[Newcomer FM] NFM10 | Game Over! (Town Wins)

[Technetium]

Mel and Arc are online. How was your night?

[Technetium]

Also, going by the fact that nobody died last night, either someone was healed by a Doctor or Mafia have possibly found the Witch. (Witch in this version of FM has a shield right?)

Yes, Witch has a shield.

[Arcthurus]

Hello everyone, slept peacefully.

Didn't really see much worth commenting about over D1, so I'll not analyse there on that regard unless asked to.
No kills again- it's starting to become a common occurrence in NFM, it seems.

There are a variety of things that could've happened. Witch being hit, Escort roleblocking the right person, or a protective save (BG being hit while vesting is also a possibility - in this specific case, consider remaining quiet as the Mafia might guess you're a Witch).

[melanora]

Mel and Arc are online. How was your night?

... Just because a person is online doesn't mean anything. I was reading 8G. I appreciate your enthusiasm, but calm yourself.

I slept peacefully.

If you are a marshal or bodyguard, keep your mouth fucking shut. You slept peacefully. If you were healed, say so.

God help us if scum found the witch night one. Better hope they don't have a blackmailed.

[RetralMega]

Slept peacefully.

[Rickdaily12]

If no one was attacked, there are a few explanations:

1. Mafia hit the Witch.
2. A Mafia Killer was shooed away by a Marshal.

Guess we can also clear Tech of being the Witch, for now.

[Rickdaily12]

Oh, and I slept peacefully, in case that was needed.

(Mfw not saying anything happened to you makes people think something happened to you)

[Rickdaily12]

So, Azamelto, you told everyone yesterday that you were trying to get a feel for Forum Mafia seeing as this was your first game. 48 hours to read four pages seems rather simple enough. Were you able to get a good feel of anyone yesterday?

Anything sticking out to you about Day 1, catching your eye much?

[Rickdaily12]

(sorry for the Quadruple post)

Arc, your slot hasn't given us anything as of yet, so even if you think nothing about Day 1 was really indicative, I'd still like to hear anything you have.

[ZSSDistortion]

TheChosenOne095
ZSSDistortion - Slept peacefully
Alyxie
Azamelto - Slept peacefully
Leese
Arcthurus - Slept peacefully
YoursTruely
RetralMega - Slept peacefully
Technetium - Witched
Rickdaily12 - Slept peacefully
Melanora- Slept peacefully
HiphopLog
IAmAMunchlax

That leaves 6 people still to check in as far as I'm concerned.

[Azamelto]

So, Azamelto, you told everyone yesterday that you were trying to get a feel for Forum Mafia seeing as this was your first game. 48 hours to read four pages seems rather simple enough. Were you able to get a good feel of anyone yesterday?

Anything sticking out to you about Day 1, catching your eye much?

Apart from me seemingly being woefully under-prepared compared to some, I've no real insights yet. I'm trying to look at people and understand what they're trying to convey in their posts but nothing definitive yet, sorry.

[Leese]

inb4 Rick sends us onto the next page with 25 posts in a row

I slept peacefully.

I'm really hoping maf didn't find the witch N1... that would be a really unlucky first night, especially after NFM 8. What are the odds of that happening again so soon?

(Rhetorical... don't say 1 in 10 or w/e... I'm still jetlagged. My maths aint shit XD)

Ninja'd.

[Hiphoplog]

I slept peacefully.

I think if no one claims to have been healed or roleblocked then we should assume the Mafia found the Witch night 1.
At worst we are right and the Mafia is now able to work with the Witch. And if it's wrong then Marshal did a good job night 1, and if a Marshal did a good job night 1 it means Janitor isn't very likely rolled.

[Technetium]

6 peaceful nights, 1 Witch target, and 5 unknowns.
Fuller list of no-kill explanations:
Mafia hit Witch
Mafia hit vested BG
Mafia killer roleblocked
Target protected by Marshal or Doctor

[Rickdaily12]

Apart from me seemingly being woefully under-prepared compared to some, I've no real insights yet. I'm trying to look at people and understand what they're trying to convey in their posts but nothing definitive yet, sorry.

I'm not asking for anything definitive. Anything you bring forward helps even slightly, even if your guesses don't pan out very well. You saw me do this yesterday with Tech. I told him that something struck me off about the effort he was bringing forward, that I appreciated it for the most part, but he also seemed overzealous to the point that I was put off a little, that I don't fully understand my issues with him.

