Search found 94 matches

Return to: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game

Re: Episode XV | Game over! | The Last Santa Game

I assumed that was the case even though I'm not a frequent player.
by tardispaten
Mon Apr 30, 2018 11:51 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Game over! | The Last Santa Game

ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:
tardispaten wrote:
ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:
tardispaten wrote:Also, how the heck did Zorua even guess acurately I was Mafia day 1. As a new person to an Episode, I was testing waters slightly and yet somehow the interactions I was doing was Mafia actions. I really need to learn how to play better.

Was kinda funny how when they were alive they were able to convince people to get votes on me, but when they died, the votes no longer went on me.

Fluffy as hell posts and somewhat scummy with that


What is meant by fluff anyway? I never bothered to ask anyone, but I think it might be worth asking now if I'm to improve my game.

Your posts were unnecessarily wordy, and yeah you’re on the wordier side but it was too wordy. Basically making posts appear longer but not saying anything


Not gonna lie, I've always been like this because I thought sometimes wordy might be useful. Gonna have to try and learn to cut that down then, because other FM games, sure I was almost the same, especially Cakez's game.
by tardispaten
Sun Apr 29, 2018 12:04 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Game over! | The Last Santa Game

UzayAltay wrote:Evan's signal was very good at Day 2, If there is Evan , there is signal . ( His question about Capo Retrain was the signal , because of I witched Jacob night 1. )
I guessed Tardis is mafia at Day 4 , because of Evan never go after Tardis . Chub was the only maf I can't Find , my guess was on Wabbit at 3rd Maf .

Melanora was right about me , But I didn't try to signalling . The only read which effected was Evan's read , because of I only know Evan .
I realized Jamez is probably PR , but I didn't go after Hım because of I softed I guess he is PR , which can make it Obvious I am witch .

I saw Kmenx soft , and it was Obvious Kmenx is not cit and Kmenx is probably PR , So I control Jamez to Hım . Either Jamez will die or A PR will blocked , which is Win-Win .

I think Ulti v Evan is TvS , didn't think Ulti is SK until he flipped . Good game by Ulti I think .
Controlling Jacob was Okay , I think he can be a TP who want to don't targeted early . But controlling Jamez's results on Night 2 was insane , Sherrif and Invest outed themselves because of that control , and I controlled Hım to the Kmenx ( who died same night ) , which Result only 1 RB claim . Jamez was about lynched , and mafia never suspected . ( Except Ulti v Evan , which was a Day fight between SK and Mafia . ) After that , night actions was easy , Melanora was blocked by Consort , so block Melanora Night 3 , Schultz was blocked by consort , Block Schultz Night 4 ,


First Witch Win on Episodes ! Yay ! :)


I think you guessed me as Mafia day 3 because you said originally I was a good town read, then got scummy, but then by day 4, you changed the read back to town. Was that a slight signal to me or something, because you did kinda open Witch after I asked Mel what it meant, so I had some thoughts about you being Witch.
by tardispaten
Sun Apr 29, 2018 11:52 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Game over! | The Last Santa Game

ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:
tardispaten wrote:Also, how the heck did Zorua even guess acurately I was Mafia day 1. As a new person to an Episode, I was testing waters slightly and yet somehow the interactions I was doing was Mafia actions. I really need to learn how to play better.

Was kinda funny how when they were alive they were able to convince people to get votes on me, but when they died, the votes no longer went on me.

Fluffy as hell posts and somewhat scummy with that


What is meant by fluff anyway? I never bothered to ask anyone, but I think it might be worth asking now if I'm to improve my game.
by tardispaten
Sun Apr 29, 2018 11:50 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Game over! | The Last Santa Game

lucky333123 wrote:Issue is that pretty much everyone thought I was scum so *shrugs* I should have pushed you like crazy.

I have played with you as Town before. Something just seemed odd about your playing style. It was more of a gut feeling.


