Town of Salem Game Forums

melanora wrote:So basically, fuck this game.

TrueGent wrote:

TheCow wrote:I want to see a VC so I have a better idea of where people stand. I'm hoping Arc will give us another extension, too. If you think that's stalling, you can go shitpost in the lounge.

we dont need an extension cus you are confirmed scum lol

Kmenx wrote:

Varanus wrote:

Kmenx wrote: or at least he is not the sheriff he claims

Can you explain what you mean by this?

Not right now but I ll explain it later Let s say i know something cow is scummy af there is no reason for me to reveal stuff at least

@Rhazh Forgotten s slot

RhazhBash wrote:Ok which slot did you replace into again Kmenx?

Kmenx wrote:/Vote Cow and Ronit


Cow is so chaotic in this game like in everygame he got found as scum or forced to make claim as one


And he is definately not the sheriff or at least he is not the sheriff he claims

CJBlack44 wrote:Post no 1 - using RNG to make reads when you have a CONFIRMED SCUM

Spoiler:

TheCow wrote:
Well, RNG has spoken.

parkerparkour
Lots of D1 joking. Makes a post regarding game philosophy. Scum reads Downie, cite: [deflective]. Extensive joking with Salte. Criticizes meta defenses (regarding k1ll->downie [NAI]). Implies downie is Policy potential. Cites apathy as "[scum freelo]". Waves k1ll's [buzzword] assertion. Post scumreading downsforget, shading k1ll, insulting salte. Retracts downie scumread? Implies it's a policy. Also states that Laima's defence of downie is solid (I think Laima's post is regarding downie. Hard to tell since only pronouns are used and there isn't much context to be gained). Tells downie to "modkill himself", cite: [retardation]. Calls downie a "[scumread]" and "ML" in the same breath.

Town {Nothing state}
Scum {downie/forgotten}
Notable {Salte , Cowtrion , k1ll/Exa}

Conclusion: parker has a very closed focus this game with the majority of her interactions being with those under "notable". Inexplicably answer's metrion's rhetorical question early on.



IAmAMunchlax
Complains about Salte slot "shit posting". (note: he then proceeds to post 13 times, though there is not enough content to be added here. Compare and contrast.) Says he sees CJ "lurking but not posting". Says downie is apathetic and/or lethargic. Says Cow's reason of forgot being scum is "bad" and forgot "hasn't done anything scummy in [his] books". Reads downie as town. Believes Obinora visited k1ll/exa. Defends against CJ in this post. Says "they" (presumably salte) were "shitting up the thread" and he "told them to stop and actually participate" (I cannot find quotes affirming this assertion aside from this. The fact that CJ accepts is dubious). He says downie "comes of (sic) as scum " but that he never said downie was scum explicitly. Waves CJ's shade (from my PoV CJ is throwing shade here, saying that the post came from an "anti-town mindset". Meanwhile, Munch is strawmanning CJ on his second point. NAI, poor play from both.) Here Munch defends the view [downie is scum with a scummy attitude]

Town {downie/forgotten}
Scum {Nothing stated}
Notable {Salte , CJ/Rhazh}

Conclusion: Munch's filter is padded by extra needless posts, however he is pushing the pro-downie agenda. Repels CJ's prodding in what appears to be an organic manner. Likely not taking detailed notes or rereading based on a few minor lapses and contradictions.


Upshot: There appear to be large and notable contradictions between the two heads of this hydra. Compare and contrast these two posts. This post for context. Ultimately giving this slot a townlean based on the above and because their agenda appears protown straightforward.

Note: I haven't contacted met about this since he's still sleeping.

POST 2 - fencesits on us by null reading us, even though we have A TON of alignment-indicative posts

Spoiler:

TheCow wrote:RhazhBash
Rhazh makes a metaread on iEs based on [SK!SirCakez, 8B -- Post?]. Post cum reading Cowtrion slot, cite: scum!met>scum!cow, met lead head, therefore scum. [Rhazh/CJ -> cowtrion , for/down , iesAFK | S] for/down - "You can tell that his reactions are clearly not Town reactions". iEsAFK - "I don't like how he comes in asking people to start discussion instead of starting it himself...He's acting like SirCakez in 8B, but scummier." Here he says this post has "town intentions". Here he implies Exa is contradicting himself on [ies] , [dom]. Criticize his push, cite: [appeal to dead townie]. Defends Dom's post countering "doubtcast argument, waves. Associative read [k1ll/exa+ies]. Asks if people read Dom as Scum or NewTown, read: newtown.

Town {Dom/Tyrone}
Scum {Cowtrion , forgot/downie , iEs/Hurri , Exa/k1ll}
Notable {Dom/Tyrone , iEs/Hurri}

Conclusion: Reads remain constant throughout the game. Does not cite reasons on the majority of the reads. Counters exa's reads with an inverted read. Making associative reads.



