Page 21 of 50

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 3:33 pm
by rightodude
Eragon1329 wrote:
rightodude wrote:
0verki11 wrote:
rightodude wrote:Hey, I had problems with admins needing to review my posts but I got it fixed now. sorry about all the delay for posting. I'm UTC+13 btw.

hey, what do you think of whats been going on in the thread?


personally I think phone is ultra sketchy, mario is just confusing but you all seem to think that chemist is scum so I might agree just based off of that entirely



~~~ plenty of in between posts


rightodude wrote:/vote phone



rightodude wrote:
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:
Joeshe wrote:
TheDebil wrote:questionarre

1. give me your predictions on who will the 3 mafia be.
2. how active are you?
3. what is your timezone?



1. Phone, Chemist, Bodhrak
2. I have school and work some days so sorry I have a life outside of FM (therefore not too active but active enough)
3. EST (It is 10:10 pm rn and my friends want to grind on BlackDesertOnline)

I also /vote Phone (tell me if im doing this wrong). His joke seems to have gone south for him and chemist took defense? Bodhrak tried calling me and other inactives scummy (which i can see where he's coming from) but could be trying to divert attention.

Anyways ill be on and off

Wait so why do you think Phone should be lynched?

read what he's saying and tell me a reason why he shouldn't be lynched



this is what im talking about
early on, you called Ph0ne "ultra sketchy" without really giving anything else, and you left it at that.

then after posting more, you hop onto the Ph0ne wagon as one of the last 3 voters and say "why shouldn't he be lynched" without expanding on any reasons you think he should be lynched

what I get from this is that I should include more info in my posts. first of all, phone was joking but it extended far over what anyone would normally joke, that made me lean into the scummy side a bit. He was playing like jester which is super odd because we have no jester in this game :thonk:. Mario was defending ph0ne which I think is fair considering that we knew very little but ph0ne wasn't doing much to defend until the last minute. He was either asleep or thinking about what to say in response to what was happening. What he was saying felt very forced. ph0ne also seemed like he was covering up what he was saying, almost as if he had made a mistake. at the point in the game that we were at I think the vote was fair. There was more stuff coming out of ph0ne that seemed odd than there was normal stuff and we were all turned against him by the time he realised his mistake. My thinking was very much directed by other players but I did have my reasons

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 3:47 pm
by JuvenileFourtyTwo
I'm going to say this, I understand that you want to lynch me, but you're wrong

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 4:11 pm
by 0verki11
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:I'm going to say this, I understand that you want to lynch me, but you're wrong

never heard a better defense in my life.

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 4:35 pm
by JuvenileFourtyTwo
0verki11 wrote:
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:I'm going to say this, I understand that you want to lynch me, but you're wrong

never heard a better defense in my life.

I mean, what else can I say other than my role.

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 4:42 pm
by Bodhrak
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:I mean, what else can I say other than my role.

Give us your reads, so we have something to go on.

Also don't worry, we won't be lynching until everyone has checked in.
Well I won't.

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 4:49 pm
by JuvenileFourtyTwo
Bodhrak wrote:
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:I mean, what else can I say other than my role.

Give us your reads, so we have something to go on.

Also don't worry, we won't be lynching until everyone has checked in.
Well I won't.

I wasn't kidding. I have no clue who is what.
I guess that joeshe and rightodude have been pretty friendly with each other whenever they interact with each other and they could be scumbuddies? That's the most I have to give. I'm pretty bad at reads.

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 5:05 pm
by Bodhrak
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:I wasn't kidding. I have no clue who is what.
I guess that joeshe and rightodude have been pretty friendly with each other whenever they interact with each other and they could be scumbuddies? That's the most I have to give. I'm pretty bad at reads.

That's something (not something I would have given attention, but something).

If you don't want to be lynched you have to give us more: An alternative.
Maybe you think some players are actively avoiding the thread.
Maybe you think someone is actively targeting you as you are an easy target.
Or you can look at the ISOs (first page, second post) of individual players and look for odd behavior changes or pauses or votes out of nowhere - indicating someone might be in the mafia chat and get pointers from his scumbuddies or being an opportunist.

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 5:06 pm
by Bodhrak
Also getting some sleep now.

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 5:47 pm
by rightodude
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:
Bodhrak wrote:
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:I mean, what else can I say other than my role.

Give us your reads, so we have something to go on.

Also don't worry, we won't be lynching until everyone has checked in.
Well I won't.

I wasn't kidding. I have no clue who is what.
I guess that joeshe and rightodude have been pretty friendly with each other whenever they interact with each other and they could be scumbuddies? That's the most I have to give. I'm pretty bad at reads.

I just don't think that joeshe is scum. he definitely could be though. I think that the only confirmed town is mario right now

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 6:18 pm
by 0verki11
rightodude wrote:
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:
Bodhrak wrote:
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:I mean, what else can I say other than my role.

Give us your reads, so we have something to go on.

Also don't worry, we won't be lynching until everyone has checked in.
Well I won't.

I wasn't kidding. I have no clue who is what.
I guess that joeshe and rightodude have been pretty friendly with each other whenever they interact with each other and they could be scumbuddies? That's the most I have to give. I'm pretty bad at reads.

I just don't think that joeshe is scum. he definitely could be though. I think that the only confirmed town is mario right now

Chemist is also confirmed town

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 6:20 pm
by Joeshe
Hello and good evening,
Sorry I haven't been posting, like I've mentioned before, I have school and work outside in my real life which keep me busy. I'm going to say, I am definitely busy from 7 am EST to 1 pm EST one the weekdays and possibly busy from 1:30 pm EST to 9:30 pm EST if I am working that day.

Now my response to Juve, can you give me an example of me being friendly with Right? I dont post that much so I dont really remember what I do post. Other than that, I'm not going to defend Right, just in case he scum. Nor will I scum read him since all I have been doing so far is skimming through the forum. Tbh from what I have read, Juve has felt a bit scummy as he keeps pointing the attention to others yet hasn't given a solid defense as to why he isn't scum. I want to vote Juve but I will wait for the more experienced players to give some solid reads as well as Juve's defense.

IF YOU STRONGLY FEEL LIKE JUVE IS SKUM. TRY YOUR BEST TO CONVINCE MY VOTE. IF NOT TRY TO DEFEND HIM.

Like I mentioned, before this is my first game so sorry for the sheep vote. I'll be more cautious when voting.

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 7:07 pm
by rightodude
Joeshe wrote:Hello and good evening,
Sorry I haven't been posting, like I've mentioned before, I have school and work outside in my real life which keep me busy. I'm going to say, I am definitely busy from 7 am EST to 1 pm EST one the weekdays and possibly busy from 1:30 pm EST to 9:30 pm EST if I am working that day.

Now my response to Juve, can you give me an example of me being friendly with Right? I dont post that much so I dont really remember what I do post. Other than that, I'm not going to defend Right, just in case he scum. Nor will I scum read him since all I have been doing so far is skimming through the forum. Tbh from what I have read, Juve has felt a bit scummy as he keeps pointing the attention to others yet hasn't given a solid defense as to why he isn't scum. I want to vote Juve but I will wait for the more experienced players to give some solid reads as well as Juve's defense.

IF YOU STRONGLY FEEL LIKE JUVE IS SKUM. TRY YOUR BEST TO CONVINCE MY VOTE. IF NOT TRY TO DEFEND HIM.

Like I mentioned, before this is my first game so sorry for the sheep vote. I'll be more cautious when voting.

Yeah, I'm not sure what that 'being friendly' post was about. I haven't gone out of my way to be nice to you at all lmao

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 7:14 pm
by JuvenileFourtyTwo
Joeshe wrote:Hello and good evening,
Sorry I haven't been posting, like I've mentioned before, I have school and work outside in my real life which keep me busy. I'm going to say, I am definitely busy from 7 am EST to 1 pm EST one the weekdays and possibly busy from 1:30 pm EST to 9:30 pm EST if I am working that day.

Now my response to Juve, can you give me an example of me being friendly with Right? I dont post that much so I dont really remember what I do post. Other than that, I'm not going to defend Right, just in case he scum. Nor will I scum read him since all I have been doing so far is skimming through the forum. Tbh from what I have read, Juve has felt a bit scummy as he keeps pointing the attention to others yet hasn't given a solid defense as to why he isn't scum. I want to vote Juve but I will wait for the more experienced players to give some solid reads as well as Juve's defense.

IF YOU STRONGLY FEEL LIKE JUVE IS SKUM. TRY YOUR BEST TO CONVINCE MY VOTE. IF NOT TRY TO DEFEND HIM.

Like I mentioned, before this is my first game so sorry for the sheep vote. I'll be more cautious when voting.

Like I said, I'm trying to give my reads, and the only time I've done that was in one other game, and although expansive, the were way off. I just noticed that you agreed with Right a few times on their opinions, but like I said, I'm just trying to get into doing reads and doing fm in general again.

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 7:19 pm
by 0verki11
what other FM games have you played?

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 8:17 pm
by Joeshe
@overkill Are you asking me or juve

@juve Can you tell me what opinions? You are always being vague about them... I mean they could be good opinions or bad ones.
Plus posting your reads are a great way of practicing, not posting them could mean you're scummy and afraid to post something wrong.

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 8:55 pm
by 0verki11
Joeshe wrote:@overkill Are you asking me or juve

@juve Can you tell me what opinions? You are always being vague about them... I mean they could be good opinions or bad ones.
Plus posting your reads are a great way of practicing, not posting them could mean you're scummy and afraid to post something wrong.

juve, but feel free to answer as well

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 10:13 pm
by MoustachioMario
0verki11 wrote:
rightodude wrote:
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:
Bodhrak wrote:
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:I mean, what else can I say other than my role.

Give us your reads, so we have something to go on.

Also don't worry, we won't be lynching until everyone has checked in.
Well I won't.

I wasn't kidding. I have no clue who is what.
I guess that joeshe and rightodude have been pretty friendly with each other whenever they interact with each other and they could be scumbuddies? That's the most I have to give. I'm pretty bad at reads.

I just don't think that joeshe is scum. he definitely could be though. I think that the only confirmed town is mario right now

Chemist is also confirmed town


How?

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2019 11:10 pm
by JuvenileFourtyTwo
0verki11 wrote:what other FM games have you played?

I've played 3 other games about 2 years ago, and I haven't been able to play Town of Salem for a while. I think I was scum once in those three, and that's the game that I gave my first ever in depth reads I believe. I'm basically a newb again tho.

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Sat Feb 02, 2019 12:25 am
by Eragon1329
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:
Bodhrak wrote:
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:I mean, what else can I say other than my role.

Give us your reads, so we have something to go on.

Also don't worry, we won't be lynching until everyone has checked in.
Well I won't.

I wasn't kidding. I have no clue who is what.
I guess that joeshe and rightodude have been pretty friendly with each other whenever they interact with each other and they could be scumbuddies? That's the most I have to give. I'm pretty bad at reads.


Can you point out the interactions that you think are “friendly”

Both of them have had almost no interaction with the thread itself, let alone each other

I don’t even think joeshe mentioned righto at all?

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Sat Feb 02, 2019 12:26 am
by Eragon1329
rightodude wrote:
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:
Bodhrak wrote:
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:I mean, what else can I say other than my role.

Give us your reads, so we have something to go on.

Also don't worry, we won't be lynching until everyone has checked in.
Well I won't.

I wasn't kidding. I have no clue who is what.
I guess that joeshe and rightodude have been pretty friendly with each other whenever they interact with each other and they could be scumbuddies? That's the most I have to give. I'm pretty bad at reads.

I just don't think that joeshe is scum. he definitely could be though. I think that the only confirmed town is mario right now


What out of joeshe’s 2-3 posts make you think he is scum???

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Sat Feb 02, 2019 12:26 am
by Eragon1329
*not scum*

EBWOP

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Sat Feb 02, 2019 12:34 am
by Eragon1329
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:
Joeshe wrote:Hello and good evening,
Sorry I haven't been posting, like I've mentioned before, I have school and work outside in my real life which keep me busy. I'm going to say, I am definitely busy from 7 am EST to 1 pm EST one the weekdays and possibly busy from 1:30 pm EST to 9:30 pm EST if I am working that day.

Now my response to Juve, can you give me an example of me being friendly with Right? I dont post that much so I dont really remember what I do post. Other than that, I'm not going to defend Right, just in case he scum. Nor will I scum read him since all I have been doing so far is skimming through the forum. Tbh from what I have read, Juve has felt a bit scummy as he keeps pointing the attention to others yet hasn't given a solid defense as to why he isn't scum. I want to vote Juve but I will wait for the more experienced players to give some solid reads as well as Juve's defense.

IF YOU STRONGLY FEEL LIKE JUVE IS SKUM. TRY YOUR BEST TO CONVINCE MY VOTE. IF NOT TRY TO DEFEND HIM.

