ciary wrote:I disagree.
just as much as he looked it up, so could you have. since the idea of mafia is covering yourself against these things, I always have all rolecards open in a separate tab to counter these questions. I also have a default will to do something similar.
honestly, if you don't like these kind of questions, make sure ou can easily counter them. you don't have to know all rolecards by hard to do so you know
germankamikazi wrote:I specifically was jailed and the jailer asked me what the 4th word in my goal was. I was the mafioso so I had to lie and tell him I'm the vigilante and guess what that word is. After about 10 seconds (possibly looking up the vigilantes goal) he came back and said I was lying and executed me. Personally I believe this is against the spirit of the game. If he believed I was lying and executed me, fine, but to ask for specific information in a role card or useing it during a defense is against the spirit of the game. I don't believe a player should have to memorize or consult the wiki to play the game. It is about using an individuals knowledge of the roles, how they work, and what a person says as the basis of their game-play.
My personal suggestion is to make it known that asking for information specific to role cards or wills (copy and pasting wills into chat) as means of accusation or defense is against the spirit of the game and therefore should not be used in Town of Salem henceforth.
GaaraOfDaFunk wrote:As for the "copy and paste your last will" I think that is more BS than asking for role card info IMHO. I mean if you are in jail you would not have access to your last will (since last wills are generally kept in a house) so you wouldn't have it on you.
ciary wrote:I disagree.
just as much as he looked it up, so could you have. since the idea of mafia is covering yourself against these things, I always have all rolecards open in a separate tab to counter these questions. I also have a default will to do something similar.
honestly, if you don't like these kind of questions, make sure ou can easily counter them. you don't have to know all rolecards by hard to do so you know
Kia wrote:ciary wrote:I disagree.
just as much as he looked it up, so could you have. since the idea of mafia is covering yourself against these things, I always have all rolecards open in a separate tab to counter these questions. I also have a default will to do something similar.
honestly, if you don't like these kind of questions, make sure ou can easily counter them. you don't have to know all rolecards by hard to do so you know
What is to stop a person from asking for a screenshot? I honestly think if you need to use outside sources for a game on the off chance you are asked a question, then the game is broken in at least some sense.
Deathwolfgaming wrote:Kia wrote:ciary wrote:I disagree.
just as much as he looked it up, so could you have. since the idea of mafia is covering yourself against these things, I always have all rolecards open in a separate tab to counter these questions. I also have a default will to do something similar.
honestly, if you don't like these kind of questions, make sure ou can easily counter them. you don't have to know all rolecards by hard to do so you know
What is to stop a person from asking for a screenshot? I honestly think if you need to use outside sources for a game on the off chance you are asked a question, then the game is broken in at least some sense.
Because as stated in The Terms of Use you are not allowed to use screenshots for proof. Now, back to the topic at hand, you could easily look it up, true, but of course he would get suspicious of you not answering for a while. Its cheap, but still allowed. I personally don't use it, but there are that doe, and you must find out how to lie to them.
balloonhead122 wrote:Wait what? No to the wills! There is no reason why you can't write a fake one at all, just like how you can lie about your role. It is a huge part of the game and you can't just disallow it, even if you did it would still happen anyway in every game, and if anyone did get banned for it there would be complaints everywhere.
lionon wrote:btw. i usually sabotage role card reading since i hate it. if i am bad, i look it up in the docs and if i am a townie, i tell the jailor to screw himself if he wants my card read.
lionon wrote:well i say literally "I don't do role card reading".
If the jailor decides to execute me because of this it will be a lesson.
chitownmvp01 wrote:lionon wrote:well i say literally "I don't do role card reading".
If the jailor decides to execute me because of this it will be a lesson.
I usually just do it when asked and then at the end of the game I tell them it's a bad tactic. I would rather not want to risk getting executed because of disobeying the Jailor.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests