[Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win

[MoustachioMario]

I will not accept "It was a joke mario" as your defense

You never accept that. Look what ph0ne was when you didn't accept the "it was a joke" defense.

That'll teach everyone ;)

[JuvenileFourtyTwo]

I will not accept "It was a joke mario" as your defense

You never accept that. Look what ph0ne was when you didn't accept the "it was a joke" defense.

That'll teach everyone

Not to make jokes? I think I will continue to make jokes when the opportunity pops up, mkay

[MoustachioMario]

I will not accept "It was a joke mario" as your defense

You never accept that. Look what ph0ne was when you didn't accept the "it was a joke" defense.

That'll teach everyone ;)

Not to make jokes? I think I will continue to make jokes when the opportunity pops up, mkay

mkay

[MoustachioMario]

we might as well get a rolecall maybe?

DO NOT CLAIM YET THOUGH

[JuvenileFourtyTwo]

we might as well get a rolecall maybe?

DO NOT CLAIM YET THOUGH

Isn't that what a rolecall is?

[MoustachioMario]

we might as well get a rolecall maybe?

DO NOT CLAIM YET THOUGH

Isn't that what a rolecall is?

I want to wait for "experienced" players to say ok :D

[Eragon1329]

we might as well get a rolecall maybe?

DO NOT CLAIM YET THOUGH

Isn't that what a rolecall is?

I want to wait for "experienced" players to say ok

Nah

We are already low enough on PR's as it is, I don't think we should out the remaining ones.

[Kears123]

we might as well get a rolecall maybe?

DO NOT CLAIM YET THOUGH

Isn't that what a rolecall is?

I want to wait for "experienced" players to say ok

It's a no from me. We need the PRs we do have to stay hidden.

[rightodude]

we might as well get a rolecall maybe?

DO NOT CLAIM YET THOUGH

so you want us to call out our roles?

[Bodhrak]

we might as well get a rolecall maybe?

DO NOT CLAIM YET THOUGH

so you want us to call out our roles?

Don't claim.
We only have a TI and a TP left.
The TI should only claim if they have good info.
The TP definitely shouldn't claim. They will simply get nightkilled.

[Bodhrak]

we might as well get a rolecall maybe?

DO NOT CLAIM YET THOUGH

so you want us to call out our roles?

Don't claim.
We only have a TI and a TP left.
The TI should only claim if they have good info.
The TP definitely shouldn't claim. They will simply get nightkilled.

And obviously citizen claims will reduce the space for these roles, making it easier for maf to target the PR roles "by accident", so don't claim that either.

[MoustachioMario]

we might as well get a rolecall maybe?

DO NOT CLAIM YET THOUGH

so you want us to call out our roles?

Don't claim.
We only have a TI and a TP left.
The TI should only claim if they have good info.
The TP definitely shouldn't claim. They will simply get nightkilled.

And obviously citizen claims will reduce the space for these roles, making it easier for maf to target the PR roles "by accident", so don't claim that either.

I claim citizen

[Bodhrak]

I claim citizen

Good job.

Are prods in order? Joeshe? flint?
Still shenanigans with Mods?

rightodude are you here? can you share some reads?

[Kears123]

I claim citizen

Good job.

Are prods in order? Joeshe? flint?
Still shenanigans with Mods?

rightodude are you here? can you share some reads?

I'm working on mine

[Varanus]

Prods are a 36 hour timer
It hasn't even been 24 hours since day started

[0verki11]

no rolecall, still want to lynch Juvanile

[Chemist1422]

Bodhrak's progression onto phone felt weird to me. He shaded the votes then proceeded to vote him?

[rightodude]

I claim citizen

Good job.

Are prods in order? Joeshe? flint?
Still shenanigans with Mods?

rightodude are you here? can you share some reads?

Sorry but I was asleep when you sent that. what do you mean by reads? I'm a complete noob lmao

[rightodude]

I claim citizen

Good job.

Are prods in order? Joeshe? flint?
Still shenanigans with Mods?

rightodude are you here? can you share some reads?

Sorry but I was asleep when you sent that. what do you mean by reads? I'm a complete noob lmao

oh wait, I get it now lol. tbh I agree with chemist in saying that bodhrak was acting weirdly onto phone. Mario does seem like he's citizen but he might not be telling the truth so he doesn't get nightkilled.

