UzayAltay wrote:Noel, can we heard a full alibi from you?
Well, after some thinking I concluded that the person who bringed the blade to murder scene should be victim, herself. It is just a theory, but the one make the most sense.
Assuming Jinx and Nyx isn't a culprit duo, that leaves you and Angelina, and I believe both of you had time to commit crime so we should hear your alibi fully.
A1- noel stalked Shoker
A2- she continued stalking. Shoker seemed to think that we’re jinx.
A3- Shoker made an offer to bring some items and meet A6 near the slot machine alone. Noel ignored it and went to the resting area.
A4- she went to the great serpent (nyx and Jinx were there).
A5- I woke up, told Nyx and Jinx about Shoker’s suggestion and that if I died, he’s the most likely suspect. I went to the slot machine (no one was there)
A6- I stayed in the slot machine (no one was there either. Shoker didn’t arrive and neither Jinx nor Nyx bothered checking if I’m ok)
(honestly, I’m not really in the right mood to play this rn so sorry for being crappy.
I’ll try to deduce as much as possible but please, don’t call me out on that)
a blade and sheath could not match for 2 reasons:
less likely imo- the blade had no sheath from the beginning (and the killer took a random sheath for some reason???)
more likely- there were 2 knives?
were there any signs of the victim fighting the killer?
was erika left-handed????? she could have theoretically held a knife there?
@shoker, there can’t be an accomplice involved. We’d be informed if that was the case (it’s written in the rules)
UzayAltay wrote:Well, biggest flaw of it is for what reason victim was holding a dick-like knife in her hand.
Though like I couldn't find any explanation to when did culprit took it if we ignore this. (maybe Agelina taking it the earlier night byt still now I cannot explain what was victim holding at their left hand right before they are killed.)
.....honestly, what would help the most rn is an information if there were any signs of the dick knife being placed into the sheath
if the sheath didn’t fit, there should have been some marks left.
This would mean that the victim was the one who brought the knife.
if not, it would mean that the killer was the one who left the knife or sheath there. The victim could have had a knife on their own (which they held in order to defend themself), while the attacker had the dick knife.
After the murder, during the last actions the murderer could have taken the victim’s knife and replaced it with the murder weapon (the dick knife)....
does this make sense?