SilverCruz wrote:I think it'd be better to just stick in Ranked V3 as a non-Ranked role list. Trivial and doesn't step on anyone's precious precious Elo.
EqsyLootz wrote:You gotta explain how those roles work first
MarsGodofWar wrote:SilverCruz wrote:I think it'd be better to just stick in Ranked V3 as a non-Ranked role list. Trivial and doesn't step on anyone's precious precious Elo.
Wtf is Ranked V3? I don't understand what your last sentence has to do with anything "Trivial and doesn't step on anyone's precious precious Elo." If players are good at the game then they should be able to play more then one competive set-up without them losing all the time
There are possibilities for thousands of set-ups. Creating a list of multiple ranked set-ups (5-10) shouldn't be that much to ask for. If they want to improve their game and stop players from getting bored, then have more than one competitive set-up to allow different gameplay styles.EqsyLootz wrote:You gotta explain how those roles work first
viewtopic.php?f=14&t=116256&p=3592019#p3592019
Ezradekezra wrote:A lot of these lists only have 5 evils, which would be waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too Town-sided
SilverCruz wrote:"Creating a list of multiple ranked set-ups (5-10) shouldn't be that much to ask for.", it is if they involve roles that you made up which don't exist and haven't been tested. I am the last guy who's going to go to bat for the negligent fellows responsible for this game, but expecting a bunch of role lists that involve roles you made up before the roles that you made up have been fully considered and tested, let alone implemented in your best case scenario, to happen comes off as... naive at best, to me.
Ezradekezra wrote:Ranked should just have one mode since otherwise people would just wait until the role list that they do the best on is in play for easy elo
I'd support a rotating casual mode tho
A lot of these lists only have 5 evils, which would be waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too Town-sided
SilverCruz wrote:Frankly for a TMK setup, Godfather needs to get thrown into the garbage with Mafioso. Reinterpret it as a trait (like having the Necronomicon) that confers roleblock immunity (to keep Escorts from deadlocking, not that they're good at anything else), basic defense, and detection immunity. Assign it to a member of the Mafia, either random or based on a priority list, jumping to another one if the current Godfather goes down.
syjfwbaobfwl wrote:SilverCruz wrote:Frankly for a TMK setup, Godfather needs to get thrown into the garbage with Mafioso. Reinterpret it as a trait (like having the Necronomicon) that confers roleblock immunity (to keep Escorts from deadlocking, not that they're good at anything else), basic defense, and detection immunity. Assign it to a member of the Mafia, either random or based on a priority list, jumping to another one if the current Godfather goes down.
not really, all TMK ideas come with a mafioso and (sometimes) a GF rework
Reason why Kigirze's TMK idea wasnt completely accepted is because GF became a simple maf member with defense, and mafioso became a mafia amnesiac
Orecreeper's, Cook's and my TMK idea (the most supported ones) had in common that GF decided who kills, or who to kill, because as the leader of the mafia, they needed to have some power
viewtopic.php?f=27&t=114386&p=3566939&hilit=+TMK+poll#p3566939 if you need it
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:syjfwbaobfwl wrote:SilverCruz wrote:Frankly for a TMK setup, Godfather needs to get thrown into the garbage with Mafioso. Reinterpret it as a trait (like having the Necronomicon) that confers roleblock immunity (to keep Escorts from deadlocking, not that they're good at anything else), basic defense, and detection immunity. Assign it to a member of the Mafia, either random or based on a priority list, jumping to another one if the current Godfather goes down.
not really, all TMK ideas come with a mafioso and (sometimes) a GF rework
Reason why Kigirze's TMK idea wasnt completely accepted is because GF became a simple maf member with defense, and mafioso became a mafia amnesiac
Orecreeper's, Cook's and my TMK idea (the most supported ones) had in common that GF decided who kills, or who to kill, because as the leader of the mafia, they needed to have some power
viewtopic.php?f=27&t=114386&p=3566939&hilit=+TMK+poll#p3566939 if you need it
I hadn't noticed that thread since I don't read role ideas. I guess I can't post there now since it's necrobumping, right?
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
syjfwbaobfwl wrote:Joacgroso wrote:syjfwbaobfwl wrote:SilverCruz wrote:Frankly for a TMK setup, Godfather needs to get thrown into the garbage with Mafioso. Reinterpret it as a trait (like having the Necronomicon) that confers roleblock immunity (to keep Escorts from deadlocking, not that they're good at anything else), basic defense, and detection immunity. Assign it to a member of the Mafia, either random or based on a priority list, jumping to another one if the current Godfather goes down.
not really, all TMK ideas come with a mafioso and (sometimes) a GF rework
Reason why Kigirze's TMK idea wasnt completely accepted is because GF became a simple maf member with defense, and mafioso became a mafia amnesiac
Orecreeper's, Cook's and my TMK idea (the most supported ones) had in common that GF decided who kills, or who to kill, because as the leader of the mafia, they needed to have some power
viewtopic.php?f=27&t=114386&p=3566939&hilit=+TMK+poll#p3566939 if you need it
I hadn't noticed that thread since I don't read role ideas. I guess I can't post there now since it's necrobumping, right?
This is one of those threads that alex would want to revive, he needs as many voters as posible
rainycake wrote:I thought the same thing today. But instead of rotating, I would rather if they were random. You enter a game and you might get any of the ranked role lists.
A list with NK roles.
A list with NB roles.
A list with Vampires.
You type your name, rolls start spinning, You get SK and you are in a the town now. You look at the list, it's the list with 2 NKs and no mafia. I think they can make a lot of interesting lists.
There can a good amount of lists so we can actually see all roles while playing.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 26 guests