SFM13: Co5 - Game Over - Town, Executioner, Phantom Win

[Kmenx]

Birdy will you really consider surviviors reads while lynching (Without the council)

[LadyAnnabelle]

as of yet, i have no reads, so i will continue to huggle my pillow.

[RHawkeye]

My Current Reads:
Spoiler:

ladd - Slight town. Trying to generate discussion, giving their opinions, making reads and backing them up well.

Anonymous0726 - Not enough content to get a proper read, nothing done so far to further town's agenda. Null town at best.

Varanus - Neutral read. Plenty of posts, but not a lot of content to further the town's agenda. Don't like that post about how trying to read people early in d2 is a waste of town.

Segaco - Not enough content to get a proper read. Has reads but isn't backing them up properly with reasons/opinions of his own. Slightly scummy.

Latewood - Not enough content to get a proper read. Hasn't really done anything to further the town's agenda. Fence-sits on Kirize. Null town at best.

Kmenx - Scummy. Sheepy reads. No scumhunting. So many posts with so little content. It's strange how he seems to accept the survivor claim as true straight away - this in particular I can't see as town behaviour. Scum read.

testaccount1234 - Slight town. They've been making a decent effort to do things that favour the town's interests, like asking questions and suggesting a vote allocation system to indicate to the Council who we think should be lynched. I really don't see this suggestion as something scum would do.

parichithay - Scummy. Accuses Kmenx of lying about his night result. Accuses moonbird of trying to deflect attention by saying he has RL stuff to take care of. Sheeps on reads and doesn't elaborate on them. Scum reads people but doesn't try to scumhunt or pressure them. Scum or VI read.

cmitc1 - Scummy. Tunnelling too hard on Kirize, which I think it opportunistic. Kirize is the only person they've tried to scumhunt and they haven't done anything else I consider pro-town. Mafia > Neutral imo.

dota2reporter - The comment asking about scumslips was really off to me. Hasn't really done anything to further the town's agenda. Neutral read.

Mindslayer - Slight town. Giving their own opinions and scumhunting. I'm liking what I'm seeing here.

Kirize12 - Leaning slight town. If they're doing what I think they're doing anyway. Likelihood of flips imo goes town>mafia>neutral. I can elaborate on this read later, but for now I'd like to leave it at that.

moonbird - Slight town. Scumhunting, giving opinions, providing reads.

birdyThePhoenix - Neutral read. On the positive, they're giving opinions, scumhunting. On the negative, most of their reads aren't backed up very well. They also have a lot of null posts.

LadyAnnabelle - Not enough content to get a proper read. Doesn't seem to be reading the thread/trying to scumhunt, so is a null town at the best. Rather defensive over having no reads early in the day. Posted reads have zero explanation to go with them. Hard claimed neutral and asked for roles to be revealed, should probably be killed. I do *not* trust this claim since they're trying to use it to deflect attention off themselves. I also don't like the appeal to mafia/neutrals in the event the claim is true. Could quite possibly flip witch.

Lokiben - Slight town. Scumhunting, providing opinions. All good so far.

murat1996 - Scummy. Claimed to be suspicious of Kirize d1, yet softed a TI with info on Varanus d2. Twice talks about Kirize possibly being a vet, after being told not to the first time. Reads lack proper backing up and are a little sheepy. Going in on Kirize again d2. Is too obvious to be an executioner...?

Jfire - Slight scum. Hardly any posts, but what they have posted has contained some things that make me suspicious. They seem to be trying to sew mistrust among townies, which I do not like, nor do I see as pro-town.

Sorry, real life got in the way for a while :<

[cmitc1]

as of yet, i have no reads, so i will continue to huggle my pillow.

do not shit post..... i seen a couple on this page, and its pointless.

[BirdyThePhoenix]

Updated ISO List

RHawkeye
ladd
Anonymous0726
Hiphoplog
Varanus
Segaco
Latewood
Kmenx
testaccount1234
parichithay
cmitc1
dota2reporter
Mindslayer
Kirize12
moonbird
BirdyThePhoenix
LadyAnnabelle
Lokiben
murat1996
Jfire

[BirdyThePhoenix]

Birdy will you really consider surviviors reads while lynching (Without the council)

If you think someone is a survivor (not sure how I feel about LadyAnnabelle though), why exactly would you lynch them? You are obviously better off lynching scum.

[BirdyThePhoenix]

Updated ISO List

RHawkeye
ladd
Anonymous0726
Hiphoplog
Varanus
Segaco
Latewood
Kmenx
testaccount1234
parichithay
cmitc1
dota2reporter
Mindslayer
Kirize12
moonbird
BirdyThePhoenix
LadyAnnabelle
Lokiben
murat1996
Jfire

Also later today or tomorrow I'll go right down this list and with a FR post.

