Kirize12 wrote:-snip-
Kirize12 wrote:Ezradekezra wrote:Kirize12 wrote:-snip-
You forgot GA turned Surv and BMer preventing people from claiming stuff
Also, evils won't necessarily claim their results and some people just don't claim them as any alignment
It is still totally possible none of those roles will be in the game.
I'm not entirely sure why Coroner would be checking evils (unless there's no Town deaths) but I'll grant you that. Not entirely sure what utility it would have though.
If you don't claim your results, or write them in your will, you are gamethrowing imo.
Kirize12 wrote:
I’m ok with this role in a gamemode where there are no flips and players do not receive feedback of any kind. Not in Ranked or even AA.
Kirize12 wrote:It feels really niche. In most cases, I would rather have a Sheriff that could check those players directly, or an Invest to deduce their claims.
I really like the idea of the Coroner in the Clue Variant, and potentially as Coven Exclusive, however. I’d like to test it in Clue Variant first.
Kirize12 wrote:Cabohhh wrote:Kirize12 wrote:It feels really niche. In most cases, I would rather have a Sheriff that could check those players directly, or an Invest to deduce their claims.
I really like the idea of the Coroner in the Clue Variant, and potentially as Coven Exclusive, however. I’d like to test it in Clue Variant first.
You act like niche is bad lmao
anyways clue variant won't work, it's functionally broke (like me)
Filling a niche is good. A role that you would prefer to be another role EXCEPT in a cetain scenario isn't good.
Clue Variant is just flipless. Flipless modes can and have worked before, if you personally don't like them...well, I can't force you to play a game you don't like any more than you can force me to play Classic.
Kirize12 wrote:Nobody’s ever tried. Doesn’t mean it won’t work.
Ichbinderubermensch wrote:So a worse medium that occupies a TI slot?
Cabohhh wrote:Ichbinderubermensch wrote:So a worse medium that occupies a TI slot?
lmao did you read the role? waht-
It is not Medium. This role doesn't rely on chat. This role can do things Medium can't (like, for example, reveal hidden roles). This role isn't instantly confirmable. This role can confirm Retributionist, one of the hardest roles to confirm without a BG or Vigilante.
So, no, not "a worse medium that occupies a TI slot".
Ichbinderubermensch wrote:Cabohhh wrote:Ichbinderubermensch wrote:So a worse medium that occupies a TI slot?
lmao did you read the role? waht-
It is not Medium. This role doesn't rely on chat. This role can do things Medium can't (like, for example, reveal hidden roles). This role isn't instantly confirmable. This role can confirm Retributionist, one of the hardest roles to confirm without a BG or Vigilante.
So, no, not "a worse medium that occupies a TI slot".
That's because you don't understand the job of Medium in a RC game.
Ichbinderubermensch wrote:"Coroner doesn't rely on people staying in the game after death (Which is one of the peeves of Medium). Coroner doesn't rely on anyone to give information."
But that's not a flaw from the role itself. It's a flaw from the players.
Ichbinderubermensch wrote:"Coroner cannot learn their target's role."
What did you meant by "You will learn their action if they are Forged.", then? Won't knowing the action of their target's night ability be enough information to deduce their role since most roles perform unique actions or you were refering to something else by "their action"?
Ichbinderubermensch wrote:I'm assuming that "You will learn what happened to them" is going to be exactly like a spy's bug.
Which one of these results Med can't get and will be useful to Town?
Ichbinderubermensch wrote:Guaranteed no info D2 as TI.
Ichbinderubermensch wrote:Results can be easily faked and are extremely vague.
Ichbinderubermensch wrote:Can be Rb'ed.
Ichbinderubermensch wrote:Needs to survive to post their results.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 9 guests