Search found 29 matches

Return to: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win

Well, this was fun, but mighty confusing. I'm not used to scum reading, so I was just sort of trying to stay in the background, but was suddenly thrown into the deep end, which helped, but it also became a bit stressful. As I expected, I only started doing stuff D3 and later, with the previous days just me trying to get used to the game.

Sadly, I don't think that I would want to play another one of these, as although it was fun, it felt more like a commitment than a game. My computer breaking half way through definitely didn't help.
by Flint9
Tue Feb 26, 2019 1:36 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 6

I think that this finished before Bodhrak even woke up.
by Flint9
Mon Feb 25, 2019 3:42 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 6

It's clearly Joeshe and I have some more evidence to prove it.
1. Eragon is just trustworthy, and has greatly helped the town in many ways. If you were scum, then WP, you fooled everyone.
2. Bodhrak is trustworthy, as he tried to see why I was so focused on lynching Joeshe and Chubby, and if he was scum, he has no reason to do that, as there is a chance that I would become sus of him, so him trying to make me think would be the last thing he would want to do as scum.
Therefore it as to be Joeshe
/vote Joeshe
by Flint9
Mon Feb 25, 2019 3:41 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 5

Whoops, the website said I couldn't use the BBC codes and I didn't know what that meant, so I disabled them. /vote unvote /vote ChubbyMooshroom
by Flint9
Fri Feb 22, 2019 8:13 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 5

Bodhrak wrote:
Flint9 wrote:I want to vote Joeshe over Chubby because there was already a vote on him, and Chubby seemed more meming than anything and IK that the evil is either Joeshe or Chubby, so since it will be a 2v1 if we misslynch, I'm fine with killing one today and the other tomorrow.

How are you so sure it's either Joeshe or Chubby?

rightodude (who we know was scum) did vote Tilted/Chubby D2 when pressured and even though the wagon was dying at that point I still doubt he is voting a scumbuddy out of nowhere
Tbh if Joeshe flips town and Eragon doesn't get nightkilled, I'd have to vote him
Then again if Eragon lives I will get killed, so I won't get to vote anyway

Also Eragon kinda defending righto to not be PL is something I don't really like looking back.
Imagine how the game would have turned out if we simply had gone with that PL D2 and yes obviously that would have been pure luck, but still.

If tomorrow {Eragon, Chubby, me} are alive then it's 100% WIFOM from my pov,
I just hope it doesn't get to that and Joeshe simply flips scum


The reason why I trust both you is because chubby is acting REALLY scummy, and Joeshe is also being scummy. Because they're scummy, it's unlikely that you guys are scum.

Eragon1329 wrote:
ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:
Eragon1329 wrote:Chubby, do you think i am a good player?

actual important question.

Image


lol

ok this is scum

So, Chubby's main argument for me being scum was that I didn't die N1. Thats a terrible argument for any point of view, especially considering the fact mafia almost definitely has an agent, thus their vigilante kill N1. "Not Dying N1" is something that actually proves nothing. Then, their further argument is that im still not dead. This is also a bad argument, albeit not quite as bad. However, being worried by the fact that Im "not dead" implies thinking that i am good, or i deserve to be nightkilled by a good player.

If chubby thinks im a bad player, why would mafia kill a "bad player." over someone thats even townier and "better"

so, this being said, Chubby is 100% wolf, as his main(and still bad argument) is 100% illogical

/vote ChubbyMooshroom

@Flint/@Bodhrak/@Joeshe

CFD this over Joeshe


Sure, I'm down to lynch either one.
/vote unvote /vote ChubbyMooshroom
by Flint9
Fri Feb 22, 2019 8:11 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 5

I want to vote Joeshe over Chubby because there was already a vote on him, and Chubby seemed more meming than anything and IK that the evil is either Joeshe or Chubby, so since it will be a 2v1 if we misslynch, I'm fine with killing one today and the other tomorrow.
by Flint9
Fri Feb 22, 2019 8:00 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 5

The main reason why I'm wanting Joeshe dead fast is because we may lose our mislynch if someone makes a mistake and vote for Eragon.
by Flint9
Wed Feb 20, 2019 7:17 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 5

