Episode VIII | Game Over (The One with the Ending)

[stellaluna]

How is that first post fishing ? Like, I don't get why Mole asked that, pretty pointless and I see it more as clutter than anything.

Pointless clutter on day 1? Better lynch him asap!

[Metrion]

Overall I don't think that's a strong basis for a scum read so Mole is still good in my books.

Maybe you should read the entire post, Mole.

I'm commenting on it because it was brought up, if you have a problem with yourself being discussed now then speak now. And are you trying to say fishing is helpful to the town, is that what you're trying to say, I don't think you are? But otherwise you're not addressing the point I made in my post; don't fish. .

I have no qualms with Dork requesting a replacement perhaps because I am a Moderator who knows the rules and am privy to the genre of Arcthurus's situation, but really things come up in real life and I know Dork isn't the kind of person to rage quit. Giving the night results seems like the most logical thing because the day flow depends on it.

I just consider it factually to be fishing. It's as simple as that.


-----


@spretznaz: any thoughts so far, I think you're a good player so I'd like to bring you into the spotlight since you haven't said much of anything yet.

[Moleland]

Overall I don't think that's a strong basis for a scum read so Mole is still good in my books.

Maybe you should read the entire post, Mole.

I'm commenting on it because it was brought up, if you have a problem with yourself being discussed now then speak now. And are you trying to say fishing is helpful to the town, is that what you're trying to say, I don't think you are? But otherwise you're not addressing the point I made in my post; don't fish. .

I did read the whole post, I just wanted to comment on it because I felt it was inaccurate.

I was not fishing. I said "I wonder if anyone originally rolled spy or agent." Not, "Did anyone role spy or agent, I wonder?"

One is a statement of how I was thinking, the other actually looking for responses.

[Metrion]

"I really would like you to respond." and "Can you please respond?"

One is a statement and the other is a question. The both aim to elcite a response.

So can your post reasonable look like it's try to get a response by wondering aloud? In my opinion and others that is a yes.

[Metrion]

"I really would like you to respond." and "Can you please respond?"

One is a statement and the other is a question. The both aim to elicit a response.

So can your post reasonably look like it's trying to get a response by wondering aloud? In my opinion and others that is a yes.

Dammit phone. Fixed some stuff.

[spretznaz]

@spretznaz: any thoughts so far, I think you're a good player so I'd like to bring you into the spotlight since you haven't said much of anything yet.

Yeah I suck for not posting, been getting a ton of crap done irl so I don't have to pull all-nighters next week. Gonna quickly catch up and give initial thoughts before I go to sleep.

[spretznaz]

That took about 5 minutes. I didn't post for a day and a half and there'sonly 2 more pages. This game's sure going places!

And here's what's even worse. I'm seeing meat from...Metrion, and Moleland. I can pretty much call everything else so far garbage white noise, and...wow, everything's terrible.

SO...anyways, literally the only thing useful that I saw come up so far was the rolefishing thing. I can say right now that 99.9 percent of the time someone's rolefished on Day 1 or 2, they were scum or me. Something to keep in mind, but I don't want to lynch based on that alone though, we have a fairly nice town buffer and I kind of want to keep it. Please post, people.

(also can we policy lynch mela )

[Moleland]

"I really would like you to respond." and "Can you please respond?"

One is a statement and the other is a question. The both aim to elicit a response.

So can your post reasonably look like it's trying to get a response by wondering aloud? In my opinion and others that is a yes.

Dammit phone. Fixed some stuff.

Did it really look like it wanted a response? I say no. But it seems we'll just have to agree to disagree on that.

[Moleland]

SO...anyways, literally the only thing useful that I saw come up so far was the rolefishing thing. I can say right now that 99.9 percent of the time someone's rolefished on Day 1 or 2, they were scum or me. Something to keep in mind, but I don't want to lynch based on that alone though, we have a fairly nice town buffer and I kind of want to keep it.

Again, if it was fishing today it was fishing yesterday as well. Why only comment on it now?

[melanora]

Yeah, this game is... all in favour of lynching me, raise your hand.

[SamuelJackson1972]

Yeah, this game is... all in favour of lynching me, raise your hand.

Sounds like something a killer would say.....

[Akame]

Yeah, this game is... all in favour of lynching me, raise your hand.

Sounds like something a killer would say.....

Or a jester.

[Akame]

Actually I would like to see what Mel claims in order to be lynched. If she claims NK/mafia I'd be down for a lynch but at the end of the day. I doubt that townie would want to get lynched at this point in the game.

[VonAntarctic]

Invenio seriously.

You started a push, and you have made up an excuse to prove your theory. I'm not blind, and I'm sure you are not too.

___________________________________________

Melanora is truly an unpredictable wildcard, to say. They haven't been much useful other than being ahead of Arcthurus in delivering ISO. Akame's question here is fine.

Spretz is commenting on others doing simply white noise while he himself hasn't told practically anything. Where do you base your assumption that everything else is white noise? Honsetly you are just swimming under radar and than you appear and blame us for not contributing, whereas I can see some more people contributing here.

I find leyva's SK supects atleast interesting. What makes you belive it is them other than the kill, wich could be done by anyone? Also you mention you haven't played with alot of people, thus you are putting them lower? It should be about what they have done this game, right?

On account on inactives, Zero doesn't contribute anything, datdownie has just made simple reads, matthew hasn't done.. anything? Please step up your game, if you are Town stop being useless.

