Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:Sheriffs would be so useless if this was implemented... But I always thought custom should have custom rules, so it's fine. I find it weird that if town guesses the role of a town member then that player will be lynched. People can still vote "inno" during a trial by saying that the accused person has an impossible role (like vampire) or a very unlikely role (like mayor). Scumreading votes will also be almost impossible.
So even though I like custom improvements, this rule doesn't exactly convince me. I think the devs should spend their time in more urgent fixes.
Dragnier wrote:The concept is interesting.
The players would be able to see what everybody voted? Ex. Player A voted player on stand is Doctor, Player B voted player on stand is Doctor, Player C voted player on stand is Serial Killer, etc. Or the individual votes will be hidden and only the final result will be revealed "Majority of players voted correctly - Player is lynched"
This could give an extra advantage to evil roles as they have a chat where they can coordinate the voting every night, to make sure they vote together.
This would also punish newbie players.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
alex1234321 wrote:Mislynches would almost never happen. Why would a Town member ever guess that someone has a Town role? Scum lynches would be harder, but mislynches would never happen as long as Town has majority unless it's the Executioner's target.
I would support an alternate voting option that is more like the FM voting. Where anyone can vote at any time of day and the first person to reach majority is automatically lynched.
Dragnier wrote:Wait, I'm a little confused. So the role voted needs to match the player's role for him to be lynched?
So let's say a player claims to be roleblocking others. Players decide to push him to the stand.
Then, for example:
People that trust him, will vote him as a Escort
People that doesn't trust him, will vote him as a Consort
If the player is Townie, mafia players will vote him as Consort. If the player is Mafia, mafia players will vote him as Escort.
I guess that if the majority votes he is a Townie role (Ex. Escort), then he won't be lynched, right?
If the majority votes he is a Evil role (Ex. Consort), then he gets lynched.
Or if the player role is guessed correctly he gets lynched, regardless if he is good or evil role? (Except for those Jester/Exec scenarios), meaning that if you believe your Escort buddy is really telling the Truth, so you need to vote him as a different role so he isn't lynched as if the majority votes Escort he dies?
I'm assuming it will be expected that the player claims his real role in the stand if he is townie. Because claiming a different role (The player is the Veteran, but claims Vigi to bait mafia) could lead him to get lynched.
If the majority of the players vote him as Veteran (he claimed that), it will be incorrect so he won't be lynched (meaning he could be a Vigi, or Mafia)
If the majority of the players vote him as Mafioso, Ambusher, etc, it will be incorrect so he won't be lynched (meaning he could be a Veteran or Vigi, or the mafia role that wasn't voted)
If the majority of the players vote him as Vigilante (he claimed Veteran), and it is correct, then the player will be lynched?
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests