Executioner Suggestion

[goldtrotter]

I just completed a game where I was Executioner and was about to win, but my target left the game while on stand. This was very upsetting! I was basically cheated out of a win. My suggestion is if the Executioner's target is put on stand, and the target commits suicide while on stand, that should count as an Executioner victory.

[syjfwbaobfwl]

That is considered harasment, so next time remember to report them

about the suggestion, yeah it could make sense

[Descender]

this was suggested in the auto inno lynch thread
/fullsupport

[Ayame01]

Yeah, I think those who are voted up and leave should just be auto lynched. Not fair to exe, and I see no reason why it could be a bad idea. It's advantageous to town when an evil DCs. They just vote inno and vote someone else up. It could save time too by skipping the voting part/last words.

Can anyone think of a reason why this could be bad?

[Joacgroso]

This could be bad if the person on the stand was a jester, though it can be easily fixed by making the jester unable to haunt and also denying them the win. The only problem is that this would give gamethrowers the power to easily cause a misslynch. But I guess they can do it anyway, so this is fine.

[ScarfVendetta]

This could be bad if the person on the stand was a jester, though it can be easily fixed by making the jester unable to haunt and also denying them the win. The only problem is that this would give gamethrowers the power to easily cause a misslynch. But I guess they can do it anyway, so this is fine.

If I recall correctly, Jesters are already unable to haunt if they leave.

They definitely won't receive a win for their statistics. The only issue is that leaving early also prevents you from receiving a loss, which renders the W/D/L ratio inaccurate.

[Yemac]

This could be bad if the person on the stand was a jester, though it can be easily fixed by making the jester unable to haunt and also denying them the win. The only problem is that this would give gamethrowers the power to easily cause a misslynch. But I guess they can do it anyway, so this is fine.

If I recall correctly, Jesters are already unable to haunt if they leave.

They definitely won't receive a win for their statistics. The only issue is that leaving early also prevents you from receiving a loss, which renders the W/D/L ratio inaccurate.

Joacgroso, how would that be bad if the person on the stand is a jester? It doesn't auto-lynch. have you read the post? They're saying if exe's target leaves while on the stand, exe wins, even if that person get's inno'd off. If the person gets guiltied, exe wins, if they get innod, exe loses. This does nothing to increase gamethrowers or mislynches. It merely counts it a win for exe?

I don't understand where the confusion lies here.

Situation now:
Person (exe target) get's voted up
Person leaves.
Town inno's.
Exe does not get win

Situation suggested:
Person (exe target) get's voted up
Person leaves.
Town inno's.
Exe wins

[Joacgroso]

Joacgroso, how would that be bad if the person on the stand is a jester? It doesn't auto-lynch. have you read the post? They're saying if exe's target leaves while on the stand, exe wins, even if that person get's inno'd off. If the person gets guiltied, exe wins, if they get innod, exe loses. This does nothing to increase gamethrowers or mislynches. It merely counts it a win for exe?

I don't understand where the confusion lies here.

Situation now:
Person (exe target) get's voted up
Person leaves.
Town inno's.
Exe does not get win

Situation suggested:
Person (exe target) get's voted up
Person leaves.
Town inno's.
Exe wins

I was replying to this:

Yeah, I think those who are voted up and leave should just be auto lynched. Not fair to exe, and I see no reason why it could be a bad idea. It's advantageous to town when an evil DCs. They just vote inno and vote someone else up. It could save time too by skipping the voting part/last words.

Can anyone think of a reason why this could be bad?

[Yemac]

Joacgroso, how would that be bad if the person on the stand is a jester? It doesn't auto-lynch. have you read the post? They're saying if exe's target leaves while on the stand, exe wins, even if that person get's inno'd off. If the person gets guiltied, exe wins, if they get innod, exe loses. This does nothing to increase gamethrowers or mislynches. It merely counts it a win for exe?

I don't understand where the confusion lies here.

Situation now:
Person (exe target) get's voted up
Person leaves.
Town inno's.
Exe does not get win

Situation suggested:
Person (exe target) get's voted up
Person leaves.
Town inno's.
Exe wins

I was replying to this:

Yeah, I think those who are voted up and leave should just be auto lynched. Not fair to exe, and I see no reason why it could be a bad idea. It's advantageous to town when an evil DCs. They just vote inno and vote someone else up. It could save time too by skipping the voting part/last words.

Can anyone think of a reason why this could be bad?

Ah, you didn't quote, so I thought you were replying to the original post. Ignore what I said then