Well, you played with me once or twice. Can't remember when and who's games. It was either Cakez where I was the Mayor or Moon's game. However, even then as town, to be honest, I had no clue what the actual hell I was doing. I guess I was just lucky all the time never to get lynched. But after playing the episode and playing on other sites, I've become quite confident. Maybe the act it was an episode made me feel a bit "meh". I'll see next scum game I can convince you I'm town after more practice. Hope to see you in more games that we might be in together. :D
by tardispaten
Sun Apr 29, 2018 9:34 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Game over! | The Last Santa Game

lucky333123 wrote:
tardispaten wrote:Also, how the heck did Zorua even guess acurately I was Mafia day 1. As a new person to an Episode, I was testing waters slightly and yet somehow the interactions I was doing was Mafia actions. I really need to learn how to play better.

Was kinda funny how when they were alive they were able to convince people to get votes on me, but when they died, the votes no longer went on me.



I guessed you were scum on D1 too and felt that way through the whole game.


Was there a telltale sign or something, because I thought I was fine the way I was playing and I could not see it...
by tardispaten
Sun Apr 29, 2018 9:21 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Game over! | The Last Santa Game

Probably was slightly too passive as well considering this was the first episode. I always assumed that citizens played passively, so I tried to play how I believe citizens tried to play. However, after seeing Wabbit playing aggressively, I've also learnt that as citizen, you should also try and play slightly more aggressively.

But yeah, I'll probably join some games in the future and join in more episodes to see if I can improve my games. Kinda sad I have to miss the next episode because of the win now, but gives me some more time to practice and get my game together.
by tardispaten
Sun Apr 29, 2018 9:20 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Game over! | The Last Santa Game

EvanManManMan wrote:Jacob and Tardis put effort into making posts although Tardis' late game voting patterns were scummy.


Meh, I think I could have done better to be honest. I think the reason of the late vote was because I had a feeling Wabbit would have not responded in time to the do you think Jamez is truly Consort argument so I thought I might have gotten away with it. As you said Evan, if we were opposite factions, you would more than likely have called me out there, but when you were talking about the gamethrowing situation, if I was town in this case, I would have likely countered you and start a CFD against you.

The only thing I think I struggled with was the slight content of the posts I was posting because sometimes, I would have to catch up after work or school. I really also need to try and get back into these games and pray I try and play something like Consig, Investi or Sherrif, so I can understand the investigation results more, because after a long time and even as scum, I felt like an idiot understanding about Schultz investigating Mel.
by tardispaten
Sun Apr 29, 2018 9:14 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Game over! | The Last Santa Game

Also, how the heck did Zorua even guess acurately I was Mafia day 1. As a new person to an Episode, I was testing waters slightly and yet somehow the interactions I was doing was Mafia actions. I really need to learn how to play better.

Was kinda funny how when they were alive they were able to convince people to get votes on me, but when they died, the votes no longer went on me.
by tardispaten
Sun Apr 29, 2018 1:46 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Game over! | The Last Santa Game

I actually think I said some point I thought Uzay was Witch in the Maf chat, but Mel was right. They openly witched with their reads, but their interaction in the end was somewhat townie. He fell of the rader and no one wanted to point it out.
by tardispaten
Sun Apr 29, 2018 1:36 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 4: The law in this town lies dead

Even though I have some doubts about Jamez, he is the only one that can stop Mafia if Lucky is the Witch (and Jamez is Escort) and will be able to let Schultz make an investigation. Because of this, I am willing to change my vote from Jamez and instead

/vote Lucky
by tardispaten
Sat Apr 28, 2018 8:41 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 4: The law in this town lies dead

Wabbit, I want your oponion. How likely do you believe that Jamez is town since he keeps on being witched?

As I said before, it is odd that Witch would control a roleblocking role, so do they think that Jamez can be Consort and keep blocking Schultz that way, or they just used the day 2 claim because they really think he is Escort who would be beneficial to them?
by tardispaten
Sat Apr 28, 2018 7:02 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 4: The law in this town lies dead

Also, Var saying to Wabbit that their idea that Var could only be scum if Jamez puts me off slightly. I don't think he is scum as such, but I feel like he could be a slight scum/null read to me for the moment since it doesn't look like he's putting in much effort at the moment and just make quips, but something about this makes me remember something slightly.
by tardispaten
Fri Apr 27, 2018 8:57 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 4: The law in this town lies dead

