Moderators: Varanus, FM Game Moderators
SamuelJackson1972 wrote:As I said again, I was trying to see if you'd point out your own contradiction, which turned out to just be misinterpretation on my part.
alouvre wrote:that still doesn't make sense to me, but okay, let's move past that. what do you think is mel's alignment and why did you unvote her?
melanora wrote:ryanyb wrote:Oh shit I just noticed something. Mel, you're hardcore scum-reading alouvre's slot, then you make this comment:melanora wrote:Actually I find this hilarious because normally you're really good at scum hunting so you're going to feel like a dumbass when you see I'm Town. I'll excuse you because you just replaced in, but seriously, dumb.
What changed your mind. Apparently you think he's town now or you wouldn't make this comment.
In case any of you forgot, there is such a thing as Serial Killer. IMO I think that Alouvre is Mafia, and is pushing on me because he thinks that I'm Neutral, possibly the SK, which is how I have steam rolled the game in the past. Therefore, Alouvre will feel like a fucking idiot for pushing to kill me because I'm actually not the SK that the Mafia are looking for.SamuelJackson1972 wrote:I mean, you're being voted by multiple people with two days left and you don't even refute their reasoning.
What reasoning? There was literally no reasoning to any of the votes. That's the point.LordofFail wrote:Holy fuck this sheep wagon on Mel though
Even semi-drunk lof knows this is a fucking terrible idea lol
Honestly LoF this whole game you and I are on the same level of agreement. It really bothers me.James2 wrote:I'm not sure why we're lynching Melanora. What reason is there to think she's scum.
Literally this.
Also I called Hark scum LONG before Hark called me scum. So...
Please keep trying.
alouvre wrote:understandable, I just meant we can't say much else about you when you haven't responded to what we have already said.SamuelJackson1972 wrote:As I said again, I was trying to see if you'd point out your own contradiction, which turned out to just be misinterpretation on my part.
that still doesn't make sense to me, but okay, let's move past that. what do you think is mel's alignment and why did you unvote her?
SamuelJackson1972 wrote:alouvre wrote:understandable, I just meant we can't say much else about you when you haven't responded to what we have already said.SamuelJackson1972 wrote:As I said again, I was trying to see if you'd point out your own contradiction, which turned out to just be misinterpretation on my part.
that still doesn't make sense to me, but okay, let's move past that. what do you think is mel's alignment and why did you unvote her?
I think Melanora is at most neutral scum, and even then I doubt that.
You see, there have been plenty of people flying under the radar that are more likely to be scum then them.
Now I'm not saying that the lynch is bad, I'm just saying that scum wouldn't want to be in the spotlight most of the time.
SamuelJackson1972 wrote:I think Melanora is at most neutral scum, and even then I doubt that.
You see, there have been plenty of people flying under the radar that are more likely to be scum then them.
Now I'm not saying that the lynch is bad, I'm just saying that scum wouldn't want to be in the spotlight most of the time.
ryanyb wrote:alouvre wrote:that still doesn't make sense to me, but okay, let's move past that. what do you think is mel's alignment and why did you unvote her?
That reminds me I never explained why I say neutral (and she could be mafia but im leaning neutral).
She's been playing this game so incredibly safe, only giving reads on those that are accusing her of being scum. She's intentionally neglecting to offer up opinions on most players, and made a point on day one to not be helpful in the slightest, which bled over into day two. It just feels like she's way too hesitant right. That's why I put her as witch after D1, and why I still continue to see her as likely witch/bomber/sk. She's been trying to appeal to everyone except those who are currently voting her. Doesn't feel indicative of mafia since by this point in the game they should have some game plan (right?) and all she's seem to do thus far is try to stop herself from getting hung.
alouvre wrote:ok james
alouvre wrote:what do you want to do
alouvre wrote:yeah but which 7:20pm? his own? or did y'all standardize a timezone?
and, npr, can you elaborate on why you thought mel's "vote and somewhat tunnelling on hark" is scummy, as well as what specifically about her attitude towards misa pinged you off?
melanora wrote:
Okay so throw back to this real quick. I think that Cham was actually the intended N1 kill. The whole, saying that you can redirect mafia on who to kill, it's like baiting the Mafia, saying that we can control them. And note how Hark replies. He's like... how?! And then even points out that this is the kid's second game, given how we don't kill new people N1.
Kirize mentions that Cham is an odd choice, and Hark is immediately like, stop chit chatting and hypoclaim. He doesn't give a shit about the Mafia Kill, just wants claims from people.