/vote joeshe
by Flint9
Wed Feb 20, 2019 7:15 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 5

How do you do bold again?
by Flint9
Wed Feb 20, 2019 5:34 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 5

I SP.
[/b]/vote joeshe[/b]
It's him or chubby. Both are equally likely, we have 1 mislynch, and people seem more comfortable voting joeshe, as almost everyone agrees he is scum.
by Flint9
Wed Feb 20, 2019 5:33 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 4

Bodhrak wrote:
Flint9 wrote:SP
We don't have to kill anyone yet. We still have a while. Remember, 1 mislynch and we're dead.

False.
Kears flipped Godfather, so we still have one mislynch left.
5 citizen cs 2 scum now

Oh yeah, I forgot about that.
by Flint9
Fri Feb 15, 2019 10:19 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 4

SP
We don't have to kill anyone yet. We still have a while. Remember, 1 mislynch and we're dead.
by Flint9
Fri Feb 15, 2019 1:49 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 3

Flint9 wrote:
0verki11 wrote:
Flint9 wrote:Ok, I've had enough with the 'experienced person' joining. They admitted to trying to act like a noob, but all they're doing is being scummy. I'm terrible at scum reads, but I still know to not kill the mod confirmed town. /unvote /vote chubby

nono please dont Kears is scum
/vote Kears
Finally placing my vote


Sure, /unvote /vote kears


Oh wait, I never unvoted, as I didn't put / vote before it
by Flint9
Tue Feb 12, 2019 5:03 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 3

0verki11 wrote:
Flint9 wrote:Ok, I've had enough with the 'experienced person' joining. They admitted to trying to act like a noob, but all they're doing is being scummy. I'm terrible at scum reads, but I still know to not kill the mod confirmed town. /unvote /vote chubby

nono please dont Kears is scum
/vote Kears
Finally placing my vote


Sure, /unvote /vote kears
by Flint9
Tue Feb 12, 2019 4:17 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 3

Ok, I've had enough with the 'experienced person' joining. They admitted to trying to act like a noob, but all they're doing is being scummy. I'm terrible at scum reads, but I still know to not kill the mod confirmed town. /unvote /vote chubby
by Flint9
Tue Feb 12, 2019 2:20 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 3

ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:
rightodude wrote:
ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:
Eragon1329 wrote:anyways there have been only 2 kills, the second of which was on confirmed town

I’m not sure if I should believe you or not given I haven’t read and don’t want to

Still your tone in reply was disgusting

You should probably read some D2 stuff chubby, just to get you notified about all the happenings.

Nah it’ll be fine I’m the Pog I don’t need to read


Ok, I feel off about this guy, and I feel like they are acting jestery forgetting that there isn't a jester in newbie games. They obviously don't really care about the game, as they didn't bother to read the chat, and is just trying to completely tear down what we know. Also, how was their tone in reply disgusting? Eragon was just showing that he isn't terrible at the game after you assumed they were scum just for living. 9 of us are living, does that make us all scum? If you're going to join an ongoing game, at least catch yourself up on what's going on, IK that 37 pages of text is boring to read through, but that's what you signed up for when volunteering to be a back up.
by Flint9
Mon Feb 11, 2019 4:41 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 3

Eragon1329 wrote:
Flint9 wrote:From what I've seen so far, these are my leads:

Flint: Myself, admittedly very quiet, I wouldn't be surprised if I got PLed or killed by mafia because I'm likely not going to be healed.
You wouldn't be killed by maf because if you are a town you are a mislynch opportunity(also we dont have another doctor)
RIghto: Slightly scummy, they have basically have been saying stuff everyone else has been saying and defended tilted a bit, and if they are scum, tilted is likely a scum buddy.
Bodhrak: Slightly scummy, they seem a lot more active then the rest of the newbies, suggesting that maybe they don't want to seem scummy from talking too little, and most of their main contrabutions are their leads on people, which they do often, and suggests that they are trying to seem towny. This could all be that they are a new player, and want to try to make sure that they aren't mislynched, so that's why it's only a slight scum lead.
never scumread someone for having good activity, unless its a meta, please.
Joeshe: Scummy, as they seem to be trying to explain why they aren't active so they can last late game, as people may think "They will likely be more active late game," and they have only a little more posts than me.
Kears: Scummy, as they seemed to act very, I guess mother-like to the new players like me, with their accusations it seems to be just pointing fingers at everyone, suggesting that they are trying to create chaos so mafia can live for longer. They only listed 3 people as town from their leads, being myself, Bodhrak and Over. The only person they defended is Overn If Kears is scum, Over and Bodhrak likely are to.
Aren't you scum reading like all but 3 or 4 people as well?
Over: Slighly scummy, as they seemed to be mainly saying things that others were as well.
Mario: Confirmed town, is acting really scummy, but that's prob because they're confirmed.
its just because they are Mario LOL
Tilted: Can't make reads on because they weren't really saying anything useful and they are getting replaced.
but you made reads on other people that had even less useful stuff?
Eragon: I skipped the 1st 3 pages of his ISO because this has taken me half an hour to do so far. No read, but judging by the fact that I called practically everyone else slight scum, he could easily be town, as they basically just pushed on righto and juve, and juve was meming a lot so it makes sense that he seemed scummy.

All in all, I think that it's most likely that the mafia is Kears, Bodkrak and Over.


flint gets a little bit of town points for trying to solve, but some of these are kinda meh.
(im posting in blue to make it easier to read)

but is there anything except "too much activity" to scumread bodhrak for?


My main scumread on Bod isn't anything that Bod did, but the fact that Kears found them to be towny, when everyone else they found to be towny (including myself) are already thought to be sus. The main reason why I can't scumread Tilted is because he's getting replaced.
by Flint9
Sun Feb 10, 2019 1:14 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 3

Bodhrak wrote:
Flint9 wrote:From what I've seen so far, these are my leads:

Flint: Myself, admittedly very quiet, I wouldn't be surprised if I got PLed or killed by mafia because I'm likely not going to be healed.
RIghto: Slightly scummy, they have basically have been saying stuff everyone else has been saying and defended tilted a bit, and if they are scum, tilted is likely a scum buddy.
Bodhrak: Slightly scummy, they seem a lot more active then the rest of the newbies, suggesting that maybe they don't want to seem scummy from talking too little, and most of their main contrabutions are their leads on people, which they do often, and suggests that they are trying to seem towny. This could all be that they are a new player, and want to try to make sure that they aren't mislynched, so that's why it's only a slight scum lead.
Joeshe: Scummy, as they seem to be trying to explain why they aren't active so they can last late game, as people may think "They will likely be more active late game," and they have only a little more posts than me.
Kears: Scummy, as they seemed to act very, I guess mother-like to the new players like me, with their accusations it seems to be just pointing fingers at everyone, suggesting that they are trying to create chaos so mafia can live for longer. They only listed 3 people as town from their leads, being myself, Bodhrak and Over. The only person they defended is Overn If Kears is scum, Over and Bodhrak likely are to.
Over: Slighly scummy, as they seemed to be mainly saying things that others were as well.
Mario: Confirmed town, is acting really scummy, but that's prob because they're confirmed.
Tilted: Can't make reads on because they weren't really saying anything useful and they are getting replaced.
Eragon: I skipped the 1st 3 pages of his ISO because this has taken me half an hour to do so far. No read, but judging by the fact that I called practically everyone else slight scum, he could easily be town, as they basically just pushed on righto and juve, and juve was meming a lot so it makes sense that he seemed scummy.

All in all, I think that it's most likely that the mafia is Kears, Bodkrak and Over.

One correction: All the PR are dead, noone is going to heal anybody.
And when it comes to mafia kills: The next target will obviously be Mario, due to them being confirmed. After that possibly me. Definitely noone that can be pushed to a mislynch easily.

Those reads are pretty close to mine, but the conclusion ... oh boy.
You think I'm in a team with Kears, who I scumread heavily and only want to not lynch because they lack a plausible scumteam.
And Over, who I was very much on board lynching yesterday.
Also Over who wanted to start a wagon on Kears and explained why he scumread Kears.