I'm questioning why Wabbit to be honest. They voice their opinions quite well and I haven't seen anything to suggest that they could be scum since they are contributing a lot, and opening discussions. I would say they would be a Town read. Not a high town read compared to Schultz, but I would read them as town nevertheless.
by tardispaten
Fri Apr 27, 2018 8:36 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 4: The law in this town lies dead

Schultz128 wrote:If you don't understand why I claimed sheriff then you haven't been reading enough Uzay


He understood why you claimed Sheriff much better than me the last day. I still thought that you checked Lucky even when you explained this so many times, and he had to say a few times that I needed to read the game properly.
by tardispaten
Thu Apr 26, 2018 2:47 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 4: The law in this town lies dead

In all fairness, neither did I believe that Schultz was a PR, especially a TI because he made a push on Mel originally saying she was Mafia and he was Sheriff, until I reread the cards and realised that Sheriff was within two Mafia results and we went through the whole discussion about people needing to read properly. However, after rereading the situation many times, especially after the four RT issue, I believed him more, and I still believe him to be TI.
by tardispaten
Thu Apr 26, 2018 9:33 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 4: The law in this town lies dead

/vote Jamez

Sorry about this Jamez, but it's for now, considering you can be the Consort roleblocking Schultz despite you being witched.

The only concern I have is why would Witch still be controlling Consort if you are one, and why have they not moved to anyone else. Again, during the day, I will be willing to change my vote, but right now, my vote will be on you.

You say Schultz could be Consig though, so he's not out of my mind, and the fact he keeps on being blocked does not help him either. You could be Escort roleblocking Consig, but Schultz is a high town read to me, and Wabbit says there could still be scum hiding in the PR claims. This is my second concern, whether there is scum hiding there or not.
by tardispaten
Thu Apr 26, 2018 2:52 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 4: The law in this town lies dead

lucky333123 wrote:
TheWabbit wrote:
ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:
TheWabbit wrote:tardis and lucky needs to be rechecked

var prob not mafia

i still don't like the way the Witch makes convenient targets if we assume jamez is legit

?

wdym

tardis and lucky are both getting unnoticed, which feels weird
varanus probably wouldn't be like this if they were mafia, considering his play at NFM46

if jamez is legit then we cannot just deny the luck witch has been getting with the controls
specifically the mela rb N2


I’ve been trying to point out for most of this game that tardis is basically going under the radar. They have went back to obscurity after the pressure stopped being put on them.

Second, I didn’t even know Mel was TI until she claimed. I believe Mel because my gut told me she was Town.

With the roleblock in Schultz, I feel like Shultz is also Town however if Jamez was really witched, witch could possibly still not know who mafia is.


But then why would Witch control a Mafia member since they sort of need to work together? Witch only needs to listen to the conversation we are currently making and then control people to determine what they could be based on their results. In this case, Witch may think that Jamez is Escort/Consort, so they are still controlling him to make sure that Schultz cannot find them and scum since they win together. Isn't that the point as well that Witch should not know who Mafia is, and has to control everyone to try and figure out who the Mafia is, try and control people like TKs into killing town and try and determine who their "associates" are?

I think Jamez could be town, but Witch is targeting him to make it impossible for Schultz to find out the other Mafia members. However, he could still be Consort, but he's still being controlled to make sure that Schultz still cannot find the scum team.
by tardispaten
Wed Apr 25, 2018 11:48 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 4: The law in this town lies dead

TheWabbit wrote:
Jamezbeast wrote:
Soulshade55r wrote:6 v 4 isn't really amazing honestly
I'd Jamez claims to be Escort, yet he went to block Schultz seems like a consort'y kind of play because even if Schultz was consig it would be way more important trying to block a killing mafia.
Consig normally wouldn't kill because it's useful.

Jamez please tell me who you blocked on each night now.

N1, Varanus. I was not confident in reading them and thought they hadn't done anything particularly town motivated but would also be likely to make the kill for scum seeing as they were mostly townread.