Like I mentioned, before this is my first game so sorry for the sheep vote. I'll be more cautious when voting.

Like I said, I'm trying to give my reads, and the only time I've done that was in one other game, and although expansive, the were way off. I just noticed that you agreed with Right a few times on their opinions, but like I said, I'm just trying to get into doing reads and doing fm in general again.


They never even agreed on an opinion though?

Joeshe never mentioned righto once at the time you said they were friendly.
If you are saying they have the same opinion becuase they both voted Ph0ne, then does that mean all 7 voters, including yoursef, are “friendly?”

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Sat Feb 02, 2019 1:01 am
by rightodude
Eragon1329 wrote:
JuvenileFourtyTwo wrote:
Joeshe wrote:Hello and good evening,
Sorry I haven't been posting, like I've mentioned before, I have school and work outside in my real life which keep me busy. I'm going to say, I am definitely busy from 7 am EST to 1 pm EST one the weekdays and possibly busy from 1:30 pm EST to 9:30 pm EST if I am working that day.

Now my response to Juve, can you give me an example of me being friendly with Right? I dont post that much so I dont really remember what I do post. Other than that, I'm not going to defend Right, just in case he scum. Nor will I scum read him since all I have been doing so far is skimming through the forum. Tbh from what I have read, Juve has felt a bit scummy as he keeps pointing the attention to others yet hasn't given a solid defense as to why he isn't scum. I want to vote Juve but I will wait for the more experienced players to give some solid reads as well as Juve's defense.

IF YOU STRONGLY FEEL LIKE JUVE IS SKUM. TRY YOUR BEST TO CONVINCE MY VOTE. IF NOT TRY TO DEFEND HIM.

Like I mentioned, before this is my first game so sorry for the sheep vote. I'll be more cautious when voting.

Like I said, I'm trying to give my reads, and the only time I've done that was in one other game, and although expansive, the were way off. I just noticed that you agreed with Right a few times on their opinions, but like I said, I'm just trying to get into doing reads and doing fm in general again.


They never even agreed on an opinion though?

Joeshe never mentioned righto once at the time you said they were friendly.
If you are saying they have the same opinion becuase they both voted Ph0ne, then does that mean all 7 voters, including yoursef, are “friendly?”

That statement was odd, I haven't done anything with joeshe at all lmao. I'll just take that as a mistake? not sure anymore

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Sat Feb 02, 2019 5:34 am
by Bodhrak
Joeshe wrote:Hello and good evening,
Sorry I haven't been posting, like I've mentioned before, I have school and work outside in my real life which keep me busy. I'm going to say, I am definitely busy from 7 am EST to 1 pm EST one the weekdays and possibly busy from 1:30 pm EST to 9:30 pm EST if I am working that day.

Now my response to Juve, can you give me an example of me being friendly with Right? I dont post that much so I dont really remember what I do post. Other than that, I'm not going to defend Right, just in case he scum. Nor will I scum read him since all I have been doing so far is skimming through the forum. Tbh from what I have read, Juve has felt a bit scummy as he keeps pointing the attention to others yet hasn't given a solid defense as to why he isn't scum. I want to vote Juve but I will wait for the more experienced players to give some solid reads as well as Juve's defense.

IF YOU STRONGLY FEEL LIKE JUVE IS SKUM. TRY YOUR BEST TO CONVINCE MY VOTE. IF NOT TRY TO DEFEND HIM.

Like I mentioned, before this is my first game so sorry for the sheep vote. I'll be more cautious when voting.

(For reference: You can look up your posts in your ISO.)
We aren't going to defend Juve, he has to do that on his.

The lack of support from his supposed scumbuddies means one of these three things to me.
1. He is being bussed as a weak member to gain towncred.
2. His scumbuddies aren't active. This would lead to possibly flint also being scum. But who else?
3. He's actually town and just backed into a corner and too much of a noob to come up with a decent defense.

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

PostPosted: Sat Feb 02, 2019 5:38 am
by Bodhrak
Bodhrak wrote:We aren't going to defend Juve, he has to do that on his.

*own

Eragon1329 wrote:Joeshe never mentioned righto once at the time you said they were friendly.
If you are saying they have the same opinion becuase they both voted Ph0ne, then does that mean all 7 voters, including yoursef, are “friendly?”

That's probably what he was implying.
Pretty weak to me.