CJBlack

Immediately leave joking phase. Preemptively wave lurking accusations. Declares Rhazh main-head. Criticize k1ll for [town reading downie] after 3-4 posts. Counters wave with pressure. Settles soon thereafter. Reverse BoP k1ll, pokes Met for downie/forgot read and k1ll for "anyone striking [her] as scummy" in this post. (link) Counters met, defending Milte. Feels that forgotten is scummier than downie and questions the downie focus. Shades forgotten. k1ll/exa read: void , cowtrion read: agreement (scum). Cite: "day 1 ... Cow was being scummy while metrion was ... pro-town... i re-read ... and to be honest, metrion doesn't look so protown to me anymore. Claims to not have defended milte but rather was attacking met. Claims to not have fence sat downie, cite: "I clearly said that I found the downie/forgotten pairing scummy". (long post, cutting things down for this overview) This post: affirm met read, cowtrion scum read. Claims associations with cowtrion/parklax. Top-town RVS/AtE cite: [on topic, succint(sic), not defensive/cautions. Implies aggression retracts from [townreads]. Here calls munch hypocritical, nulls dom, fences the acknowledging RVS but nulling. Here he presses Munch's wave. Here he poses topic questions. Affirms downie/forgotten scum read, no intent to push. Further prods downie.

Town {Nothing stated}
Scum {Cowtrion , forgot/downie}
Notable {RVS/AtE}

Conclusion: Reads remain constant throughout the game. Posts are needlessly bulky, NAI but poor play (imo). Buddying RVS/AtE slot, read sharing. Multiple reiterations.


Upshot: Slot seems to be coordinating though are having difficulties presenting their arguments in both concise and consistent manners. Both halves are showing traits that are NAI but are indicative of annoying play in general, which I highly dislike. Null reading the slot, marking it inconsequential.

POST 3 - scummiest post ever for obvious reasons: no reasoning provided, "don't care if it's a mislynch"
Spoiler:

TheCow wrote:/vote CJRhazh

They're scummy and even if its a mislynch, at least rhazh will shut up.

POST 4 - AGAIN makes accusations with no backup. Calls Exa\K1ll SK even though they supposedly showed up as Mafia. I'm not buying that bullshit about the reverse whatever shit.

Spoiler:

TheCow wrote:Cy you fucker you should have joined with me

Exa is GF and CJRhazh are shitty SK?

And these are ALL on the same page - I haven't even gone on the next page because I don't want to waste my time. I grabbed the first 4 that I found - and trust me, I didn't have to look too hard. If you want more, just open Cow's ISO lol.

RhazhBash wrote:

TheCow wrote:

RhazhBash wrote:Current scum predictions:

Mafia is Varanus/Cow/Swordsworth

NK is Exacerbated

Subject to change depending on Cow's flip. (In the .00001% chance he's Town)

So from your PoV, lynching Mafia is better than lynching the NK? k.

You're 100% confirmed scum in my eyes, and a safer lynch than Exa. Plus we would get more information from your flip than his anyways.

RhazhBash wrote:Current scum predictions:

Mafia is Varanus/Cow/Swordsworth

NK is Exacerbated

Subject to change depending on Cow's flip. (In the .00001% chance he's Town)

K1llthestory wrote:Varanus, when Cow flips scum, is a scumbuddy of Cow. I say that also with a bit of certainty because of their interactions, and Varanus was scummy when he replaced in.

CJBlack44 wrote:

ronit wrote:True, don't sheep, think by yourself and actually do something instead of wading in exa's and k1lls shadow.
Cj your mission should you choose to accept it is find one of those 10 posts

Because you're too lazy to? Fine. Hold on 5 mins.

@Rhazh: this is the only time I'll ever 100% agree with an early vote. I couldn't agree more. Cownit's posts are 100% bullshit. There is a small chance that Cow is Town - or rather, there was. But there is NO chance whatsoever that Cow is Sheriff.

@Cyantic: so you admit that K1ll hasn't scumslipped, yet the fact that Cow is trying to push this false idea into people's heads doesn't bother you at all. Okay. Seems legit.

K1llthestory wrote:It's impossible for me to see Cow as town at this point Alouv

K1llthestory wrote:I'm not sure why Exas pushing so hard, but I'm sure we were just being confident town Rhazh? Unless I didn't read correctly, we never said that?

K1llthestory wrote:

TheCow wrote:Rhazh, are you a sheriff?

Not a townie post

K1llthestory wrote:

TheCow wrote:

K1llthestory wrote:the crumb in itself doesn't matter but exa's using it to solidify out case in the sense that I said there were two prots when there was only the possibility of one being taken into account at the time. Now, we're discussing our role, and since we didn't claim marshal but doctor, that makes us a second prot. in theory, if that line wasn't rehearsed then our claim would become that much stronger

K1llthestory wrote:well the theory that marshall had protected someone had arose, and I assumed that since mela's kill had failed it meant that there was another protective who was most likely a marshal which lead me to believe there were two prots

Where I'm getting the slip from are these two posts referring to the claim.

That's not a slip

K1llthestory wrote:the crumb in itself doesn't matter but exa's using it to solidify out case in the sense that I said there were two prots when there was only the possibility of one being taken into account at the time. Now, we're discussing our role, and since we didn't claim marshal but doctor, that makes us a second prot. in theory, if that line wasn't rehearsed then our claim would become that much stronger

K1llthestory wrote:well the theory that marshall had protected someone had arose, and I assumed that since mela's kill had failed it meant that there was another protective who was most likely a marshal which lead me to believe there were two prots

K1llthestory wrote:Disregard any argument of our crumb, we influenced our arguments too heavily with them, but Cow has still done much worse in regards to scumminess