SFM13: Co5 - Game Over - Town, Executioner, Phantom Win

[testaccount1234]

i guess the nk is likely an arso, due to one mafia death. OR there is a chance somebody was saved.

There could be a Werewolf no?

I don't think Werewolf is balanced yet to be in Forum Mafia.

Also, I really don't want fluff in this game so is it alright if I ask everyone a question?

[Mindslayer]

i guess the nk is likely an arso, due to one mafia death. OR there is a chance somebody was saved.

There could be a Werewolf no?

I don't believe WW exists here.


Also, I bet that cmit was roleblocked by an escort. Looking back at his posts, I see nothing like softclaims or general town vibes that would prompt a hypothetical consort to visit them.

p-edit go for it test

[murat1996]

i guess the nk is likely an arso, due to one mafia death. OR there is a chance somebody was saved.

There could be a Werewolf no?

I don't think Werewolf is balanced yet to be in Forum Mafia.

Also, I really don't want fluff in this game so is it alright if I ask everyone a question?

Then Arsonist is POSSIBLY confirmed. Although, we haven't gotten anyone to say they were attacked and healed and/or a doused claim. This is rather confusing :/

[murat1996]

Either way, I gotta go to sleep, its 10:49 pm, I got like 2 exams tomorrow, I shouldn't be missing that.

[Jfire]

I slept peacefully

[RHawkeye]

It's too early to rule out a Serial Killer. We can speculate after everyone has checked in. It's possible someone was healed, or they were scared off by a marshal. Like half of the player list hasn't checked in.

Kirize, I'm assuming you slept peacefully since you've said nothing to suggest otherwise?]

Experimental roles are not in play.

[murat1996]

Based on the investigative results, the Stalker is NOT in play, or at least that is what I see.


Okay this time I'm going to sleep, so bye guys

[testaccount1234]

Scumread test.

I really can't at this stage because I really don't suspect anyone at this stage. I mean, no-one still stands out to me.

However, I will voice my opinions that I think the Neutral Killing isn't Arsonist at this stage. One of those main reasons is that no-one claimed doused but someone who hasn't replied about what happened to them could claim doused.

I have two questions.

1. Who do you think is the Neutral Killing? Serial Killer? Arsonist?
2. Do you think anyone is lying about what happened to them last night?

For the first two, my answers are simple. I think the Neutral Killing is Arsonist and I don't think anyone would lie at this stage. However, I want some opinions on everyone else.

EDIT: And of course several posts are made after I type this.

EDIT: And of course. It happens again!

[testaccount1234]

Kirize, I'm assuming you slept peacefully since you've said nothing to suggest otherwise?]

(fish) (fish) (fish)

Apparently asking if someone slept peacefully is role-fishing. More at five!

[Anonymous0726]

@Moonbird, there's a random mafia. I hear it has a high chance of being a mafia.

i always thought random mafia was an sk. Good to know.
ye, that slipped my mind, I really shouldn't be making accusations. meh

What?! you seriously thought Random Mafia would have a Serial Killer which is a NK?

It's a joke originating from ASG1 (I think?)

[RHawkeye]

Check ins so far:
Spoiler: RHawkeye - slept peacefully
ladd
Anonymous0726 - slept peacefully
Hiphoplog
Varanus - slept peacefully
Segaco
Latewood - slept peacefully
Kmenx
testaccount1234 - slept peacefully
parichithay
cmitc1 - role blocked
dota2reporter
Mindslayer - slept peacefully
Kirize12
moonbird - slept peacefully
birdyThePhoenix
LadyAnnabelle
Lokiben - controlled by a witch
murat1996 - slept peacefully
Jfire - slept peacefully

Cmit was probably blocked by an escort, imo. I don't think a consort would have targeted him.

Lokiben being targeted by a witch is interesting. I don't see anything particularly scummy in his results. Anyone have any thoughts on why he was targeted?

Kirize, I'm assuming you slept peacefully since you've said nothing to suggest otherwise?]

(fish) (fish) (fish)

You're hiding something then. Good to know.

[RHawkeye]

Lokiben being targeted by a witch is interesting. I don't see anything particularly scummy in his posts. Anyone have any thoughts on why he was targeted?

[Varanus]

1. Who do you think is the Neutral Killing? Serial Killer? Arsonist?
2. Do you think anyone is lying about what happened to them last night?

1: I don't particularly care, nor do we have a way of knowing until everyone has checked in. Arsonist is simply more likely.
2: With someone claiming witched, there are very few reasons for anybody left to lie. An immune target attacked by SK, or possibly another neutral doused by an arso are the only lies I can think of off the top of my head that would be useful. There's really no way we can tell if these happened though, so there's no point speculating about it.

[Anonymous0726]

A) Ignore that last post, it was caused by my weird internet not realizing there were more posts even though I had just refreshed.
B)

Kirize, I'm assuming you slept peacefully since you've said nothing to suggest otherwise?]

(fish) (fish) (fish)

Apparently asking if someone slept peacefully is role-fishing. More at five!

Really Kirize? Everyone knows that you're supposed to check in. This is NOT FISHING.

[testaccount1234]

Well Kirize is currently on the top of my scum-read list. Just say if you slept peacefully or not!

[Varanus]

Really Kirize? Everyone knows that you're supposed to check in. This is NOT FISHING.

Kirize is many things. Stupid is not one of them. I can assure you he knows perfectly well what fishing is.
I see no reason to read him as scum off of this. There is no reason for any scum to draw attention to themselves this way.

[Varanus]

Lokiben being targeted by a witch is interesting. I don't see anything particularly scummy in his posts. Anyone have any thoughts on why he was targeted?

Could be a newer player witching an older player in hopes that they'll hit an experienced scum and be able to ride in their wake.
Could be Var screwing around.
Could be someone enjoying the Var/Loki banter, assuming one is scum, and witching one of the two.
Loki's posts so far have been townie to me. Could be witch attempting to hit a semi-active town who might be vig.

Could be witch staying home and claiming to be witched.

[Kmenx]

I got doused and slept peacefully ? Wat?

[Varanus]

I got doused and slept peacefully ? Wat?

Trickster confirmed.

[Kmenx]

I got doused and slept peacefully ? Wat?

Double check your PM.

My pm says my result and

You were doused last night

You slept peacefully las night now you may post in the day chat

[Varanus]

This is on the list of things nobody has any reason to lie about. If you could convince me Iggy had a good reason not to tell us prankster is in play, I may consider changing my opinion.

[Mindslayer]

Scumread test.

I really can't at this stage because I really don't suspect anyone at this stage. I mean, no-one still stands out to me.

However, I will voice my opinions that I think the Neutral Killing isn't Arsonist at this stage. One of those main reasons is that no-one claimed doused but someone who hasn't replied about what happened to them could claim doused.

I have two questions.

1. Who do you think is the Neutral Killing? Serial Killer? Arsonist?
now that kmnex claimed doused I'm willing to bet arso. I don't believe he's lying since I see nmo reason to lie about dousings now. The question is why the fuck the arso douched him in the first place.
2. Do you think anyone is lying about what happened to them last night?
no.

For the first two, my answers are simple. I think the Neutral Killing is Arsonist and I don't think anyone would lie at this stage. However, I want some opinions on everyone else.

EDIT: And of course several posts are made after I type this.

EDIT: And of course. It happens again!

[RHawkeye]

I agree with Varanus. It makes no sense for Kmenx to post that if he's lying. Perhaps you should check with iggy that the result is correct? It's possible an arso targeted you but changed their mind, and that iggy got mixed up.

[ladd]

Good news fellas, we have a jailor, I was jailed. Bigger post coming.

[dota2reporter]

I slept peacefully.
So the answer I wanted to get from my question was "call them out, then wait till day 5 (irl) and lynch" but i forgot why i asked that lmao.

I think Kirize is a jester, like he doesnt to say results or even try to, he just sits there.

I don't think Kmenx is lying, why would he? That wouldn't help scum probably. Iggy will come and answer everything, let's just wait.