N2, attempted Soul. I was going to WIFOM between blocking Soul and blocking someone else (namely Wabbit, strongest scumread at the time) but after Kmnex post, I decided to go for Soul. I was then witched, assuming onto Mel.

N3, attempted Wabbit. Again, strongest scumread that's not a PR claim. Witched again, assuming onto Schultz.

And it's obvious Soul shot Olly btw.

Any thoughts as to why Kmenx didn't shoot?


Probably wanted to make sure he was able to shoot scum 100% without losing his bullets. As well as this, he likely decided to stay quiet to make sure he was not witched to shooting town.

But hang on... I just had a thought. Why did Witch not control Soul since he claimed TK? Maybe as he said, if he was Vet, he was baiting the Witch. I had Vig vibes though because if I was Vet, I wouldn't bait by saying "I may might be baiting".
by tardispaten
Wed Apr 25, 2018 11:12 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 4: The law in this town lies dead

TheWabbit wrote:
Schultz128 wrote:But how is Soul confirmed

not actually confirmed


What do you mean not actually confirmed right now? What Schultz and Evan has discussed suggest why Soul could be the Vig that killed Olly and Kmenx is because if Soul had bullets left, wouldn't he have more likely been controlled by the Witch to kill someone? Or am I misunderstanding what has been said?
by tardispaten
Wed Apr 25, 2018 9:08 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 4: The law in this town lies dead

TheWabbit wrote:there are only 3 PR claimants:

Schutlz
Jamez
Soul

3 PR slots are left. There's a maximum of 1 scum here. The scum would be Mafia.
I'm going to review the night results that were claimed.


Slept peacefully.

Why is there a maximum of one Mafia out of all thesr claims? I thought the issue was resolved with the lynch of Ulti as the fake claimer. Or is it relating back to the consort talk we made last night.

Also looking back, I can see no one climed witched day 2, but I thought this was because we were avoiding hypoclaiming. Or was that only if there was an Arsonist?
by tardispaten
Wed Apr 25, 2018 8:57 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 3: Oh dear

Not sure if my vote was counted looking at vote count so I'll

/vote ulti again
by tardispaten
Mon Apr 23, 2018 12:15 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 3: Oh dear

I had a thought about a potential person who could be SK. I think they changed on my reads from scum to null. I was thinking Uzay because we thought he was open witching based on his reads. Although he hasn't been as active now, from what I read, he's motivated, but not too motivated. You guys can say I'm wrong if you want, but ot links with safe kills and trying to stay under the rader.

I still think SK is hiding in one of the RT claims though.
by tardispaten
Sun Apr 22, 2018 3:42 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 3: Oh dear

Jamezbeast wrote:
xUltiix wrote:/vote Evan

This is not gonna happen. Evan is being townread by both TI claims and one of those is guaranteed to be town, therefore this lynch is impossible without a scumvote on it.

Comfortable with voting Wabbit or Schultz.


We also know with Schultz, a lynch on him is not going to happen. This is going to end up in a full circle of you, Schultz or ultii.
by tardispaten
Sun Apr 22, 2018 1:49 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982

Re: Episode XV | Day 3: Oh dear

/vote Ultii

I just don't know anymore, but he's been putting me off slightly. It took him a long time to make his claim of TP after he claimed RT. Out of all the rt claims, this bugs me the most. I believe Schultz to be the rt investigator and Mel is also undoubtedly Sherrif. However, the three rt claims really bugs me the most. I can see some town motivation from Jamez, which makes me think he could be town, but at the same time, could be consort. Aould, I still not too convinced on his tk claim, but I'm following Jamez's meta on Soul for now (do not let us down with this Jamez. This is about the only town motivated thing I have seen you done to be honest while the day 2 claim made me feel uneasy).

I feel like Ulti might be the beneficial lynch today rather than Jamez. If he ends up blocking Schultz or Mel, and they tell us, then he is most likely consort. With Schultz check on him, it isn't that good, since he could be escort as well. I'm willing to make Jamez a snull/slight town on my reads now.
by tardispaten
Sun Apr 22, 2018 12:38 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game
Replies: 3425
Views: 328982
Next

Return to: Episode XV | Game over! | Mafia/Witch WIN | Last Santa Game