Nevermind, let's lynch Over then, I'm on board with that.

/vote Overki11

I'm not used to scum reading, as I'm used to playing normal ToS, where you can scum read, and then get info to back up the read and things like that, so my reads could quite easily be completely off.
by Flint9
Sat Feb 09, 2019 8:08 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 3

From what I've seen so far, these are my leads:

Flint: Myself, admittedly very quiet, I wouldn't be surprised if I got PLed or killed by mafia because I'm likely not going to be healed.
RIghto: Slightly scummy, they have basically have been saying stuff everyone else has been saying and defended tilted a bit, and if they are scum, tilted is likely a scum buddy.
Bodhrak: Slightly scummy, they seem a lot more active then the rest of the newbies, suggesting that maybe they don't want to seem scummy from talking too little, and most of their main contrabutions are their leads on people, which they do often, and suggests that they are trying to seem towny. This could all be that they are a new player, and want to try to make sure that they aren't mislynched, so that's why it's only a slight scum lead.
Joeshe: Scummy, as they seem to be trying to explain why they aren't active so they can last late game, as people may think "They will likely be more active late game," and they have only a little more posts than me.
Kears: Scummy, as they seemed to act very, I guess mother-like to the new players like me, with their accusations it seems to be just pointing fingers at everyone, suggesting that they are trying to create chaos so mafia can live for longer. They only listed 3 people as town from their leads, being myself, Bodhrak and Over. The only person they defended is Overn If Kears is scum, Over and Bodhrak likely are to.
Over: Slighly scummy, as they seemed to be mainly saying things that others were as well.
Mario: Confirmed town, is acting really scummy, but that's prob because they're confirmed.
Tilted: Can't make reads on because they weren't really saying anything useful and they are getting replaced.
Eragon: I skipped the 1st 3 pages of his ISO because this has taken me half an hour to do so far. No read, but judging by the fact that I called practically everyone else slight scum, he could easily be town, as they basically just pushed on righto and juve, and juve was meming a lot so it makes sense that he seemed scummy.

All in all, I think that it's most likely that the mafia is Kears, Bodkrak and Over.
by Flint9
Sat Feb 09, 2019 8:50 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 3

I will likely start to be a lot more active today, as it's the weekend for me
by Flint9
Sat Feb 09, 2019 12:05 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 3

MoustachioMario wrote:top is town

bottom is scum


Then why are you saying to get eragon after we lynch kears if they are town according to your reads?
by Flint9
Fri Feb 08, 2019 9:00 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 3

/vote kears

I know that I'm wagoning, but mario is confirmed town.
by Flint9
Fri Feb 08, 2019 8:52 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 3

Judging by the fact that Varunus said that the game is going poorly, some of our big leads are probably wrong, as she is suggesting that town isn't doing well.
by Flint9
Fri Feb 08, 2019 6:30 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 3

SP
by Flint9
Fri Feb 08, 2019 6:25 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Day 2

Eragon1329 wrote:
Flint9 wrote:
Kears123 wrote:
Flint9 wrote:I had nothing happen to me during night time.


That's good! Who do you think is scum/mafia and why?


I think that Tilted is scum, as he seems to be meming even after D1, and he seems to be trying to just shut down all accusations about him without good reasoning.


basically the same boat as Juve here.

tilted has been getting a lot of pressure for memeing the last page or two, and basically repeating the same thing and hopping on the wagon feels opportunistic


I mainly hoped on the wagon because I was feeling pressured to make an accusation by Kears with the "Who do you think is scum/mafia and why?", and I'm used to trying to hang with info and not just scum reads. I also, as you can tell from the prod, wasn't reading chat for a while, so I just tried to quickly think of who I thought might be sus without giving much time to think about it and read everyone's ISOs. I'm still a bit overwhelmed with all the posts, and the fact that I have to read through chat to read the posts because I'm not there in real time, so it will probably be a while before I start to actually make good scum reads.
by Flint9
Mon Feb 04, 2019 5:34 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win
Replies: 1225
Views: 75388
Next

Return to: [Newcomer FM] NFM64 | Game Over | Mafia Win