Re: Reaver (Neutral Killing)
Posted: Wed Jan 26, 2022 4:03 am
"WW used to be super weak with it appearing suspicious all game. Godfather and Necronomicon wielders should also be innocent to the Sheriff; Godfather is literally Mafioso with Basic defense, Detection immunity, and a different Investigator result."
WW wouldn't be underpowered appearing suspicious all game. Remember most people don't play this game optimally so when people are 1vs14, the win rate is a lot lower. I highly disagree about Godfather and Necro wielders being innocent to Sheriff. Sheriff SHOULD be a threat. Someone outs themselves as Sheriff, then the risk to kill them should be worth it. Most games I ignore Sheriff claims and I win as Mafia. Basic defense is fine with GF. But should GF literally be the same as Mafioso with added benefits? Just because that's the way it is, doesn't make it right
"It's really not a "strong finisher" if like 16 roles can stop it from killing lol.
Also... "miss thing" is LGBTQ+ slang; I didn't call you a woman."
Killing roles (which we discussed changing) and roleblockers pretty much. As if there's gonna be a shit load of them in the game anyway. So you may have 2-3 players who are detrimental to your game, that's why you kill them. The strong finisher point is still valid... once again you're trying to decipher a small part of my argument as to why you're right. At best this role can finish off the game with 3 fatal attacks with one of them being a Powerful Rampage, that's a finisher. Just because it COULD fail, doesn't invalidate my point
WW wouldn't be underpowered appearing suspicious all game. Remember most people don't play this game optimally so when people are 1vs14, the win rate is a lot lower. I highly disagree about Godfather and Necro wielders being innocent to Sheriff. Sheriff SHOULD be a threat. Someone outs themselves as Sheriff, then the risk to kill them should be worth it. Most games I ignore Sheriff claims and I win as Mafia. Basic defense is fine with GF. But should GF literally be the same as Mafioso with added benefits? Just because that's the way it is, doesn't make it right
"It's really not a "strong finisher" if like 16 roles can stop it from killing lol.
Also... "miss thing" is LGBTQ+ slang; I didn't call you a woman."
Killing roles (which we discussed changing) and roleblockers pretty much. As if there's gonna be a shit load of them in the game anyway. So you may have 2-3 players who are detrimental to your game, that's why you kill them. The strong finisher point is still valid... once again you're trying to decipher a small part of my argument as to why you're right. At best this role can finish off the game with 3 fatal attacks with one of them being a Powerful Rampage, that's a finisher. Just because it COULD fail, doesn't invalidate my point