Schultz128 wrote:RAmcius wrote:vanilla mafia uses cop, not sheriff
HMMMM
cop is vanilla, sheriff is standard in here. Naming is important
Moderators: Varanus, FM Game Moderators
Schultz128 wrote:RAmcius wrote:vanilla mafia uses cop, not sheriff
HMMMM
RAmcius wrote:cop is vanilla, sheriff is standard in here. Naming is important
enderitem wrote:So we should have instead used a system that either involved more from the FM Mods or the community... huh, how outlandish.
Seriously though, if this is how bad the results are because of the system set for the Creator's Spotlight, then the best course of action is involving the FM Mods more in it as far as I can see. Since they, themselves, removed Evan's role, can't they create a pool of roles submitted by the community and have them be voted instead? Or something reverse in which the Mods can veto roles no matter the votes. There were over 30 roles in this one I believe, votes being this divided sounds normal when that is in mind. Shrinking that amount at least somewhat solves the problem here in my opinion.RAmcius wrote:cop is vanilla, sheriff is standard in here. Naming is important
Nobody cares, stop derailing the thread.
Metrion wrote:To be frank, a lot of roles are bad.
Kirize12 wrote:Silencer won't do shit tbh
Dash2 wrote:RAmcius wrote:Schultz128 wrote:RAmcius wrote:vanilla mafia uses cop, not sheriff
HMMMM
cop is vanilla, sheriff is standard in here. Naming is important
They're literally the same roles. Names don't mean shit
RAmcius wrote:it's funny, how people without sense of balance make roles, then vote for these roles and you wondering why bad roles are chosen?
best part is that Evan asking to remove most useless role that no one gonna use, but is totally fine with gunsmith - a role that gives 3 1-shot dayvigs. You may think hitting immune and not knowing who was hit is ok, but whoever shot will know who they targeted and there's no town roles with passive BP yet, so sad days for nk/witch/gf
Kirize12 wrote:Silencer won't do shit tbh
Kirize12 wrote:Silencer won't do shit tbh
enderitem wrote:Kirize12 wrote:Silencer won't do shit tbh
It will just be the best deception role after Janitor probably so yeah, not much. Gunsmith does seem like it needs the number of shots reduced at least, it just solves any counterclaim immediately the following night and it seems like it is easily confirmable. I think people just wanted to vote something from every faction and Mirrorer was the only available Neutral for them... since one of those is Vampire.
Chemist1422 wrote:enderitem wrote:Kirize12 wrote:Silencer won't do shit tbh
It will just be the best deception role after Janitor probably so yeah, not much. Gunsmith does seem like it needs the number of shots reduced at least, it just solves any counterclaim immediately the following night and it seems like it is easily confirmable. I think people just wanted to vote something from every faction and Mirrorer was the only available Neutral for them... since one of those is Vampire.
That's why I voted it. Also we need another NE more than we need another NK.
Varanus wrote:Janitor is actually bad in the current meta btw
Kmenx wrote:RAmcius wrote:it's funny, how people without sense of balance make roles, then vote for these roles and you wondering why bad roles are chosen?
best part is that Evan asking to remove most useless role that no one gonna use, but is totally fine with gunsmith - a role that gives 3 1-shot dayvigs. You may think hitting immune and not knowing who was hit is ok, but whoever shot will know who they targeted and there's no town roles with passive BP yet, so sad days for nk/witch/gf
Oh this makes sense it is like we don't already have a town role that has a 3 shot night vig and can claim should it hit an immune role /s
Varanus wrote:Janitor is actually bad in the current meta btw
Chemist1422 wrote:That's why I voted it. Also we need another NE more than we need another NK.
enderitem wrote:Chemist1422 wrote:That's why I voted it. Also we need another NE more than we need another NK.
We had like 5 NE before this, why would we need more? I feel like you didn't even look at the role, just picked it for being NE.
ICECLIMBERS wrote:enderitem wrote:Chemist1422 wrote:That's why I voted it. Also we need another NE more than we need another NK.
We had like 5 NE before this, why would we need more? I feel like you didn't even look at the role, just picked it for being NE.
"it" refers to Silencer.
Kirize12 wrote:Silencer won't do shit tbh
Chemist1422 wrote:enderitem wrote:Kirize12 wrote:Silencer won't do shit tbh
It will just be the best deception role after Janitor probably so yeah, not much. Gunsmith does seem like it needs the number of shots reduced at least, it just solves any counterclaim immediately the following night and it seems like it is easily confirmable. I think people just wanted to vote something from every faction and Mirrorer was the only available Neutral for them... since one of those is Vampire.
That's why I voted it. Also we need another NE more than we need another NK.
BasicFourLife wrote:Chemist1422 wrote:enderitem wrote:Kirize12 wrote:Silencer won't do shit tbh
It will just be the best deception role after Janitor probably so yeah, not much. Gunsmith does seem like it needs the number of shots reduced at least, it just solves any counterclaim immediately the following night and it seems like it is easily confirmable. I think people just wanted to vote something from every faction and Mirrorer was the only available Neutral for them... since one of those is Vampire.
That's why I voted it. Also we need another NE more than we need another NK.
It's a terrible NE. What we need is GOOD NEs but they are only a myth.
LinearPoint wrote:BasicFourLife wrote:Chemist1422 wrote:enderitem wrote:Kirize12 wrote:Silencer won't do shit tbh
It will just be the best deception role after Janitor probably so yeah, not much. Gunsmith does seem like it needs the number of shots reduced at least, it just solves any counterclaim immediately the following night and it seems like it is easily confirmable. I think people just wanted to vote something from every faction and Mirrorer was the only available Neutral for them... since one of those is Vampire.
That's why I voted it. Also we need another NE more than we need another NK.
It's a terrible NE. What we need is GOOD NEs but they are only a myth.
Jester exists.
Kmenx wrote:RAmcius wrote:it's funny, how people without sense of balance make roles, then vote for these roles and you wondering why bad roles are chosen?
best part is that Evan asking to remove most useless role that no one gonna use, but is totally fine with gunsmith - a role that gives 3 1-shot dayvigs. You may think hitting immune and not knowing who was hit is ok, but whoever shot will know who they targeted and there's no town roles with passive BP yet, so sad days for nk/witch/gf
Oh this makes sense it is like we don't already have a town role that has a 3 shot night vig and can claim should it hit an immune role /s
Kmenx wrote:ICECLIMBERS wrote:enderitem wrote:Chemist1422 wrote:That's why I voted it. Also we need another NE more than we need another NK.
We had like 5 NE before this, why would we need more? I feel like you didn't even look at the role, just picked it for being NE.
"it" refers to Silencer.
it likely refers mirrorer
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 33 guests