9E (MC) | From Bad To Norse | Detonator Wins

[ladd]

I forgot to answer this post, since I had missed it.

I will give you an example to try to explain myself better: two assassins kill two different people, one of them brags about it, while the other does not talk about it to anyone. Does this changes the fact that both killed a man? No, not really.

The same applies here.

Well, I think that the votes were just jokes anyway, because we can't lynch a person on day one.

Do you actually think that the people voting TheCow just as a joke are likely to be non-town? The way that you compare it to murder implies this to some extent.

Nope, it was just an example to make you understand what my point was.

And why do i have this itchy feeling someone is going to kill me N1 just to put a middle finger in my face... can a town protective help me? Thanks in advance.

And now i guess im gonna be a sheep and jump on the bandwagon...

/vote Elastoid

Been reading some other games to get a grasp and i realise im doing quite some stupid things. Feel like somebody is gonna think i'm scum, investigate me, i get framed and get lynched.

Ah, whatever... As long as i dont die N1 im happy as i could be.

Re reading the thread at night, I found both of these posts to be more likely to come from Town than from Scum, especially the first sentence in the first post quoted.

The awkward wording put me a bit off upon a first read, but both seem genuine.

Can someone who is able to use the ISO script compile a list of ISO?

[LordofFail]

I slept peacefully.

[Arcthurus]

I slept peacefully.
Tell me if these work and I'll add them to the OP:

Spoiler:

Elastoid
Hiphoplog
KingofEvil
Arcthurus
Sturps
Swordsworth
LordofFail
EvilDeanius
ItsmeCreature
Dota2reporter
Ladd
parkerparkour
Munchlax
Exacerbated
yauaustin202
PersianRugs
teamalex
TheCow
vorono
RetralMega

[ladd]

I slept peacefully.
Tell me if these work and I'll add them to the OP:

Spoiler:

Elastoid
Hiphoplog
KingofEvil
Arcthurus
Sturps
Swordsworth
LordofFail
EvilDeanius
ItsmeCreature
Dota2reporter
Ladd
parkerparkour
Munchlax
Exacerbated
yauaustin202
PersianRugs
teamalex
TheCow
vorono
RetralMega

They work fine for me, thanks.

[ladd]

Another thought I had during the night:

I felt like D1, due to the way it went, was the perfect opportunity for scum to gain easy Town Credit and, personally, I found the fact that it did not happen awkward; do you think this is indicative of the scum composition ( in particular Mafia, since they would be the ones more willing to expose themselves )?

Spoiler: Elastoid
Hiphoplog - Slept Peacefully.
KingOfEvil
Arcthurus - Slept Peacefully.
Sturps
Swordsworth - Dead.
LordofFail - Slept Peacefully.
EvilDeanius0 - Slept Peacefully.
ItsmeCreature
Dota2reporter - Slept Peacefully.
Ladd - Slept Peacefully.
parkerparkour
IAmAMunchlax
Exacerbated
yauaustin202
PersianRugs
teamalex
TheCow
Vorono
RetralMega

I will update this, as people check in.

[LordofFail]

Another thought I had during the night:

I felt like D1, due to the way it went, was the perfect opportunity for scum to gain easy Town Credit and, personally, I found the fact that it did not happen awkward; do you think this is indicative of the scum composition ( in particular Mafia, since they would be the ones more willing to expose themselves )?

Spoiler: Elastoid
Hiphoplog - Slept Peacefully.
KingOfEvil
Arcthurus - Slept Peacefully.
Sturps
Swordsworth - Dead.
LordofFail - Slept Peacefully.
EvilDeanius0 - Slept Peacefully.
ItsmeCreature
Dota2reporter - Slept Peacefully.
Ladd - Slept Peacefully.
parkerparkour
IAmAMunchlax
Exacerbated
yauaustin202
PersianRugs
teamalex
TheCow
Vorono
RetralMega

I will update this, as people check in.

I dont understand your argument.

Firstly, I dont really given townreads from Day 1, but that is just me
Secondly, are you using reported night results as part of your argument or are you just putting it there as a FYI?

[PersianRugs]

slept peacefully

[ladd]

Another thought I had during the night:

I felt like D1, due to the way it went, was the perfect opportunity for scum to gain easy Town Credit and, personally, I found the fact that it did not happen awkward; do you think this is indicative of the scum composition ( in particular Mafia, since they would be the ones more willing to expose themselves )?