I have noticed Metrion has been pushing on Moleland. What will you say about that, Invenio? Is it okay just because it's day 2? Or am I even not worthy of asking that question?
The fact you aren't Mafia doesn't mean you cannot be an evil role.

[Zero]

Commenting on what people posted Day 1 is pointless. Day 1 and day 2 is the time people start to get a feeling for each other. I am guessing nothing meaningful will be said until we hit day 3.

[Moleland]

Commenting on what people posted Day 1 is pointless. Day 1 and day 2 is the time people start to get a feeling for each other. I am guessing nothing meaningful will be said until we hit day 3.

I don't like the vibe your posts are giving me. What are your player reads so far?

[Moleland]

On account on inactives, Zero doesn't contribute anything, datdownie has just made simple reads, matthew hasn't done.. anything? Please step up your game, if you are Town stop being useless.

Erm... Von? Matthew is dead.

[Loominaty]

My 2 cents about the SK-discussion:
I wouldn't rule out a more experienced player going for Dizzy, just so one can say "but I would never kill such an easy mislynchtarget!". It's even possible the SK just wanted to get the safe kill off, to win through numbers, so I don't necessarly agree on that list from leyva.

@melanora:

I would policy shoot myself at this point.

Yeah, this game is... all in favour of lynching me, raise your hand.

Whats up? Anything with your rolecard you want to tell us?

Spretz is commenting on others doing simply white noise while he himself hasn't told practically anything. Where do you base your assumption that everything else is white noise? Honsetly you are just swimming under radar and than you appear and blame us for not contributing, whereas I can see some more people contributing here.

^ this
seriously Spretz you are extremely hypocritical

SO...anyways, literally the only thing useful that I saw come up so far was the rolefishing thing. I can say right now that 99.9 percent of the time someone's rolefished on Day 1 or 2, they were scum or me. Something to keep in mind, but I don't want to lynch based on that alone though, we have a fairly nice town buffer and I kind of want to keep it. Please post, people.

Ehm, no. Every game I recently played at least as many townies as scum get accused of rolefishing, since everyone is throwing that term around like crazy..

Commenting on what people posted Day 1 is pointless. Day 1 and day 2 is the time people start to get a feeling for each other. I am guessing nothing meaningful will be said until we hit day 3.

You know you can make a start by posting something other then oneliners right?

[VonAntarctic]

On account on inactives, Zero doesn't contribute anything, datdownie has just made simple reads, matthew hasn't done.. anything? Please step up your game, if you are Town stop being useless.

Erm... Von? Matthew is dead.

Whoops. Didn't mean to say matthew, meant to say Samuel.

I don't even know how could I bork that up. I knew I could switch around Neasans and Nellyfox, but I have outdone myself...

@Loom

I bet mela is joking about how everyone wants to lynch him/her after 7R. But it could mean something more, I agree.

[SamuelJackson1972]

On account on inactives, Zero doesn't contribute anything, datdownie has just made simple reads, matthew hasn't done.. anything? Please step up your game, if you are Town stop being useless.

Erm... Von? Matthew is dead.

Whoops. Didn't mean to say matthew, meant to say Samuel.

I don't even know how could I bork that up. I knew I could switch around Neasans and Nellyfox, but I have outdone myself...

@Loom

I bet mela is joking about how everyone wants to lynch him/her after 7R. But it could mean something more, I agree.

I would do something if I was given something to do that wasn't already done before.

Yeah, this game is... all in favour of lynching me, raise your hand.

Sounds like something a killer would say.....

Yeah I have nothing else.

[datdownie]

Hey, at least I admit having no posts rather than going with it. Not much I can give at the very least. I'm just waiting for a real conversation to happen.

@nelly yes I went that way, it still touches me on who you are.

@Von cannot do so, just trying to do my job.

[melanora]

Yeah, this game is... all in favour of lynching me, raise your hand.

Sounds like something a killer would say.....

Or a jester.

Or...

[Salense]

And here's what's even worse. I'm seeing meat from...Metrion, and Moleland. I can pretty much call everything else so far garbage white noise, and...wow, everything's terrible.

I'm not going to argue that there hasn't been a whole lot of discussion so far, but I'm pretty sure most of the posts in this game have not been white noise, and to be honest you haven't really done much to help either /shrug

Invenio seriously.

You started a push, and you have made up an excuse to prove your theory. I'm not blind, and I'm sure you are not too.

Yeah, that push still looked heavily faked to me, and his lack of response to anyone questioning it so far doesn't really give me any reason to doubt that.[/quote]

Melanora is truly an unpredictable wildcard, to say. They haven't been much useful other than being ahead of Arcthurus in delivering ISO. Akame's question here is fine.

I feel like this is mostly the fault of the inactivity in this game, though I do agree that she hasn't really had much of a "presence" in this game so far.

Commenting on what people posted Day 1 is pointless. Day 1 and day 2 is the time people start to get a feeling for each other. I am guessing nothing meaningful will be said until we hit day 3.

Alright, so other than this useless post, do you have any opinions on anyone at all?

Hey, at least I admit having no posts rather than going with it. Not much I can give at the very least. I'm just waiting for a real conversation to happen.

I feel like this is the problem with half of the players in this game, though it doesn't mean you should sit around being useless, you should try contributing your opinion to the conversations that are happening right rather than waiting for a good one to happen

[Moleland]

Ok. Time to put the cat amongst the pigeons. To everyone - if you could, who would you want to lynch today?

[melanora]

...

Arc I hate you. Bad juju.