Town of Salem Game Forums

I think the Coven is fine. Yes they can't kill each night or can kill multiple times each night, but that's what makes them different from the Mafia. This is basically a Mafia faction with different roles with this change. Sorry, I don't agree.

Seems like an interesting faction. I rather like it. Cool faction bro! The creativity here is nice, the roles are nice too. Here are some things I don't like: Enforcer killing all guilty voters is kinda... much. Of coruse this creates new risks of voting an accused target, as the enforcer could doub...

A role I made a long time ago called Shapeshifter, had a lot of positive feedback. I really liked it myself. However, I feel like they were a lot of problems: Too many options Some of them were just immunities. Some of the options were a bit too powerful. Some of them were weak. I decided to redo th...

Yep that would be fine. It being neutral evil would also be kinda cool, it can join the mafia and help them a ton or if they think Mafia is straight up dead they can side with NK's. While this kinda defeats the lore of the role, it's still something.

This role is cool, but I think is weak. Having the 3rd mafia role straight is better. Here is my idea: Make it a neutral evil. That way mafia can always have 2 mafia dead before the sleeper agent joins and always have 3 active mafia. It may be swingy, but I think it would better off like that.

This buff seems great. Too bad they won't use it probably. Adds deph to the role and I love the Ret idea there.

As Jezz said this would make sense. rip my fake surv strat

Mayor can reveal so invest results don't matter that much for it. So changing it around doesn't really do much.

This has been posted many times. Personally I think it would be nice.

Seems interesting, that is all I haft to say really.

*rocket science*

*rocket science*

There is a similar role out there with the same concept. But it helps Mafia instead.

Spectre0 wrote:For Christ's sake, name it "Sentient Penis" and be done with it.

Seriously, the name doesn't matter at all. How about we talk about the ROLE?


...and the role rocks imo

Well I wana shut up about the name but people will probably keep talking about it.

*BS4125 is still salty about the name of this role not being Corriere or Gossiper and lots of people before him have said that these names are viable as this role implies that the messages has to be delivered and these names explain how the message is delivered (via a Corriere (BS4125 prefers the I...

If the devs want to keep Witch like this, they should either make it so it can't witch people 2 nights in a row or limit the controlling. Or make it so when the Witch controls someone they can't control them again for 2 nights. This would fix witch getting mass protection. However, it is probably be...

Kirize12 wrote:Oh.

The TP thing shouldn't stay IMO, it makes Protectives confirmable.

I suppose it's alright.

Well if it is removed, it will need another attribute. Maybe it will be posted publicly? It would confirm there is a Analyst, but not who it is

Edit: And then the protectives can protect from there.

What's the point of the Mafia Chat if the Mafia won't use it well? And as people said Town has a highest winrate. There for it needs to be nerfed and other factions need a buff. Mafia are a minority that know each other and are made to work together to complete their goal. Spy takes away this aspect...

Very interesting if you ask me, rather like it. The downside you gave it is very unique and balances the fact it can go through immunity and jail. Though due to this, being jailed as this role will mean lynch as saying you were attacked in Jail will not work. EDIT: Forgot the mask... Doesn't really ...

If town lynches someone because of a common claim, they are stupid. They should wait for more evidence before lynching. In this case Sheriff doesn't need to change, the community does.

This role is interesting, could kill 2 people at once, but might end up not and wasting a night. And it can sorta roleblock. Has its ups and downs. I like it very much indeed.

You want this game realistic? In that case the Mafia shouldn't exist, the Serial Killer should kill the Sheriff when interrogated, Sheirff should actually talk to their target, the Arsonists fire should spread and everyone would haft to run from town or die from smoke, Bullet Proof vests shouldn't w...

I kinda like this role, but that goal.... NO!

Not only is it hard, but it would be really annoying. Dragging out the game just seems frustrating. The goal may be interesting but still...

If this isn't a joke:
Hard counters shouldn't exist
Neutral Killings should NOT have a goal other than kill all that oppose you.
Oh and you change your alignment and become an immune confirmed Survivor?!
This role is just no...

Interesting role indeed, I rather like it. However it changing to an SK when every visiting role is dead would make this role have a low win rate as they would instead get an SK win. Unless they do the same thing with Amne. Personally I think if there are no more visit roles, the Stalker just gains ...

I hate suggesting buffs due to how much I can get dissed, but: Maybe if SK or WW get jailed and attack the Jailor, they should delete their will... This may seem overkill and buff a seemly perfect role (sk) and buff a hated role (ww) but, I think it could work. EDIT: This would also give Medium more...