[Latewood]

Just want to say I'm not lurking, well, I'm trying to get caught up, so yes, technically I'm lurking, but anyway.... I spent the morning reading through day one and writing reads and what not and now I'm up to page 19 and will post some final reads when I'm actually caught up. Just consider this a place holder please.

[RHawkeye]

Ugh god I'm bad at words, the last word in my read on Varanus should be time, not town.

[BirdyThePhoenix]

I never said that survivors are great and wonderful for town. I know perfectly well that they could be a scum claiming survivor. Did I saw that wasn't a possibility? No. I don't really trust her. And I don't want to attack anybody, I want to push people to say more.
Also yes it is possible that Hip is dead survivor.

[Varanus]

Ugh god I'm bad at words, the last word in my read on Varanus should be time, not town.

Don' worry about it, we all knew that's what you meant.

In other news, I'll be working on my reads now.

[BirdyThePhoenix]

Ugh god I'm bad at words, the last word in my read on Varanus should be time, not town.

Don' worry about it, we all knew that's what you meant.

In other news, I'll be working on my reads now.

Are you doing a SR post or a FR post?

[Varanus]

I said I was going to avoid it for a day or two, and that's what I did. And I was right. Accusations are indeed starting to fly. I was hoping there would be better reason for it, but I'll take what I can get.

[Jfire]

Hey guys, sorry I'm not here. I'm busy with school and stuff at the end of the semester.

By the way, I always leave my computer on an open forum tab, so yeah.

I have not read through all the thread yet.

[BirdyThePhoenix]

Hey guys, I'm on mobile, can't really contribute right now.

Again, this is useless fluff! If you don't have anything to contribute, please don't post at all.

[BirdyThePhoenix]

Hey guys, sorry I'm not here. I'm busy with school and stuff at the end of the semester.

By the way, I always leave my computer on an open forum tab, so yeah.

I have not read through all the thread yet.

Please do it as soon as possible and post at the very minimum a SR post, but a FR post would be much better.
I would like you to respond to my thoughts on you being scum.

[Mindslayer]

oh, and...... I'm just gonna ask for mass-claim, unless you REALLY don't feel like your safe..........

this is like, scum agenda right there.

>mass claim when there's a witch
>power roles ripely available to be messed up by the NE
>oooh heeelll nooooo

[BirdyThePhoenix]

Also just to let you guys know, I posted a quick tutorial on how to get rid of the Forum Snow. It makes reading threads so much easier.
viewtopic.php?f=5&t=34192

[LadyAnnabelle]

he flips out when everyone else posts fluff, and then when he does it, its fine...

[BirdyThePhoenix]

he flips out when everyone else posts fluff, and then when he does it, its fine...

I wasn't posting fluff there; I was just letting you guys know that I posted a tutorial to get rid of the forum snow as it is easier to read the thread with. Also, I am a she.

Anyways, I am heading off to bed now, I might do a check in later, but I'm not sure. I don't have as much time in the morning as I normally would have, but I'll try to do my FR post anyways.

[LadyAnnabelle]

did i hit the snooze button, or what? If everyone's asleep now, i might as well rest then :\ *yawns and goes to sleep on my pillow

[BirdyThePhoenix]

Also just to let you guys know, I posted a quick tutorial on how to get rid of the Forum Snow. It makes reading threads so much easier.
viewtopic.php?f=5&t=34192

Birdie the benevolent. All the technical posts are part of the reason I'm reading you as scum. It's an easy way to get players to trust you-- here, have a cookie, no, it has nothing to do with the fact that I have a gun in my van, no relation at all-- and it reads scum to me.

I'm not trying to get people to trust me. If people want to trust me, sure they can. I am in no way a confirmed town, and I don't want to be treated as one.

[murat1996]

Oops sorry guys, I was rather busy today and couldn't really contribute much to the conversation, but I have seen the posts regularly, just didn't have anything to say at that moment, so I apologize in advance.

Also me being taken as slight scum is totally my fault for not giving my full thoughts on certain things, such as my reads, and again I apologize.

[LadyAnnabelle]

*sleep bubble pops* oh, hey murat, glad your here, starting to think birdie may be evil, but...... meh :\

[murat1996]

*sleep bubble pops* oh, hey murat, glad your here, starting to think birdie may be evil, but...... meh :\

What does that suppose to mean? Care to share Anna?

I have noticed that Birdy has gotten a little scummy as of late, but that could be because of others putting him her in that position.