kubakuba007 wrote:if lynching the witch for the lols as maf is reportable under HS/H, outing all members of the mafia should be reportable as well (or whoever you are siding with). it ruins the game for an entire faction.
kyuss420 wrote:no one likes a snitch. if you know a player is witch, and they snitch as witch, out them and lynch them.
kubakuba007 wrote:if lynching the witch for the lols as maf is reportable under HS/H, outing all members of the mafia should be reportable as well (or whoever you are siding with). it ruins the game for an entire faction.
Paradox12 wrote:kubakuba007 wrote:if lynching the witch for the lols as maf is reportable under HS/H, outing all members of the mafia should be reportable as well (or whoever you are siding with). it ruins the game for an entire faction.
Imo, lynching the witch shouldn't be reportable at all, since maf doesn't need the witch to win. There is no reason why mafia shouldn't be able to lynch someone when they have majority. It's dumb that saying something like "lynch the witch so they don't get elo" can be considered HS/H, even if the witch didn't play well. You shouldn't have to explain your reasoning for lynching someone as mafia during mafia majority without it being considered a rule-break. Like, that just feels like a random rule that shouldn't even exist.
EqsyLootz wrote:kubakuba007 wrote:if lynching the witch for the lols as maf is reportable under HS/H, outing all members of the mafia should be reportable as well (or whoever you are siding with). it ruins the game for an entire faction.
Unfortunately since Witch is a lone faction in theory. They can not gamethrow by outting others.
kubakuba007 wrote:EqsyLootz wrote:kubakuba007 wrote:if lynching the witch for the lols as maf is reportable under HS/H, outing all members of the mafia should be reportable as well (or whoever you are siding with). it ruins the game for an entire faction.
Unfortunately since Witch is a lone faction in theory. They can not gamethrow by outting others.
yeah, but it's such a dick move. in my opition, it's just as bad as lynching a witch for the lols when you win as mafia.
kyuss420 wrote:Paradox12 wrote:kubakuba007 wrote:if lynching the witch for the lols as maf is reportable under HS/H, outing all members of the mafia should be reportable as well (or whoever you are siding with). it ruins the game for an entire faction.
Imo, lynching the witch shouldn't be reportable at all, since maf doesn't need the witch to win. There is no reason why mafia shouldn't be able to lynch someone when they have majority. It's dumb that saying something like "lynch the witch so they don't get elo" can be considered HS/H, even if the witch didn't play well. You shouldn't have to explain your reasoning for lynching someone as mafia during mafia majority without it being considered a rule-break. Like, that just feels like a random rule that shouldn't even exist.
I think the point is, if the game is already over.... 3 maf vs 2 town and witch, there is no reason for the mafia to waste a day hanging the witch. Game stalling is also reportable, if i remember correctly
OreCreeper wrote:kyuss420 wrote:Paradox12 wrote:kubakuba007 wrote:if lynching the witch for the lols as maf is reportable under HS/H, outing all members of the mafia should be reportable as well (or whoever you are siding with). it ruins the game for an entire faction.
Imo, lynching the witch shouldn't be reportable at all, since maf doesn't need the witch to win. There is no reason why mafia shouldn't be able to lynch someone when they have majority. It's dumb that saying something like "lynch the witch so they don't get elo" can be considered HS/H, even if the witch didn't play well. You shouldn't have to explain your reasoning for lynching someone as mafia during mafia majority without it being considered a rule-break. Like, that just feels like a random rule that shouldn't even exist.
I think the point is, if the game is already over.... 3 maf vs 2 town and witch, there is no reason for the mafia to waste a day hanging the witch. Game stalling is also reportable, if i remember correctly
I disagree, that would be intentionally doing nothing so the game doesn't end. Lynching the witch isn't game stalling because mafia is still lynching someone, and as long as they kill the 2 other townies, it shouldn't be against the rules. I feel like some aspects of the rules (such as this one) shouldn't really exist because all they do is restrict the way the game can be played. Mafia shouldn't be forced to let the witch win, nor anyone else that wins with them. The only people mafia should have to help win are themselves.
kubakuba007 wrote:OreCreeper wrote:kyuss420 wrote:Paradox12 wrote:kubakuba007 wrote:if lynching the witch for the lols as maf is reportable under HS/H, outing all members of the mafia should be reportable as well (or whoever you are siding with). it ruins the game for an entire faction.
Imo, lynching the witch shouldn't be reportable at all, since maf doesn't need the witch to win. There is no reason why mafia shouldn't be able to lynch someone when they have majority. It's dumb that saying something like "lynch the witch so they don't get elo" can be considered HS/H, even if the witch didn't play well. You shouldn't have to explain your reasoning for lynching someone as mafia during mafia majority without it being considered a rule-break. Like, that just feels like a random rule that shouldn't even exist.
I think the point is, if the game is already over.... 3 maf vs 2 town and witch, there is no reason for the mafia to waste a day hanging the witch. Game stalling is also reportable, if i remember correctly
I disagree, that would be intentionally doing nothing so the game doesn't end. Lynching the witch isn't game stalling because mafia is still lynching someone, and as long as they kill the 2 other townies, it shouldn't be against the rules. I feel like some aspects of the rules (such as this one) shouldn't really exist because all they do is restrict the way the game can be played. Mafia shouldn't be forced to let the witch win, nor anyone else that wins with them. The only people mafia should have to help win are themselves.
just imagine you helped mafia all game. you helped some get off the stand or diverted attention to another "threat". and finally, there is only one townie left to lynch. but then the mafia gives you the middle finger and lynches you for no reason. you got cheated away from your victory because of something you couldn't control. how would you feel?
Obviously that would suck, but I don't think something that happens as rarely as that should mean that mafia suddenly isn't allowed to kill the witch. The only players that the mafia have to let win are themselves, nobody else. Mafia should be free to make anyone else lose, just like town is free to deny wins from NBs, NEs, and NCs. Town can choose to make all non-townies lose, why shouldn't mafia be able to choose to make all non-mafia lose?
syjfwbaobfwl wrote:Tbh town killing witch when its imposible for them to win should be also reportable
syjfwbaobfwl wrote:Obviously that would suck, but I don't think something that happens as rarely as that should mean that mafia suddenly isn't allowed to kill the witch. The only players that the mafia have to let win are themselves, nobody else. Mafia should be free to make anyone else lose, just like town is free to deny wins from NBs, NEs, and NCs. Town can choose to make all non-townies lose, why shouldn't mafia be able to choose to make all non-mafia lose?
Tbh town killing witch when its imposible for them to win should be also reportable
Mafia should be punished for making people lose elo just for the lols (I think Favorable said that rule is only for ranked because in other modes, witch can side with more than 1 faction, but I may be wrong), its just unfair that a bunch of trolls take away your win just because they are an ass and want to make you lose
So, unless witch was bad/throwing/trying to get a solo witch win, that rule is perfectly fine
CapWarrior2 wrote:Well like leaving, anyone saying they should specifically lynch the witch should be a guilty report, atleast it would solve some of the problem. Otherwise your gonna have to deal with it, like everyone has heartbreaking with it.
OreCreeper wrote:CapWarrior2 wrote:Well like leaving, anyone saying they should specifically lynch the witch should be a guilty report, atleast it would solve some of the problem. Otherwise your gonna have to deal with it, like everyone has heartbreaking with it.
Why should mafia not be allowed to lynch someone who's not a direct part of their faction?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests