Town of Salem Game Forums

roz1roz wrote:Watt, why would you even reveal here?

It's not like it's likely there is any BG/Marshall left, especialy looking at the current claims. (Please, noone out themself saying they are Tps alive)
It's more like... I ask out of curiosity. What did you gain from that reveal?

ElusiveBelle wrote:

Watt2015 wrote:
Point being here, if the claim is BS, then we have tomorrows lynch. Plus I'm not feeling a Townie vibe off of Soul.

That's entirely missing the point of my post to not take the risk, negating the fact of reads or vibes town has no reason not to let it self resolve.
If we're wrong we're setting ourselves back and losing a TK, while in this case we wont lose the TK unless mafia kill them and we still have a scum die without wasting a lynch.

Also yes immunity wouldn't be overridden by prankster. That's not how it works.
Whether or not you slept peacefully would as well as other things such as roleblocked or transported.
But if you shot someone and got pranked that you slept peacefully, if they were immune you would still be told so.
If I am not mistaken healings show up as immune anyways no? If that was the case there would be no reason not to get the results as them alive the next day would prove it anyways.

ElusiveBelle wrote:

Watt2015 wrote:I'm pretty set on Soul. I see no reason to doubt the Tracker claim, except for the possibility that it could be a Consig on the other Mafia.

Tracker claim is the easiest to fake, all you say is, "Oh this person killed them."
There is no actual information of use there other than the claim. It's actually weaker than a sheriff red claim which can be just as bad.

Although mafia outing the other mafia this early is up for debate. With both sides down a number throwing the other side under the bus isn't the wisest move, not unheard of but still unwise. Mafia are looking for mislynches here which is why we need to take as little risks as possible to not give them that.

Kmenx wrote:

Watt2015 wrote:I'm pretty set on Soul. I see no reason to doubt the Tracker claim, except for the possibility that it could be a Consig on the other Mafia.

Consig wouldn't have known he made the kill which could cause a revenge outing from Soul

I really doubt they'd risk it

roz1roz wrote:

Watt2015 wrote:

Schultz128 wrote:If the Firebrand is real then they're igniting because scum is definitely in the RT and Citizen pools.

Soul is definitely scum.

I don't think an actual Firebrand exists. I personally thinks it's a Prankster.

With the other RTs I'd say the scum pool is [ladd, Shilster, Elusive, Kmenx]

I also know of a role no one knows about that definitely exists her ^_^

Glad someone else feels the same

Ps- I’m a cit

Lol, that claim.

Remember that prankster can't use same prank twice in a row.
And so far we had 2 "douses", meaning that 2nd would be mafia covering for a 1 night break.

I rather think that firebrand exists, but mafia are trying to discredit them by saying it could be prankster. (?)
That would be cool theory if it wasn't mayor with vet who are saying so.

Schultz128 wrote:If the Firebrand is real then they're igniting because scum is definitely in the RT and Citizen pools.

Soul is definitely scum.

I don't think an actual Firebrand exists. I personally thinks it's a Prankster.

With the other RTs I'd say the scum pool is [ladd, Shilster, Elusive, Kmenx]

I also know of a role no one knows about that definitely exists her ^_^

Shilster wrote:Random shil post

OctoOoze wrote:hardclaim tracker that saw soul visit andilin

OctoOoze wrote:

Soulshade55r wrote:What read lol? wtf. Could you explain these "Reads" because so far they haven't worked out well.

red
red means i have a guilty
which means you're mafia

timurtheking wrote:I am citizen

ElusiveBelle wrote:

ElusiveBelle wrote:Woo finally something to go, James and Gent are different.
Get em bois, I'd want to say they're both scum but its probably just one which makes me sad.

It seems this was missed or misunderstood,
I am Detektiv. Olly/Gent and James are different

kosmo16 wrote:I will give us some clues then...

I am Politzei and tovarishes OctoOoze and leyva45 are not suspicious

Soulshade55r wrote:

Schultz128 wrote:/vote timur

Just asking (I know your town) what is your reason?

Asew54321 wrote:Okay Watt as our president I expect you to hardcarry the Town to victory. Don't mess up please. Thanks.

Asew54321 wrote:Updated role list™:

President (James apparently)
City Investigative
Officer (Lemonader)
Psychic (andilin)
Trapper (Schultz)
Pyromaniac (???)
Random City (Gulag Admin?)
Random City (Hooker?)
Random City
Random City
Random City
Resident (Me)
Resident (Murat)
Resident (Roz)
Resident

Sicilian Mafia Head (Underboss?)
Blackmailer (Micheal)
Sicilian Mafia Random (Prostitutka?)
Sicilian Mafia Random

Russian Mob Head (Corrupt Gulag Admin?)
Boevik (Seno)
Russian Mob Random (Consort?)
Russian Mob Random

Neutral Evil
Neutral Benign
Neutral Non Killing

Asew54321 wrote:Question 1: Why was andilin killed by any Mafia?
Question 2: Why was andilin killed by both Mafias?
Question 3: Where is moonbird?

Varanus wrote:

xUltiix wrote:ToroPicana has been prodded

oh no