And then, look at the bit with Lexiam at the start of D2. Hark immediately asks if Lexiam was trying to kill someone else, and was witched onto Cham. Um... that's odd? So you go from only wanting hypoclaims and ignoring other people talking about the Mafia kill, and then suddenly Lexiam is there claiming witched, and you now have an opinion on the Mafia kill? That's weird.
Why did it take you so long to form an opinion on the Mafia kill? Why do you just autoassume that the Mafia kill was someone not intended? Were you just waiting to see who was witched to claim that they were redirected onto the new kid? Yeah... total scum move.
/vote Hark
melanora wrote:ryanyb wrote:Welcome Mel, glad you're here now.
Any counter-response to my response?
I'm always here, just rarely replying because, you know, life.
Not quite yet. We'll see.Harkonnen97 wrote:town!mela isn't what u would call the pinnacle of "pro-townyness" so
Because it used to get me lynched D2 because people said I was TOO town OR I would die N1 to scum. It got boring after a while. I stopped being super pro-town when I was literally unable to play for more than the few days before I was dead.Kirize12 wrote:wasn't mela like Town leader in 7r
And this is why I die regularly. Yes. And I was the SK.
You should fear me if I'm super pro-town tbh. Because then I'm probably not town.
and Hark... go read 7R. Honestly, you say there is no such thing as Town Leader well that just shows how new you are.
Amazing so Misa has been prodded. Excellent. Everyone ready to verbally abuse their replacement with demands for answers that can't be given? Fabulous. Or, would you all like to go ahead and mislynch right now so we don't have to wait for a replacement?
Again, Misa has rolled Mafia before and what did they do? They were super active, super scum hunter, and pretty good until caught by Mass Claim. Lurking like this is not Misa's scum meta. Let's move forward.
melanora wrote:Lexiam wrote:idk why a witch chose to control me, but it makes sense since i am pretty scummy on my other games and i have a rep for it. i do choose my words poorly, but let me defend myself. since there were no other witching ccing me, we can assume that i am not at least a witch. that doesn't clear me of being mafia or any neutrals. Then again it doesn't clear me of being witch since the witch might of chose not to control that night and claim witched. but since thats not my playstyle, its unlikely that.
its true that Misa hasn't been contributing much. /vote Misa
more votes on them will make them talk more. but dont hammer
This is literally the worst logic are you kidding me? Voting for someone this much particularly without much actual reasoning attached to the actual votes { I don't give a shit if you wrote a sonnet elsewhere about why someone is scum - include it in your vote post or gtfo } will more or less make someone just completely ghost. Then we'll get a replacement that everyone will harrass to answer for Misa' inactivity, and it will be fucking pointless.
Breathe. There is five, now four, days. Misa will either reappear and get lynched for not answer, or disappear and then that's a wasted avenue. Until such point in time, why continue humping that dead tree?
melanora wrote:Alouvre, I called Hark and Ryan scum long before they called me scum. How can you say that I've only called out people that voted for me? I called out them for going after Misa and Lex.
I'm a citizen. Nothing special. And I've been attempting to keep town from being led astray by two loud mouths that have been attempting to mislynch an inactive.
melanora wrote:Alouvre, I called Hark and Ryan scum long before they called me scum. How can you say that I've only called out people that voted for me? I called out them for going after Misa and Lex.
EXTENSIVE FACT CHECKING TIME
I'm a citizen. Nothing special. And I've been attempting to keep town from being led astray by two loud mouths that have been attempting to mislynch an inactive.
melanora wrote:Alouvre, I called Hark and Ryan scum long before they called me scum. How can you say that I've only called out people that voted for me? I called out them for going after Misa and Lex.
I'm a citizen. Nothing special. And I've been attempting to keep town from being led astray by two loud mouths that have been attempting to mislynch an inactive.
alouvre wrote: thanks npr.
ryanyb wrote:N, I think you misinterpreted something. I think she was refering to herself as the inactive in the second point you made on her most recent wall. At least, that's how I took it.
melanora wrote:You had me listed as scum when I had one post. So... You can't say you've been calling me scum all along.
That stated, I see a scum slip.
Nprom... You say the Mafioso could be witched... My m post literally talked about how the gf is the only confirmed mafia role.
How do you know that the Mafioso rolled? And that he was the one witched?
melanora wrote:You had me listed as scum when I had one post. So... You can't say you've been calling me scum all along.
I've always had you pegged as scum. Tried pressuring you into doing something D1 and you ignored it.
That stated, I see a scum slip.
Nprom... You say the Mafioso could be witched... My m post literally talked about how the gf is the only confirmed mafia role.
How do you know that the Mafioso rolled? And that he was the one witched?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests