Suggestion: Include Action in Report

[LiarGame]

Report ID: 147
Reported User: Stonefight (Wall O Trump)
Details:
night chat
Was Mafioso, waited to "vote" kill someone at the very last moment so we coudnt clean/forge. He did that on purpose.


We can only judge this report if we can see the Mafia Action at night (Mafioso voted to kill whom after who chat what like how it looks like in Chat Log in-game). Hence, it needs to be included at least as a Filter option.

EDIT: Referring to another topic posted "Show players who voted someone to the stand ". That is also an Action that is reflected in Chat Log in-game and not reflected in Report.

Maybe it will be good to include each player's Action in Filters eg: Wall O Trump's Action will reflect when he votes etc.

[KingLenny]

/Support. I'd mentally process these reports much faster if I wasn't guesstimating what actions people are performing. I saw in one report (it wasn't part of the actual report so I would've added it in) where a vig straight shot a mayor. People made a big fuss about it in chat and I considered adding it to the report until I realized the vig random-shot the day before the mayor wanted to reveal, so basically a lot of time spent on a false lead.

[TurdPile]

Lenny, I'm not sure how your case applied, because both vigilante kills and mayor reveals are shown in the report.

[KingLenny]

Report ID: 1842
Reported User: 2. wobniar (Fried Chicken)
Report Submitted: Mar. 27, 2016 11:41 am

Day 6, while you can see someone die to the vigilante, you can't see which vig took the shot. Although in this game there's only 1 vig (and no witch), with multiple vigs it could get confusing quick, especially if 2+ vigs die of guilt at the same time.

On a side note, D4, I can see the jailor execute Mary Eastey N3, but it only shows Mary Eastey as killed. Kind of a lesser point, although there are a couple D2 deaths that are blank too. I suspect the system isn't showing other kills when someone leaves or is afk (the D2 deaths were leavers but I don't see where Eastey left).

I'm running Safari 9.0.2 if these are browser-based bugs.

[LevinSnakesRise]

Report ID: 1842
Reported User: 2. wobniar (Fried Chicken)
Report Submitted: Mar. 27, 2016 11:41 am

Day 6, while you can see someone die to the vigilante, you can't see which vig took the shot. Although in this game there's only 1 vig (and no witch), with multiple vigs it could get confusing quick, especially if 2+ vigs die of guilt at the same time.

On a side note, D4, I can see the jailor execute Mary Eastey N3, but it only shows Mary Eastey as killed. Kind of a lesser point, although there are a couple D2 deaths that are blank too. I suspect the system isn't showing other kills when someone leaves or is afk (the D2 deaths were leavers but I don't see where Eastey left).

I'm running Safari 9.0.2 if these are browser-based bugs.

The report in question in my quoted post has been deemed Guilty.

Not all announcements of selections are made. Not a bug, but by design.

[bluewave41]

This was listed in the sticky so I figure bump this instead since it's relevant.

I just came across report #255495 and came up with evil ideas on how people could abuse the fact that forges aren't shown.

The problem stems from when mafia are promoted instead of showing their original role they're listed as mafioso2 or mafioso3 etc. This opens a bunch of terrible opportunities.

- Forge a will and fill it with hate speech
- Make sure mafioso dies and you get promoted

Even if that person mentions they got forged, a reviewer will only be able to see roles like godfather, mafioso, mafioso2 meaning they have no way to tell if there's a forger. Maybe they lied and didn't get forged to try to hide the fact that they did it, maybe they did get forged, who knows?

[LevinSnakesRise]

This all will have to be developer's doing. We can't do anything about this.