[Eragon1329]

I claim citizen

Good job.

Are prods in order? Joeshe? flint?
Still shenanigans with Mods?

rightodude are you here? can you share some reads?

Sorry but I was asleep when you sent that. what do you mean by reads? I'm a complete noob lmao

oh wait, I get it now lol. tbh I agree with chemist in saying that bodhrak was acting weirdly onto phone. Mario does seem like he's citizen but he might not be telling the truth so he doesn't get nightkilled.

mario is literally confirmed town

and do you have any thoughts that aren't following someone else's words?

what about your progression onto ph0ne?

[rightodude]

I claim citizen

Good job.

Are prods in order? Joeshe? flint?
Still shenanigans with Mods?

rightodude are you here? can you share some reads?

Sorry but I was asleep when you sent that. what do you mean by reads? I'm a complete noob lmao

oh wait, I get it now lol. tbh I agree with chemist in saying that bodhrak was acting weirdly onto phone. Mario does seem like he's citizen but he might not be telling the truth so he doesn't get nightkilled.

mario is literally confirmed town

and do you have any thoughts that aren't following someone else's words?

what about your progression onto ph0ne?

I didn't really do much with phone, I felt like other people (Mario) took a lot of control in that situation. most of the stuff that's been said is the kind of stuff that I've been thinking as well, joeshe and flint are an odd case though. I can only assume that they're inactive

[Bodhrak]

Sorry but I was asleep when you sent that. what do you mean by reads? I'm a complete noob lmao

Reads as in
Who do you think is town and why?
Who do you think is mafia and why?
Do you think there are scenarios where if player X turns out to be town/not town then other player Y is more likely to be town/non town?

This is kind of the point of the game - finding out other players alignment through discussion. Eventually evil players will make an error or they force themself into a scenario where there are have to defend their teammates or lynch them.

[Eragon1329]

Hey, I had problems with admins needing to review my posts but I got it fixed now. sorry about all the delay for posting. I'm UTC+13 btw.

hey, what do you think of whats been going on in the thread?

personally I think phone is ultra sketchy, mario is just confusing but you all seem to think that chemist is scum so I might agree just based off of that entirely

~~~ plenty of in between posts

/vote phone

questionarre

1. give me your predictions on who will the 3 mafia be.
2. how active are you?
3. what is your timezone?

1. Phone, Chemist, Bodhrak
2. I have school and work some days so sorry I have a life outside of FM (therefore not too active but active enough)
3. EST (It is 10:10 pm rn and my friends want to grind on BlackDesertOnline)

I also /vote Phone (tell me if im doing this wrong). His joke seems to have gone south for him and chemist took defense? Bodhrak tried calling me and other inactives scummy (which i can see where he's coming from) but could be trying to divert attention.

Anyways ill be on and off

Wait so why do you think Phone should be lynched?

read what he's saying and tell me a reason why he shouldn't be lynched

this is what im talking about
early on, you called Ph0ne "ultra sketchy" without really giving anything else, and you left it at that.

then after posting more, you hop onto the Ph0ne wagon as one of the last 3 voters and say "why shouldn't he be lynched" without expanding on any reasons you think he should be lynched

[rightodude]

Sorry but I was asleep when you sent that. what do you mean by reads? I'm a complete noob lmao

Reads as in
Who do you think is town and why?
Who do you think is mafia and why?
Do you think there are scenarios where if player X turns out to be town/not town then other player Y is more likely to be town/non town?

This is kind of the point of the game - finding out other players alignment through discussion. Eventually evil players will make an error or they force themself into a scenario where there are have to defend their teammates or lynch them.

oh ok, thanks for the extra info. I only understood the 'what is your thinking?' part.

[Bodhrak]

Bodhrak's progression onto phone felt weird to me. He shaded the votes then proceeded to vote him?

There was already several pages as I jumped in, so I posted as I read.
In hindsight I thought the phone - mario case was townies memeing (which it btw. turned out to be) and I pointed that out.

When I voted phone he was my best scumread - as far as D1 scumreading goes.

I also definitely didn't expect phone to get hammered - when I voted there where only 2 other votes on him. I would have unvoted at L-2 had I been there in favor of a claim and more discussion time.