
(Both blacksmith and historian are testable. I just think we havent had a Town Investigative role in a while.)

[Brilliand]

In my opinion, when there's a tie for 4th place, you should fail all of the roles involved in the tie, and just have 3 test roles that month.

Historian and Blacksmith are both roles that I like and previously voted for. Neutral Subalignment Rearrangment strikes me as a null choice that would not have any effect even if it did get voted in, so it might work as a stand-in for my "choose nothing" proposal. As a result, I'm OK with all of the choices, but I should probably pick something, so...

/vote Blacksmith by alex1234321

There's already another TP role in this month's test (Duelist), and after some thought, it's probably more important to compare similar roles with each other than to have a variety of roles under test.

[sunbird1002]

Well if it is more important to test similar roles, I will change my post.

/Unvote historian
/Vote Blacksmith

[alex1234321]

The tiebreaker vote has ended! Here are the final results:

Blacksmith by alex1234321 7 (me, anonymous, pumpkin, runningwiththepower, superdog, brilliand, sunbird)
Historian by alex1234321 5 (me, pumpkin, cob, runningwiththepower, benn3)
Neutral Subalignment Rearrangement by Ezradekezra (option B) 5 (royee, pumpkin, ezra, superdog, sunbird)

Blacksmith wins and will be tested this month! Historian and NSR will automatically be placed into the next role poll. You will have until July 15 to make submissions.

[cob709]

what roles are being tested this month? can you put them all in one post and link it in OP? it makes it easier to check the winners for each month

[alex1234321]

Roles that will be tested this month:

Blacksmith by alex1234321
Duelist by sunbird1002
Associate by superdog551
Confounder by Ezradekezra

[alex1234321]

I'm going to second the Disguiser Rework. I think it might be weak, but it is a versatile role and can effectively counter Jailor meta.

[runningwiththepower]

I nominate:

Vessel by Cabohh viewtopic.php?f=27&t=116810
Engineer by Blasterus viewtopic.php?f=27&t=116957&p=3599432&hilit=engineer#p3599432
Agent by Dum viewtopic.php?f=27&t=116541
Expatriate by Ezra viewtopic.php?f=27&t=111412
Decoy by Cob viewtopic.php?f=27&t=109710
Bouncer by Widget viewtopic.php?f=27&t=116348&view=viewpoll


And I second:

Charmer

[Ezradekezra]

/second Expatriate

[Blasterus]

I second Engineer

[runningwiththepower]

I also nominate Night Hag

viewtopic.php?f=27&t=117257&p=3600827#p3600827

[Brilliand]

I'll nominate Gossip. (That topic has no replies because most of the discussion happened in another topic.)

[runningwiththepower]

I second Gossip

I nominate Soldier viewtopic.php?f=27&t=117268

[Cavespider17]

/Second Bouncer
/Second Engineer

[alex1234321]

I'm going to second Agent. It may seem a little weak, but it is much stronger than either Framer or Disguiser so I think it's worth a test.

I nominate Devil.

[Cabohhh]

I'll be seconding Vessel, by me. I didn't submit the role, so it's ethical (?)

[Benn3]

/second Soldier
because apparently you can if somebody else nominated it

[Ezradekezra]

/second Devil

[alex1234321]

You ARE allowed to second your own roles. The point of the seconding system is to make sure that all roles in the poll have a realistic chance at making the TG. As long as two people want a role to be added, it doesn't matter which order they come in.

[Ezradekezra]

If a role got nope'd in the result poll but I've made changes to it since it was tested can I re-nominate it?

[alex1234321]

If a role got nope'd in the result poll but I've made changes to it since it was tested can I re-nominate it?

Yes, but it has to go through the same process as any other role.

A role that gets more edits or more testing gets to be tested without having to go through the poll or anything.
Not that we've exactly been testing those roles very much

[Ezradekezra]

I had some changes that I wanted make to Copycat and Kleptomaniac but I don't remember whether I actually edited the posts or not so I'll re-nominate them later

Edit - Forgot Klepto was still in the results poll

[Benn3]

/second Sandman

Although it's essentially just a Coven Blackmailer it seems kind of interesting, I think it should have the chance to be voted on at least.