Spoiler: Elastoid
Hiphoplog - Slept Peacefully.
KingOfEvil
Arcthurus - Slept Peacefully.
Sturps
Swordsworth - Dead.
LordofFail - Slept Peacefully.
EvilDeanius0 - Slept Peacefully.
ItsmeCreature
Dota2reporter - Slept Peacefully.
Ladd - Slept Peacefully.
parkerparkour
IAmAMunchlax
Exacerbated
yauaustin202
PersianRugs
teamalex
TheCow
Vorono
RetralMega

I will update this, as people check in.

I dont understand your argument.

Firstly, I dont really given townreads from Day 1, but that is just me
Secondly, are you using reported night results as part of your argument or are you just putting it there as a FYI?

I will try to word it better.

D1 was unusually quiet and no one was really standing out, it was the perfect chance, in my opinion, to get easy Town Credit as scum. I found the fact that no one did so strange, which is why I am asking if you think this could indicate an inexperienced mafia or a mafia composed of players that don't like to stand out, in general.

I know you don't give reads or importance to D1, but I know a lot of people on the players list, do.

Yeah, the list is completely unrelated to my argument.

[dota2reporter]

This game was so empty that I have nothing to say.
and i read the d1 several times


Is it normal?

[dota2reporter]

The ISO list works fine for me btw

[ladd]

If you have nothing to say, answer my question, Dota.

[LordofFail]

Frankly, I'm not sure the Mafia were really looking for towncred on Day 1. I think that scum simply wanted to not stand out - mix in with the crowd and stay under the radar. So I cannot really extrapolate anything of the composition of the mafia from day 1 play.

[dota2reporter]

Uhhh. I don't really scumread or townread anyone d1, and this one was especially quiet, so everyone is neutral for me right now.

(Not including me)

[Arcthurus]

From the way I see the wording, it implies a correlation between: Scum (or Mafia) not attempting to towncred = scum is composed of quieter players. Which could also be interpreted as: usually loud players are being quiet = said louder players are scum laying low.

In other words, I don't think there's much that can be gathered from D1 alone being quiet. It was the weekend, after all, so that's to be expected.

Are you asking this because you have are clueless as well, or?

[KingOfEvil]

I slept peacefully.

Will wait for everyone else to check in before speculating on possible neutral roles.

[ladd]

From the way I see the wording, it implies a correlation between: Scum (or Mafia) not attempting to towncred = scum is composed of quieter players. Which could also be interpreted as: usually loud players are being quiet = said louder players are scum laying low.

In other words, I don't think there's much that can be gathered from D1 alone being quiet. It was the weekend, after all, so that's to be expected.

Are you asking this because you have are clueless as well, or?

I am trying to make sense of that D1 and see if there is something to take away from it. Right now, besides slight town reads on Dota and Austin, I am pretty much clueless. No one has really striked me as scum, for now.

My statement was not general, it was referred to D1 of this game, in particular.

Actually I was implying the opposite, usually louder players being quiet makes me think that they are more likely to be Town, or at least not Mafia; then again, I did not consider it was the weekend. It's just an idea, I want to see people's opinion on this.

[ladd]

Anyone else having this feeling LoF's play is different?

He tends to be more active D1.

That's my feeling, I don't have a proper explanation, but is still a read.

Different in which way? You state it's a read, but I don't think you ever pointed out if you think LoF lack of activity is scum indicative or Town indicative.

LoF was normal LoF, by the way, to answer you first question. I saw nothing different from him.

[yauaustin202]

Slept Peacefully, thats about all i have right now, i'm going for reads but i dont have much.
And P/S tks 4 not killing me.

[parkerparkour]

I slept peacefully.

I like the death note being obviously related to Exa.

[ladd]

Uhhh. I don't really scumread or townread anyone d1, and this one was especially quiet, so everyone is neutral for me right now.

(Not including me)

My question was not this, though.

I would like to know if you think we can take something regarding the scum composition by the activity and posts of D1. And by scum composition, I mean skill level/experience/playstyle of the players who are scum.

I slept peacefully.

I like the death note being obviously related to Exa.

I swear it was no there before.

Anyway, yeah. I don't know if it's an awful attempt to frame Exa or a double bluff, probably the former; I don't really think Exa needs to resort to double bluffs to look Town as scum.

[ladd]

Not*

[yauaustin202]

Ladd, unrelated stuff here, but why do you have such a huge space that has nothing in it in some of your posts?

[ladd]

Ladd, unrelated stuff here, but why do you have such a huge space that has nothing in it in some of your posts?

Because I don't have a signature, probably.

[ItsmeCreature]

Slept peacefully.

Don't know why.

[ladd]

Ladd, unrelated stuff here, but why do you have such a huge space that has nothing in it in some of your posts?

Because I don't have a signature, probably.

And because my avatar is longer in vertical than it is in horizontal as well, I guess.