My comments to him shouldn't indicate alignment on either side. But it's now something people can have from me to read the both of us.

So Aza, all I'm really asking, I guess, is do you have any thoughts? I'm sorry if you're an introvert, I just want to form more of an idea about you than just "has no idea what's going on" now that we're in Day 2.

I think if no one claims to have been healed or roleblocked then we should assume the Mafia found the Witch night 1.

I suppose it's better that we stay pessimistic and paranoid, but surely this isn't the only answer. It is the WCS, though.

inb4 Rick sends us onto the next page with 25 posts in a row

I slept peacefully.

rip plan aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

6 peaceful nights, 1 Witch target, and 5 unknowns.
Fuller list of no-kill explanations:
Mafia hit Witch
Mafia hit vested BG
Mafia killer roleblocked
Target protected by Marshal or Doctor

No, this isn't likely. That basically means Mafia is committing suicide to a roleblock, they are forced to announce stuff like this.

And I'm not so inclined to think that if Tech was Scum, he'd reveal the controlling as Mafia. Especially if he were Mafia Killing- because that would mean the Witch was in full control of the Mafia Kill... unlikely that a Town member would not get hit during all of that.

[Technetium]

That basically means Mafia is committing suicide to a roleblock, they are forced to announce stuff like this.

What do you mean by that? I'm not sure I get what you're trying to say.

[Leese]

That basically means Mafia is committing suicide to a roleblock, they are forced to announce stuff like this.

What do you mean by that? I'm not sure I get what you're trying to say.

I'm guessing that if they didn't claim the rb, the escort would out them as it would be incredibly suspicious to lie about it by not claiming.

[Technetium]

That makes sense. It was worded strangely.

[TheChosenOne095]

Good morning everyone

I was attacked and healed, thanks doc

[Leese]

Gotta get some sleep since i'm running on 2 hours from last night and can barely keep my eyes open. If I wake up at some crazy time again, I'll check in with my thoughts. If not, I'll do it in the morning (UK time)

If you were healed or roleblocked, please speak up in the meantime. If you are a TP that successfully prevented a mafia kill, sit quietly and say nothing.... (best case scenario)

It could also be that the mafia didn't attack at all, but I don't see that being of any kind of benefit to them on the first night other than to cause speculation and confusion within the town.

Ninja'd...

Good job, doc!

[Technetium]

Well, that's that question answered. And the TP is apparently a Doctor.

(Assuming, of course, that he speaks truth. But if he wasn't attacked, he'll be counterclaimed, and if he's Witch, drawing attention like that doesn't make sense to me. So he probably is telling the truth, and is also probably a Town. On the other hand, "probably Town" doesn't equal confirmed at all.)

[YoursTruely]

I slept fine. Sorry bout yesterday the game started too quick for me to even realize that it had started then it was night 1.

[ZSSDistortion]

TheChosenOne095 - Attacked and healed
ZSSDistortion - Slept peacefully
Alyxie
Azamelto - Slept peacefully
Leese - Slept peacefully
Arcthurus - Slept peacefully
YoursTruely - Slept peacefully
RetralMega - Slept peacefully
Technetium - Witched
Rickdaily12 - Slept peacefully
Melanora- Slept peacefully
HiphopLog - Slept peacefully
IAmAMunchlax

That leaves 3 people still to check in as far as I'm concerned.

Updated with current information. Also hi YoursTruely, any opinions on anything in the game so far?

[YoursTruely]

Yes I do have I couple give me a couple minutes to type them out.

[Azamelto]

Apart from me seemingly being woefully under-prepared compared to some, I've no real insights yet. I'm trying to look at people and understand what they're trying to convey in their posts but nothing definitive yet, sorry.

I'm not asking for anything definitive. Anything you bring forward helps even slightly, even if your guesses don't pan out very well. You saw me do this yesterday with Tech. I told him that something struck me off about the effort he was bringing forward, that I appreciated it for the most part, but he also seemed overzealous to the point that I was put off a little, that I don't fully understand my issues with him.

My comments to him shouldn't indicate alignment on either side. But it's now something people can have from me to read the both of us.

So Aza, all I'm really asking, I guess, is do you have any thoughts? I'm sorry if you're an introvert, I just want to form more of an idea about you than just "has no idea what's going on" now that we're in Day 2.

Nothing that won't sound like parroting at this point, so no sorry.