Ezradekezra wrote:is voting over yet
Ezradekezra wrote:Yeah, Elemental honestly isn't too bad of a a role idea.
I do think that it should definitely be moved to NK though.
One issue that I do have with Elemental is that I feel like Shrieking Gusts in particular is kinda pointless, as it doesn't really do much to further the Elemental's progress toward achieving its wincon. The same kinda applies to Water Ripple as well, but being able to self-heal at least makes it useful for self-preservation purposes.
I'm not really sure what the best way to fix these abilities would be, as simply removing them would turn Elemental into a better SK. Maybe rework them into less powerful killing abilities, but not in a way that turns it into a different SK?
WaveAqualei wrote:I did have a question about Servant. How would this work if their target was Plaguebearer turned Pestilence?
WaveAqualei wrote:I see. What happens if their target is Serial Killer/Werewolf and the Servant is roleblocked? I think that's a bit complicated.
Ezradekezra wrote:WaveAqualei wrote:I see. What happens if their target is Serial Killer/Werewolf and the Servant is roleblocked? I think that's a bit complicated.
Serial Killer: Servant will not attack the roleblocker but will still attack its target. Serial Killer will still attack roleblockers.
Werewolf: Werewolf will rampage at the target's house instead of the Servant. If both are RB'd, the Werewolf will rampage at home.
WaveAqualei wrote:Ezradekezra wrote:WaveAqualei wrote:I see. What happens if their target is Serial Killer/Werewolf and the Servant is roleblocked? I think that's a bit complicated.
Serial Killer: Servant will not attack the roleblocker but will still attack its target. Serial Killer will still attack roleblockers.
Werewolf: Werewolf will rampage at the target's house instead of the Servant. If both are RB'd, the Werewolf will rampage at home.
That makes sense, but it seems like too much for Servant to act independently with a WW target. Two WWs rampaging in one night seems like a lot.
Ezradekezra wrote:WaveAqualei wrote:Ezradekezra wrote:WaveAqualei wrote:I see. What happens if their target is Serial Killer/Werewolf and the Servant is roleblocked? I think that's a bit complicated.
Serial Killer: Servant will not attack the roleblocker but will still attack its target. Serial Killer will still attack roleblockers.
Werewolf: Werewolf will rampage at the target's house instead of the Servant. If both are RB'd, the Werewolf will rampage at home.
That makes sense, but it seems like too much for Servant to act independently with a WW target. Two WWs rampaging in one night seems like a lot.
The Servant only gets to act independently once, though. Yeah, it would be OP if there were multiple uses, but I don't think that it's too much different than giving an extra shot to any other killing role.
WaveAqualei wrote:Ezradekezra wrote:WaveAqualei wrote:Ezradekezra wrote:WaveAqualei wrote:I see. What happens if their target is Serial Killer/Werewolf and the Servant is roleblocked? I think that's a bit complicated.
Serial Killer: Servant will not attack the roleblocker but will still attack its target. Serial Killer will still attack roleblockers.
Werewolf: Werewolf will rampage at the target's house instead of the Servant. If both are RB'd, the Werewolf will rampage at home.
That makes sense, but it seems like too much for Servant to act independently with a WW target. Two WWs rampaging in one night seems like a lot.
The Servant only gets to act independently once, though. Yeah, it would be OP if there were multiple uses, but I don't think that it's too much different than giving an extra shot to any other killing role.
I feel like that it's too much? Two Pestilence rampages in one night just seems...well, difficult. Also, can Servant be converted into a Vampire?
WaveAqualei wrote:How does it work when the Servant's target is a Vampire? Do they visit or does the youngest Vampire visit? Also can Servant be staked by a Vampire Hunter?
WaveAqualei wrote:Gotcha, it's also weird for two Vampire conversions to happen in a night?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests