14E - A Toast to Coolway99 and hippophant (MAFIA WIN)

[Veeena]

Ez shade win.

I'm proud of fucking over Day 2 and forcing vigilante to kill me in the night. FeelsGoodMan.

[atoonlinktothepast]

Ez shade win.

I'm proud of fucking over Day 2 and forcing vigilante to kill me in the night. FeelsGoodMan.

Who did you choose?

[Tiltedcomedian]

Mafia chat - https://discord.gg/dkVhktN
Spectators chat - https://discord.gg/PMu2MyN

Mod rant is up.

[Soulshade55r]

Ez shade win.

I'm proud of fucking over Day 2 and forcing vigilante to kill me in the night. FeelsGoodMan.

Thanks, for that I knew you were shade, you helped us a lot even if you didn't mean to.

[Rickdaily12]

I actually bothered following this game.

The moment I saw people chase others for whispering, I knew 2014 meta was long gone.

WHISPERING IS NOT SCUM META.

Just because you don't see the positive uses for it, doesn't make people scum for using it. Doesn't make people scum for trying to use it when they've never had the chance before either. And by the way, THE WHOLE POINT is to not know what was said.

I knew Town was going to rip themselves apart before Page 15. Once I saw that witch hunt, I knew things were going to go well for Scum.

It broke my heart to see how well that it did. =/

[atoonlinktothepast]

I actually bothered following this game.

The moment I saw people chase others for whispering, I knew 2014 meta was long gone.

WHISPERING IS NOT SCUM META.

Just because you don't see the positive uses for it, doesn't make people scum for using it. Doesn't make people scum for trying to use it when they've never had the chance before either. And by the way, THE WHOLE POINT is to not know what was said.

I knew Town was going to rip themselves apart before Page 15. Once I saw that witch hunt, I knew things were going to go well for Scum.

It broke my heart to see how well that it did. =/

I think it was because until someone (Arc or ender iirc) was pushing about them, a lot of them were one-sided whispers (i.e. no whisper back)

[Soulshade55r]

Do you have a spreadsheet of all the night actions?

[Rickdaily12]

How were there never Stalker Day kills, by the way? Did the Stalker really get that unlucky?

[atoonlinktothepast]

Ironic that MafiaMenace replaced Olly, the GF. Probably the easiest win, next to Chit's.

[Tiltedcomedian]

Actually, how did no one call out Soulshade for Citizen guessing Arckas??? <- just remembered

Do you have a spreadsheet of all the night actions?

How were there never Stalker Day kills, by the way? Did the Stalker really get that unlucky?

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... sp=sharing

[EvanManManMan]

Ironic that MafiaMenace replaced Olly, the GF. Probably the easiest win, next to Chit's.

That was almost me but I caught myself. I would have been in too many games, not that it would have mattered

[MafiaMenace]

Damn Game over already

[Salense]

How were there never Stalker Day kills, by the way? Did the Stalker really get that unlucky?

Really Unlucky, Stalker was hitting Jacob D3 and M4x D4

Jacob got lynched D3 before he could get stalked, and m4xie died before this

[atoonlinktothepast]

He then would have hit me, then Soul. How unlucky was that.

[Soulshade55r]

Damn Game over already

Sorry man At least you got a easy win, this game was amazing though.

[MafiaMenace]

Damn Game over already

Sorry man At least you got a easy win, this game was amazing though.

true, but I like to work for this shit tho.

[Soulshade55r]

Damn Game over already

Sorry man At least you got a easy win, this game was amazing though.

true, but I like to work for this shit tho.

Fair enough it wouldn't feel has good to win if you didn't do much but you attacking the witch ended the game because we wouldn't of known who the witch is, we could of even mistook them for the stalker and lost so your night action did play a small part in us winning

[MafiaMenace]

Damn Game over already

Sorry man At least you got a easy win, this game was amazing though.

true, but I like to work for this shit tho.

Fair enough it wouldn't feel has good to win if you didn't do much but you attacking the witch ended the game because we wouldn't of known who the witch is, we could of even mistook them for the stalker and lost so your night action did play a small part in us winning

:/

[UzayAltay]

1. HeyItsJen15? PR ?
2. M4xwell
3. xUltiix
4. Soulshade55r
5. Arckas
6. enderitem
7. UzayAltay
8. ClaudiaM25
9. atoonlinktothepast
10. The11thdoctor
11. Kosmo
12. teaser303
13. realMandingo
14. non271103
15. jacobm1122
16. Shilster
17. OllyRenard
18. Macca
19. polypies73
20. Cmitc

8-9-16-20
Soul-Arckas-teaser-Shilster-unlikely
realMan-non-Jen-Arckas- real claimed he took no PM
Shilster-Olly-SoulShade - Claudia-Fit well .

Arckas - Soul -Olly -real- Arckas ignore the fact someone else can be scared of
atoon - Claudia - Jen-Olly- atoon seems scumreading Macca , no ( unless he faked )
Olly - Shilster - atoon - Arckas - Olly seems not escort to me .

I tried hard to broke Ulti's code , but can't . Guess Poly is a citizen claim True , but he was a really citizen
Enderitem should say me Shoot Shilster directly , not via say "shoot the person whose name like shoot "
I knew I should shoot between 2 persons who defend Shade hard ( Poly and teaser ) , but choosed wrong .
Why nightskip at night 3 ? I was still thinking about night action but in case of I can't decide , I should shoot so I Posted my night action .
GG scum .
Also it is another question why Enderitem goes with a possible % 0 scum-Lynch chance .
Another question is towns activity at Day 3.

[xUltiix]

There were a lot of fuckups this game but the worst was nobody listening to me + enderitem not giving me a second best target when jacob was otherwise the lynch target
Could have actually gone positively if I was listened to there lmao

[Soulshade55r]

The Macca and Kosmo wagons were horrible honestly

[The11thdoctor]

Ez shade win.

I'm proud of fucking over Day 2 and forcing vigilante to kill me in the night. FeelsGoodMan.

Who did you choose?

I clearly stated several times that m4x was on me, not that it helped.

[xUltiix]

Ender not outing that the "escort" had tried to keep critical information from the town was also a mistake

[jacobm1122]

This just didnt go very well (╯°□°）╯︵ ┻━┻

[MaccaMania]

I think most people missed this part in my will. This was where I explained my play this game.
Spoiler: Most of you are probably going to be really surprised to see me actually flip Doctor. Granted, some of you will be pretty mad that I flipped Doctor. While I do regret most of my play this game, I still stand by that it wasn't that bad. I wanted to try and play more risky with the whisper trying to bait out the witch, but that just ended up backfiring and pushed the lynch on me. Half the people were scumreading me for not revealing the whisper earlier on while the other half were scumreading me for revealing the whisper before everyone checked in. It seemed to be a lose/lose situation. I defended myself as much as I could on this, trying to respond to nearly everyone's posts about it.

Then came Ultii revealing that he protected me, therefore a Witch couldn't visit me. Although the circumstances of me and him both being town are really unlikely, I still actually believe that he is town. His reveal early on seemed very unnecessary for scum, and I figure it's more likely to come from town. I also tried to defend myself against this, despite the fact that it was based on mechanics, and once again I was as active as I possibly could be and tried defending myself in every single way possible.

And then people accused me of being a Jester.

This was where I began to get really annoyed, and basically insulted that people thought that everything I'd done today was just a Jester act. After defending myself for one or two posts after the original accusation, I saw more people agree that I was likely a Jester, and I thought about the whole situation. Ultii had made a post earlier saying that there was no chance I was getting out of this lynch unless I had a really solid claim, which I didn't considering it was nearly a CC, and I don't think there was one person who believed I was town. People believing that I was a Jester honestly just made me give up after that. So I voted myself. I realised I might as well get it over with, because there was no way I wasn't getting lynched. I had been focusing on the game the entire day, trying to figure out how to make people believe that I was town, and all that ended up happening was people believing that my play was so bad that I had to be a Jester.

Everything I said in those 2 posts after I voted myself was pretty much entirely true, except for the part about me leaving if I wasn't lynched that day. That was mainly out of frustration, and I guarantee that I wouldn't have actually replaced out if I wasn't lynched. I wouldn't want to put someone into that position. I want to thank Moon here, because she actually PM'd me after the post and I asked if I was doing alright, and if I wanted to rant it out I could do so to her and Tilted.

I wanted to just stay off the forums for the night, but I checked and saw that people were misinterpreting my post as me claiming Jester, and I really didn't want that to be the way I was getting out of the lynch, so I made a post trying to clear everything up. After that, I actually wanted to play proper forum mafia, so I made some reads and tried analysing the thread.

I stopped playing forum mafia for about 6 months because I hated how competitive and aggressive I became when I played. I really did want this game to be different. I wanted to just relax and enjoy playing forum mafia, but that was nowhere near how it ended up turning out. I was stressed for nearly all of Day 2 and I felt that I was becoming more and more aggressive as I kept playing. After I host my FM game in a couple of weeks, I'll most likely end up leaving forum mafia again. It isn't really anything or anyone specific that happened in this game, it's just that I remembered how much I end up stressing and not really enjoying myself while playing.

I've probably lost a lot of respect from others because of my play this game, and my reputation has probably gone downhill. I never intended to offend or make anyone else feel bad this game, and I'm really sorry if I made this game not enjoyable for anyone playing, or for the hosts.

Scum played really well this game, more specifically mafia.