Jerme wrote:Both sides of the arguments have validity, causing me to feel a bit torn between both sides, which is why I retracted my vote on Rick.
/unvote
I simply do not want to cause a mylo. As I would be likely a later target causing town to lose, as I am the Citizen called Ha'anit.
Anyway back at the matter at hand:
Ender claimed TP being on Rick, yet there was no roleblock on Rick (at least Rick claimed to have slept peacefully). This could mean either that Rock's shot is fake, that Enders claim is fake (or his action did not went through), or that Rick lied about not being roleblocked having prepared his fakeclaim action already. This means, if Rick flips scum, Ender does not have to be scum, except if Ender is told, that his heal was successful. I do not if having a JOAT is common, or rather uncommon.
If Rock flips Town, we've lost. There are going to be crazy shenanigans happening if that happens because, say it with me now- I slept peacefully. I was not notified of anything that happened, and in this case it appears I should if anything did happen since we've seen people claim to be controlled and roleblocked, so it seems that people are aware of things that happen to them. Unless you're Rock, who apparently gets told that an action has failed without apparently any further explanation as to how or why.
As far as JOAT being common or not, I mean, I personally would never use one in any of my games nor have seen one be used, although I have witnessed it fakeclaimed a few times. IIRC that was normally done by the likes of Cow and Gent, so I can't really add much more on that front there.